MJJ
New Member
Two decisions reviewed already, the umpiring has been a joke.
How was Kallis given out today? Ridiculous.
Same way younis khan was given out yesterday?
No, it's different. DRS can be for multiple dismissals. However, each dismissal type must have original decision as 'umpire call'. For khan, umpire decision for the catch was originally not out- this was overturned due to the nick. The umpires call for the Kallis catch was out - this was overturned. The umpire decision for the Kallis lbw was not out - hawkeye showed that the lbw should've gone with umpire call. Therefore, Kallis shouldn't have been given out.
Hafeez is a good batsmen but I don't rate him outside the subcontinent.
Sarfraz's wicket today was
Did the Umpires say this?
http://www.sport24.co.za/Cricket/PakistaninSA/Kallis-dismissal-was-mistake-20130215
According to this article, the ICC said it was a mistake.
No, it's different. DRS can be for multiple dismissals. However, each dismissal type must have original decision as 'umpire call'. For khan, umpire decision for the catch was originally not out- this was overturned due to the nick. The umpires call for the Kallis catch was out - this was overturned. The umpire decision for the Kallis lbw was not out - hawkeye showed that the lbw should've gone with umpire call. Therefore, Kallis shouldn't have been given out.
Joe Root looking very handy, another good knock of 72 not out to see England home last night.