I like it a bit more now than when I initally played it last month, but the whole thing still feels underwhelming. The aesthetics and atmosphere of the city are fantastic, most of the characters are well written and acted and I don't mind the gunplay, but it's just so one-dimensional. There's no exploration, no interesting side activities, no particularly compelling progression systems, certainly no emergent gameplay or anything. Just a static world where all you do is fairly mundane gameplay.
It's not a bad game, it's competent and occasionally good. But that's all it is.