You have quite a few young talents and some more than decent senior players, Jedvaj, Brandt, Bailey, Havertz, Tah just to name a few. Only seen you a handful of times this season mind you but i haven't been impressed any game really. Is it on the manager or is it something else would you say?
Completely the manager IMO. Volland, Brandt and even Hradecky have already hinted in interviews that Herrlich has no real tactical concept. You know that something is wrong when even the goal keeper says that he was surprisedof how few tactical instructions the players have at Leverkusen - and Hradecky previously played under Kovac who isn't known to be the most conceptual coach in his own right.
The insane amount of class we have rescued Herrlich time and time again (especially Bailey last season) but now almost all of our amazing talents are in the worst form I've seen. They mess up the easiest passes and touches and even someone like Tah who was solid as a rock even aged 19 plays completely chaotic. This has reached a level which I can only explain with bad training that fails to even maintain basic technical consistency through exercises, game forms etc. In games our potential occasionally flares up in form of brillant combinations but for the most time you see no triangles, no coordinated movements, no patterns, nothing. Nobody knows where the other player is running and hasn't even an idea where he should position himself on the pitch. The only thing that works occasionally quite well is our pressing but I consider this a remainder of the Schmidt years during which we played the riskiest and most intense pressing seen in the Bundesliga.
Some also blame the players but while it is true that a few of them have difficult personalities, like Brandt, Wendell or Bailey, but after all man managing is also part of a manager's job and they are no divas or misfits, simply young people who could use a little more leadership at times. Especially Brandt is a very quiet, considerate and self-critical person in interviews, yet he is still far too lethargic for large parts of the game. I think a Klopp would get him on the right track in no time at all. IMO Herrlich relies far too heavily on hollow phrases as a coach and completely fails to provide a tactical concept that allows players to consistently perform. The total opposite of what I hoped for when he arrived as a no name.
He also uses many of our most gifted players completely wrong. Brandt is a defensively weak but incredibly creative winger that needs to cut in yet Herrlich always plays him on the right and lets him put dumb crosses in. He even played as a RB at times which is ridiculous. The same goals for Bailey on the other side. The minute we changed that and played in a 3-4-2-1 again, we absolutely destroyed Gladbach and Bremen with Brandt and Havertz playing centrally. Herrlich didn't even realize that and we are back to playing his stupid 4-4-2 again in which he look absolutely toothless.
Give this team a Favre, Tuchel or Klopp and we challenge Dortmund this season. Although their squad realistically is still comfortably better than ours we are (theoretically) the third best team in the league by quite a margin.