City and Financial Doping | Charged by PL with 130 FFP breaches | Hearing begins 16th Sep 2024 | Concluded 9th Dec 2024 - Awaiting outcome

Eplel said:
No matter how much you wash it, it was still a move to avoid PSR charges, and even you can't pretend it was otherwise.
Click to expand...
The purchase of the hotels? Yes, absolutely. One pretty much every team has done. Real Madrid has done it in the past. It is just as allowed as selling a player. And it doesn’t work the way people think it does… and that distinction is pretty important to understand.

But the women’s wasn’t, and that’s the point. People, including credible news outlets, completely got it wrong.
 
Mr Pigeon said:
He probably did. When he was five they were already paying Mancini under the table so as he got older and they did more dodgy salary stuff with other folk he thought "I want some of that".
Click to expand...
They're honestly the worst thing to happen to football. There's no way Lord Guardiola or any of these players would have even given that tinpot club a second look if it wasn't for their dodgy finances.

The only silver lining I take from them is that their peak also coincided with Liverpools.
 
The new Premier League handbook for 24/25 was released yesterday and the Profit and Sustainability rules are still the same, could this be an indication that City's ludicrus court action failed?
 
RedRocket9908 said:
The new Premier League handbook for 24/25 was released yesterday and the Profit and Sustainability rules are still the same, could this be an indication that City's ludicrus court action failed?
Click to expand...

I guess so. And considering the desperate nature of this case, that would be very good news for football.
 
Bluelion7 said:
Those reports were incorrect. It is astounding how low the level of understanding and the ability to flesh out the truth of a story is in many modern “news” outlets.

With the hotels, Blueco22 couldn’t “buy” the hotels from Blueco22. That’s a myth. A shareholder that owns a percentage of Blueco22 purchased 100% of the hotels.

With the women’s team we were fielding offers through third party banks for investment in our women’s team. It wasn’t until they were told that wasn’t possible that they gathered more info and decided to act.

Women’s teams in the WSL are considered “property” of the men’s team. That’s why you can credit towards your PSR for women’s investment. It outside investment goes directly to the men.

Blueco then discovered that Lyon was the only women’s team emancipated from their men’s team, and they inquired as to what they needed to do to make that that happen.

On 5/29 Blueco announced that Chelsea women’s FC would have it’s ownership shifted from Chelsea FC to Blueco22; same as the men.

Chelsea men’s FC received nothing toward PSR for this. In fact, it takes away an ability to manipulate investment in the women’s team for additional PSR credits.

The Chelsea Womens FC then received the 11m. Investment stake in THEIR team. Doesn’t go to the men or their PSR at all. The valuation people were throwing around of 150m was the total valuation of just the women’s team for the purposes of determining what kind of stake the 11m would get the investor. This was handled by a third party as well, and actually seemed kind low for a figure derived for those purposes. Angel City women’s team in the US NWSL got a valuation of 144m for similar purposes, and they are nowhere near the brand of the Chelsea Women.

All I saw was actual news outlets spreading “Chelsea selling their women’s team to themselves for 150m and now we know how they made PSR on 6/30” ….. so lame.

I asked my 8 year old, without any hints, if Chelsea bought their own women’s team for a huge amount of money. He came up with pretty close to the exact right explanation with his computer and google in about 10 minutes.

Chelsea values its women’s team greatly. They have been making big moves to ensure they continue to excel, and to let people know that they aren’t just property or a PSR tool.
Click to expand...
Not only are all Chelsea fans bloody accountants, they're actively pushing their children to become accountants too. Cruel.
Bluelion7 said:
The purchase of the hotels? Yes, absolutely. One pretty much every team has done. Real Madrid has done it in the past. It is just as allowed as selling a player. And it doesn’t work the way people think it does… and that distinction is pretty important to understand.

But the women’s wasn’t, and that’s the point. People, including credible news outlets, completely got it wrong.
Click to expand...
Oh yes? Which other teams apart from Real Madrid? Don't remember this being as common as you're saying!
 
