I was perhaps in the minority who thought season 1 of Silo started off very promisingly but became pretty boring as the season wore on. Most of the middle section was an absolute snooze fest, and that’s saying a lot because I am a sucker for slow burn sci-fi, but this series didn’t really grab me all that much. I’ll still watch season 2, but perhaps with lower expectations. Luckily I’ve seen some great series recently, especially The Leftovers, which I just finished.
The other half just put on Cross, on Prime. You can see what it’s trying to do. It’s like a cross (zing!) between Luther and Sherlock, but rubbish. Yes, rubbish. The whole season is utter tat. Really low grade TV making. For such a flagship show, this was just poor all round from Amazon. The acting is ropey at best, the plot leaps are preposterous, it plays like a Tyler Perry piece - which is a low bow, admittedly.
Aldis Hodge is decent as Cross. But most of the other characters are just caricatures of their supposed roles. The well meaning Best Friend Forever, who’s ready to give him tough love. Grandma at home, who keeps it all together and tells it how it is. The perfect, Uber talented kids, who have run ins at school courtesy of Daddy’s high profile. The cliche police chief who is blind, deaf and dumb to everything her star detective has to say in one scene, and in the very next is dealing with the explosive fall out of him being right again. But of course, the very next time they interact she’ll take his badge again and act like his theory is the ramblings of a crazy man. Rinse and repeat.
The laughable villain, who has the most bizarre motivation imaginable, and all his hyper influential and successful acolytes who are seemingly very happy to throw away a life’s work so this nutter can complete his weirdo magnum opus. And then there’s the random, never flustered, always chipper, white FBI lady, who shows up at the right time, every time, with a crucial piece of plot, just to keep it all moving along. She apparently has all the resources of the FBI at her disposal but zero procedures to follow, and is always on hand to help Cross, for no discernible reason, and never with any back up.
And then there is Cross himself. A man so brilliant, he has revelations just drop out the sky. A man so good at reading people and psychologically breaking them, that no suspect stands a chance. In the opening sequence he breaks a seemingly unbreakable suspect through the power of his dick alone. Yet this is also the guy who gets wound into a violent rage, time and again, by dinner party guests who say slightly mean things, and when exposed for misdemeanours in his past, can only resort to “No, listen, he’s doing this, can’t you all see? He’s the crazy one. Listen, please, it’s not me, it’s him! Step off or I’ll feck you up!” Truly a brilliant man.
But it’s okay, even if we manage to sidestep the fact that the show runners can’t decide if he’s a genius criminal profiler, psychologist and detective, or just a bad ass, ass licking, angry detective; we are still left with the question as to why this supposed genius is working for a local police department - an institution clearly full of corruption and incompetence, and one he shows enormous exasperation and contempt for - instead of one of the major federal law enforcement agencies. At one point he says it’s about being close to his family, but white saviour FBI lady who tries to recruit him, pops up in nearly every other scene; so clearly working in the area for the FBI isn’t a problem.
I won’t even get into all the race politics. Clearly there is an important and socially relevant point to be made there, but the handling of it is so ham fisted as to be laughable. Most of it boils down to black good, white baaaad. And it’s not that that is offensive, it’s just that it so incredibly lacks nuance that the entire point fails to get made, because nothing about the social structures reflect real life. As I said, it’s about the level of a Tyler Perry adaptation, or one of those terrible - mass produced - Harlan Coben mini-series on Netflix. It all plays out like a slightly edgy soap opera, rather than a serious show.
I know they are adapting famous books, but this series is not actually based on any book, it’s an original “Alex Cross” story for Amazon. And you can tell. Because it’s nonsense. They went for a sort of American John Luther type character and show, but ended up with something so flimsy that I suspect the majority of audiences will either drop it or just forward through to the relevant plot points.
Total waste of time. It’s also currently ranked number 1 in the US for shows on Amazon.