Castia
Full Member
- Joined
- Jun 18, 2011
- Messages
- 19,311
You have to wonder if this is them going down swinging. You would think if they were on track to get away with the charges relatively free they wouldn’t be kicking up a stink.
It's called the go down fighting.You have to wonder if this is them going down swinging. You would think if they were on track to get away with the charges relatively free they wouldn’t be kicking up a stink.
I understood this process (arbitration) as a set period to make your points, a decision made and no appeals? No?All clubs contribute 5%, including City, to the Prem’s legal fees.
I think it’s City’s plan to be litigious as feck. There’s no limit on what they can spend on lawyers (as far as I’m aware) and their owners are literally the UAE state, so they can do this continuously theoretically.
I love how their argument is that they’ve been disadvantaged right on the tail end of a treble and 4 leagues in a rowSo City feel ‘Historically disadvantaged’ by other clubs?
I feel historically disadvantaged by the royal family and the rich in general.
Can I sue them?
Can I *!
Their argument is bollox
What is this cartel City and Newcastle fans are all crying about and how are they able to decide the Premier League rules when all Premier League rule changes require the agreement of 14 out of the 20 member clubs, if this so-called cartel exists and has the power Newcastle and City fans claim they have why would they have allowed to Newcastle Saudi takeover to go through in the first place?
Also claiming City winning will instantly make the league more competitive is ridiculous
Makes me wonder why this complete shitshow was even approved in the first place. Surely anyone with a brain could see that this was going to happen?Well it's about 15 years too late but it feels like the tide has officially turned and the mainstream media and opposition fans in general have realised how damaging to English football City are.
It only took them winning 8 fecking titles in 12 years for people to realise this. Them going after the PL seems like the actions of a club panicking about the charges they've got. Have they heard they're fecked?
Wild. People don't understand the significance of this if they win this.
Or they have gathered the best lawyers money can buy and think they have a chance. Litigation like this will be astronomically expensive - one way of doping is that City can afford to do this ad infinitum, so lose this and it’s not the end. Win this and it basically is.
This is grim.
Suddenly I see a lot of twitter handles supporting City pop up on my feed. Oddly a lot of them are supposedly Everton fans. Probably a marketing ploy from Abu Dabi to whip up some momentum.
It's not really being dramatic to say that its a pivotal period in time for English football. Whichever way this goes, will have drastic and massively altering repercussions.
I still fear they will win and end the Premier League as a competitive one. The reputation of it won't just be tarnished but destroyed which will be very sad
What is this cartel City and Newcastle fans are all crying about and how are they able to decide the Premier League rules when all Premier League rule changes require the agreement of 14 out of the 20 member clubs, if this so-called cartel exists and has the power Newcastle and City fans claim they have why would they have allowed to Newcastle Saudi takeover to go through in the first place?
Also claiming City winning will instantly make the league more competitive is ridiculous
I understood this process (arbitration) as a set period to make your points, a decision made and no appeals? No?
I still fear they will win and end the Premier League as a competitive one. The reputation of it won't just be tarnished but destroyed which will be very sad
I think it actually should count towards FFP, one of the other club owners made a comment on this from memory.Yeah that’s correct, but nothing stopping them from suing in other areas (I think?). As the Sheik said a few years ago, he’s happy to tie the Premier League up in court cases for as long as possible.
Any sanction on City will be met with significant legal challenge, just as Everton appealed its point deduction.
City have unlimited resources effectively, there’s no FFP on lawyers (as far as I’m aware).
Yes I’m sure they will tie up the PL for years in courts with appeals, but they can do that for as long as they like whilst they aren’t playing in it.Yeah that’s correct, but nothing stopping them from suing in other areas (I think?). As the Sheik said a few years ago, he’s happy to tie the Premier League up in court cases for as long as possible.
Any sanction on City will be met with significant legal challenge, just as Everton appealed its point deduction.
City have unlimited resources effectively, there’s no FFP on lawyers (as far as I’m aware).
I think it actually should count towards FFP, one of the other club owners made a comment on this from memory.
Yes I’m sure they will tie up the PL for years in courts with appeals, but they can do that for as long as they like whilst they aren’t playing in it.
Everton had the points deduction applied to them whilst appealing it wasn’t put on hold during that process. Precedent has been set there.
All clubs contribute 5%, including City, to the Prem’s legal fees.
I think it’s City’s plan to be litigious as feck. There’s no limit on what they can spend on lawyers (as far as I’m aware) and their owners are literally the UAE state, so they can do this continuously theoretically.
They might have to pay the PL’s costs if they lose as well.If you lose a case the expenditure/full costs should definitely count towards FFP. Not sure it does though?
Very true, hope that’s what happens.
Can we see them with an asterix next to their name on the table from the start of next season please.
Not sure about the appeal in this situation.Yeah that’s correct, but nothing stopping them from suing in other areas (I think?). As the Sheik said a few years ago, he’s happy to tie the Premier League up in court cases for as long as possible.
Any sanction on City will be met with significant legal challenge, just as Everton appealed its point deduction.
City have unlimited resources effectively, there’s no FFP on lawyers (as far as I’m aware).
I like some mild comedy in the morning.If they're found guilty of all charges, it'll be an Obelix not an Asterix.
The scariest part is that while they are corrupt, they are also very efficient at all the other things as an organization. I fully expect them to trump the PL in the legal battle.
I'm playing dumb here, because I don't honestly know the time line.
If this rule was in force when City were initially promoted, wasn't that the time to complain about it?
or
If this rule was brought in after City were promoted, wasn't the time to complain about it was when it was proposed.
The same goes for the other clubs, like Villa and Newcastle, they sat in the meeting that accepted this rule.