WeePat said:
Not hotels but Villa did sell Villa Park to themselves back in 2020 and the PL seemingly looked into it and approved the sale.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/49600851- this report also mention Derby, Wednesday and Reading doing the same.

https://www.birminghammail.co.uk/sport/football/football-news/aston-villa-stadium-sale-ffp-17865860
Click to expand...
Sooooo not quite "pretty much every team"? It's a little bit rich for someone complaining about how things are being reported to throw out those type of comments.
 
Rooney in Paris said:
Sooooo not quite "pretty much every team"? It's a little bit rich for someone complaining about how things are being reported to throw out those type of comments.
Click to expand...

For sure. I don't think it's as common practice as BlueLion is saying. It seems to be a thing teams in PSR trouble are resorting to to fudge the books in a legal but still very dubious manner.
 
Last edited:
Oh for feck's sake.

Just fecking go away and cheat somewhere else already.

Sick of the sight of him.
 
DarkLord1984 said:
Oh for feck's sake.

Just fecking go away and cheat somewhere else already.

Sick of the sight of him.
Click to expand...
You can't really cheat that way in International football, PSG have already done the "cheat&destroy the league" mission and Italy are too poor for him.
He's gonna stick around until the PL does something...
 
awop said:
You can't really cheat that way in International football, PSG have already done the "cheat&destroy the league" mission and Italy are too poor for him.
He's gonna stick around until the PL does something...
Click to expand...
Pretty much.

Why would he leave when he can cheat until his heart's content where he is? Slimy little weasel. He clearly has no moral conscience and doesn't care if his rotten club has a huge unfair advantage - so long as he can win.

He's got the most punchable face in football. I'd love nothing more than to see him banned from the game permanently. Wishful thinking, I'm sure.
 
Last edited:
LordSpud said:


This bald fecker only sticks around when he knows it's safe. Not good.
Click to expand...


Excellent, please stay, no problem. Let's Ineos Team and ETH teach him a good lesson how to win properly without cheating. It will be this season or next season. You hear from me first!
 
Yakuza_devils said:
Excellent, please stay, no problem. Let's Ineos Team and ETH teach him a good lesson how to win properly without cheating. It will be this season or next season. You hear from me first!
Click to expand...

Wish some proper club could dominate him for few years, but he would not stay for linger as when things get difficult for him he will pack the bags to similar sort of plastic club.
 
I genuinely thought he would get bored of being at City.
 
Lay said:
I genuinely thought he would get bored of being at City.
Click to expand...
Really? He’s not really up for a challenge, he’s a cheque book manager that enjoys an environment that is perfect to succeed. He had it at Barcelona, Bayern and now City. Can you think of a better environment for him now?
 
Pexbo said:
Really? He’s not really up for a challenge, he’s a cheque book manager that enjoys an environment that is perfect to succeed. He had it at Barcelona, Bayern and now City. Can you think of a better environment for him now?
Click to expand...
Exactly. And this is part of the reason as to why he will never be the GOAT.
 
Pexbo said:
Really? He’s not really up for a challenge, he’s a cheque book manager that enjoys an environment that is perfect to succeed. He had it at Barcelona, Bayern and now City. Can you think of a better environment for him now?
Click to expand...
Next move will be Saudi league for 2-3 years and a few hundred million. Only other option I see is to 'retire' in the MLS.
 
Has there ever been a bigger case of sporting cheating than Manchester City? Lance Armstrong perhaps?

It’s shameful that they’ve been allowed turn the most popular sport in the world into such a farce.

Awful to see.
 
IRELANDUNITED said:
Has there ever been a bigger case of sporting cheating than Manchester City? Lance Armstrong perhaps?

It’s shameful that they’ve been allowed turn the most popular sport in the world into such a farce.

Awful to see.
Click to expand...

Why are you showing such disrespect to City comparing them to Armstrong? What City have done is way over and beyond what Armstrong did.

City's cheating is unprecedented in sport history. Everyone knows about their blatant cheating for more than a decade but no one can touch them in the court. They refused to co-operate, looking for loophole to get evidence time barred, counter sue EUFA/PL, delay tactics and whatnot.

