Those so called posters and media outlets make it sound like we had this perfect pressing plan
Show me one single post that says we had a perfect pressing plan? Just one.
There isn’t one. Stop reading the arguements you want to argue against and engage with the point being made.
Bruno has always done that & been criticised for it as he just wastes his energy chasing lost causes & was always leaving us with a poor midfield shape.
Bruno has not always done it to the extent he did when Ronaldo was integrated into the team. It is extremely simple- don’t take my word for it - go back to the matchday threads last season and show me one game where we lost or didn’t get a result that Bruno’s headless chicken act beyond the striker was noted as weakening the midfield or making us easy to play through? Just one...show me one thread or post? That’s not my opinion- that’s all if your opinions. Nobody raised it as a problem because it wasn’t one. It wasn’t one because for two years the front 3 had played the same, limited but somewhat effective way out of possession. Not pressing, nor coordinated but certainly closing down in fits and starts and most importantly imo, not giving the opposing teams back four liscence to stroll out with the ball, to calm down and to pick passes. Go back and watch some of the early games with Ronaldo, it’s a mixture of us sitting on the halfway line not pressing at all and Bruno running beyond Ronaldo while the other wide forward look like they don’t know where to be.
Bruno didn’t feel the need to go beyond the striker even half as much last season and it showed...front 3 were more compact and the other team was not allowed to settle as easily as they have this season. That’s why we didn’t look even half as penetrable as this season.
I conclude, that
one of the reasons we have lookEd so open this season is the gap between the front 4 and the back 6. A single pass takes out half of our team and then the issues with our backline have done the rest but I won’t go there just now.
The only arguement against what I’m saying seems to be the rather vague statement that “we rode our luck last season and it was bound to collapse”. I simply disagree. We were not an easy team to beat last season...and there is no reason why that should be so drastically changed this season unless something changes in our approach...I have given my view on what that “something” was and even if you don’t agree, you cannot simply dismiss it because you have no better explaination other than we were lucky last season!
You seem to want to suggest because the team finished second last season and is struggling this season, it’s down to Ronaldo.
Go read the flak I got earlier in the season for saying how shit we were last year...you won’t get a poster who disparaged our performance last year more than I did. The shite I got from the usual clever clogs on here saying “you don’t finish second and get to a europa league final if you’re not a good team etc.” Pointing to stats and other bullshit when I said you don’t need stats...use your eyes...we are shit!
Stop trying to twist my words and put across what you”think” I’m saying...
I am saying we were shit last season...but solid enough, our GA and xGAn were reasonable in comparison to other teams and our issues lay in the final third, breaking teams down- not just my opinion- go read the library of low block musings from last season.
This season our issues are very much and undeniably around looking completely and utterly there for the taking against even the most ordinary sides. I happen to think that there are several reasons for this, one being the integration of a new forward, who plays differently to how the others did in previous seasons, leaving the other forward unsure of what they should be doing and leaving Bruno to either, of his own accord or on Ole’s instruction, try to assist the front three in pressing the ball higher up the pitch. This creates the gaps we have seen in which the opposing midfield can waltz through us.
None of this is Ronaldo’s fault. The coach decides on how to play. But that doesn’t mean that integrating Ronaldo and trying to find a way to stay compact and still use him effectively hasn’t caused issues and conundrums- it has. Ole couldn’t solve them. Neither could Carrick IMO although Ronnys workrate against Arsenal was very impressive-Arsenal are shite and we will need that type of workrate from all our front three- in a structured manner- in order to salvage this season. We haven’t done it up until now and Ronaldo has been part of that issue. He doesn’t get a pass because he is Ronaldo and it’s reasonable enough to say...if I had to choose between starting Ronaldo knowing that the team looks more unstable with him in it but knowing he will score at least one goal——and starting without Ronaldo and perhaps not needing his goal because we are less open...I would choose the second option in some games and the first option in others! That is entirely reasonable but because I’m not scratching his initials into my arm I’m some kind of troll? Get a grip.
If he does it—if Rangnick works it out (and I think he will) I’ll be delighted...if he doesn’t...drop him. I don’t care whether or not Ronaldo plays- I care about how the team plays! So Jeppers mate, stop trying to twist what I’m saying...that’s about a simple as I can explain it. I will cheer every goal he scores and everything he tries for the team...I just won’t fan the hyperbole when I don’t think he improves us in any way.
That may well change under a coach that can use him properly. Let’s see.