littlepeasoup
Full Member
If we sign him I could see him playing more games in the Europa League than in the Prem. Would be a brilliant way to blood youngsters who haven't taken part in big(ish) European competitions.
We should wait for someone else in the EPL to sign him, then sign him the next year for 50m
If they're better than him, they will play ahead of him.Sarcasm duly noted, but there's nothing to suggest he's some amazing prospect, he's a 21 year old who's only played lower level football and has a couple of caps, nearly every "highlight" of him is just him running really fast, I don't see much else there and we already have 3 of our own kids that we could give game time to instead of wasting a signing on a championship player. He looks like a the dated English kick and run merchant, he plays the same way as Rashford on the wing.
LFC fan? No chance he'll come here then.
So he didn't know that every youth player he was signing were destined to excel.
There's a risk with every young player with potential.
Sarcasm duly noted, but there's nothing to suggest he's some amazing prospect, he's a 21 year old who's only played lower level football and has a couple of caps, nearly every "highlight" of him is just him running really fast, I don't see much else there and we already have 3 of our own kids that we could give game time to instead of wasting a signing on a championship player. He looks like a the dated English kick and run merchant, he plays the same way as Rashford on the wing.
Well Alli came from lower than the Championship and he did ok.
Shaw? One of our best dribblers and joint 2nd most throughballs with Mata. Plus a very good defender compared to most Leftbacks. The rest sure. But if you have luxury players who dont do the job without the ball then it creates a much bigger job for the hard workers to do.
Good thing that ain't usSeems a really odd signing for a top team. His main ability is his top speed, he'd be a big asset to a counter attacking/bottom half side who get space to run into. Watched him a few times and his actual ability has not impressed me. Can't see him doing well in a team with aspirations to be possession based.
Who was the last young player signed from the Championship by a top side?
Brave move from Man United, I wish more big clubs would take a chance like this.
Shame the guy decided to play for Wales though.
2015? Spurs were a good side thenI said "top" side.
Kidding aside, he's a good example but that was years ago.
Who was the last young player signed from the Championship by a top side?
Brave move from Man United, I wish more big clubs would take a chance like this.
Shame the guy decided to play for Wales though.
I suppose the players people think we should be signing are those that have proved they can hack it in the PL, but are still sufficiently under the radar that they won’t attract a huge fee (Robertson being an example). We seem to wait until everybody rates them and their price tag has inflated (Shaw).
It’s all very well mocking people for being negative about our signings but our abysmal record over recent years doesn’t leave much cause for optimism. That said, I’d rather take a cheap punt on an unproven youngster than have any more Sanchezes.
Fergie only invested in youth when he was absolutely sure that the player he's was getting was destined to excel. However he got those wrong a lot as well. Rooney, Ronaldo to name a few were gems.
Smalling, Jones, Bebe, Obertan were all bought when they were very young and you can tell how much they've improved their game since then.
If they're better than him, they will play ahead of him.
Only he can use his left just as good as his right. We don't have anyone who can do that and haven't for a while. Everyone is too dependent on their good foot...
I must be seeing a different Shaw. The one I've been seeing is a fat slob whose mistakes costed us points against Huddersfield and Shitty. If he ever becomes available I seriously doubt the likes of Real or Juventus would be in for him.
Honestly id love to see a clean sweep. Id give Pogba a second chance if he wants to remain but I wouldn't be bothered too much if he leaves as long as we can find adequate replacement
Yes not every signing will work out, youth or finished article. That's the game. I say we trust the new management team to make these calls.
I personally am glad to see us interested in a young, fast (apparently right sided?) winger who isn't costing £50+ million. If it doesn't work out it doesn't work out but writing off this potential signing before he's even kicked a ball isn't fair.
You think ?Encouraging signs, at least shows the scouting set up is doing some work.
I honestly don't see it working out in the PL. I would love to be proven wrong though.
Not nessicarily, Greenwood should have had a chance weeks ago given how shite Rashford, Martial and Lukaku have been, but he's not been given a sniff, it took until last week for Chong to get a chance to play instead of the aforementioned 3, and I can't recall the last time Gomes got on the pitch for us. I see no point in stacking up more unproven kids when we have 3 there waiting.
You think ?
We have been signing players other clubs have been scouting for months- City with Fred, Leeds with James.
Here’s what our scouts do - they call up the Leeds scouts - hey Harry, how’s it going? What’s happening at Leeds? I hear you guys are scouting this kid Daniel James, so what do you guys think of him? Pretty good eh, great, good enough for me..oh and hey, you don’t have to scout him anymore, you can spend time with your family now instead of going to matches to watch the lad play because we are signing him. Thanks Harry, cheers.
Calls Woody - hey Mr Woodward, Chief Scout here, yeah we extensively scouted that boy you wanted us to look at, he’s pretty good, sign him up
It would probably have looked better if you'd said Alexises, oops maybe not....
Which 23 year old and younger British players would Juventus and Real be battling it out for? Only a couple and no leftbacks
Fat slob? I bet you weigh more than he does. He's just won 2 awards for his work this season.
It was a jokeThey are not the only one scouting players and it's not exclusive scouting club. Every player is scouted by most clubs, whether they make a move or not depends on the recruitment team.
I totally disagree with your second point . We are lacking an entire squad not just key players. 15m buys you what nowadays? Pogba's left elbow?
We should be collecting promising young talent when they can be acquired for a decent price, especially when they have proven themselves In England or at the international level. Maybe they work out and start for years, maybe they become a decent squad player or maybe we just sell them to West Brom for 8 million in a few years.
Chris Snalling is a good example of this. Fergie seemed to randomly pluck him from Fulham out of the blue for around 7 million quid. Maybe he shouldn't have started as many games as he has, but even his critics can't complain about that deal.
14 pages? Is this the first official saga of the summer?
You think if we signed lower end PL players those same crazies would be in any way placated? Who are all these bargain youngsters playing in the PL we should sign?I suppose the players people think we should be signing are those that have proved they can hack it in the PL, but are still sufficiently under the radar that they won’t attract a huge fee (Robertson being an example). We seem to wait until everybody rates them and their price tag has inflated (Shaw).
It’s all very well mocking people for being negative about our signings but our abysmal record over recent years doesn’t leave much cause for optimism. That said, I’d rather take a cheap punt on an unproven youngster than have any more Sanchezes.
You think ?
We have been signing players other clubs have been scouting for months- City with Fred, Leeds with James.
Here’s what our scouts do - they call up the Leeds scouts - hey Harry, how’s it going? What’s happening at Leeds? I hear you guys are scouting this kid Daniel James, so what do you guys think of him? Pretty good eh, great, good enough for me..oh and hey, you don’t have to scout him anymore, you don’t have to go to the matches to watch the lad play because we are signing him. Thanks Harry, cheers.
Calls Woody - hey Mr Woodward, Chief Scout here, yeah we extensively scouted that boy you wanted us to look at, he’s pretty good, sign him up
Solskjaer was actually a member of the LFC fan club.LFC fan? No chance he'll come here then.