Hope soon the law will catch up with them.
 
Those close to him say he wants his legacy to be returning to Barcelona and making them a force again. But no chance of that unless they find some money from somewhere.
 
Yakuza_devils said:
Why are you showing such disrespect to City comparing them to Armstrong? What City have done is way over and beyond what Armstrong did.

City's cheating is unprecedented in sport history. Everyone knows about their blatant cheating for more than a decade but no one can touch them in the court. They refused to co-operate, looking for loophole to get evidence time barred, counter sue EUFA/PL, delay tactics and whatnot.

Hope soon the law will catch up with them.
Click to expand...
Agreed. It's been the best executed organised cheating and corruption regime seen in modern sports. The only comparable regime would potentially be the Russian Olympic doping regime.

Good timeline of how many legal tactics City have had to use just to delay their inevitable exclusion from the EPL:

 
I just can't understand why the PL cannot suspend City until they furnish the requested documents for the case. They allow them to continue and cheat through the years and affecting the whole league and other clubs.
In a normal workplace, if an employee is suspected of commiting a fraud, I am surr this employee would be suspended until investigation is completed. No company will let the employee continue working, getting promotion and bonuses.
The whole situation is just absurd and lack of common sense.
 
I read here at some time, that there should be a decission around November. Is there something in this or is there no chance of a conviction at all? The cheating is obvious of course, but the league and the uk as a whole is profiting from oil states significantly. So the question is, if the pl is taking a hit for the larger goal. Year after year it will get harder as City will be seen as a legit big club. Nonne will ask how they got that big in the end.
 
Their revenues even surpassed that of RM, Barca, Man Utd and BM when they can't even fill their stadium. And we are supposed to believe all their sponsors are legit. UEFA and PL are playing along sulking to City.
 
Sassy Colin said:
The fact that they refuse to provide the documentation almost proves their guilt.

If they were innocent of all charges, they'd happily hand over the documents to demonstrate that.
Click to expand...
Exactly. Any business entity preferring to spend tens of millions on distraction litigation rather than handing over their accounts tells you all you need to know.
 
FujiVice said:
Those close to him say he wants his legacy to be returning to Barcelona and making them a force again. But no chance of that unless they find some money from somewhere.
Click to expand...

The irony of him at Barcelona is that even then, both Real Madrid and Barcelona had an unfair advantage over every other La Liga club by reaping over 70% of TV rights money. I mean, I'm shocked Redcafe doesn't address this at all.

For almost 20 years, including Pep's entire Barca spell, the big two were disproportionately fecking over every other La Liga team.
 
Sassy Colin said:
The fact that they refuse to provide the documentation almost proves their guilt.

If they were innocent of all charges, they'd happily hand over the documents to demonstrate that.
Click to expand...

Imo i'm a bit surprised there isn't specific rules that would allow the PL to hand down rather harsh punishments just for refusing to provide the documentation within a certain amount of time.
 
It is quite simply scandalous that this shit is rolling into another season. We literally do not know if they can even legitimately win the title and have to play along for another year. I complained about this to the point there's nothing more to say, but this is such a ridiculous situation that my interest in a season starting has never been lower.

The integrity of the sport is gone, and the validity of any games is gone, until these cheats are punished.
 
If they don’t discard their leagues won then at least I hope they get docked 10 pts for each season since 13/14. Obviously the 2nd place team gets the league. Anything over 10 pts and whatever team was in 2nd wouldn’t deserve it anyway. Sounds fair.
 
I don't believe for a second there will be any "reckoning". A points deduction at best but at least they won't win 5 in a row. And that's if there's any deduction at all.
 
Pep is already talking about staying on. Bet he knows something that we don't know.

No way they get punished heavily most probably will be a tap on the hand
 
Tyrion said:
I'd be surprised if they're even given a fine.
Click to expand...
Probably they won't be
But if there is any "punishment" this is what the FA will go for. Least controversial, no taking titles/trophies away, keeps Abu Dhabi paymasters onside. "Punish" the richest club in the world by fining them - job done.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.