No offense but that's really the worst excuse I have ever seen for players missing chances.
It is not an excuse for players missing chances, it is the reason for the magnification
No offense but that's really the worst excuse I have ever seen for players missing chances.
I'm beginning to think he simply doesn't have the engine of a Neymar or Lingard.
Needs to start doing endurance training.
That’s a fair point. It’s something that needs to happen more often.Got your point, yes our movement is clearly an issue. And that Carrick chance happened only because McTominay ran till the byline with the ball, if we had done more of that in the entire match, I'm sure one of our attackers would have got into that position.
Someone said the other day he isn't clinical because he doesn't have 25 goals in the league. He's only had around 40 shots in the competition.This guy has been clinical most of the season, producing at the same level as players who have played like 10 more games than him in the league, whilst showing improvements in all aspects of his game; has one game where he's not clinical and posters get their knickers in twists calling him lazy, a bottler, lacks drive, should be benched or sold.
Sterling went from headless chicken to goalscoring wide man with elite movement in the space of a few months. The reason is down to coaching. Put Sterling in our current set up and he’ll struggle even more than Martial supposedly is. Despite being our POTM about 3 times now.
LOL obviously you have to praise Martial if he had a good game otherwise everyone will know that you don't like Martial. It's days when he doesn't perform well it clearly shows, you said Sanchez' "overall game was better" so his open goal miss is excusable when it is clear to everyone that Sanchez was just as bad as Martial against Newcastle.
See, this is moronic. Put Sterling in our team in place of Martial and we'll be no better off.Sterling was always good but lacked an end product. Anyone who thought otherwise was a moron. All that's changed is him taking the chances he routinely missed before.
Twice the player Martial is.
So in that instant where Sanchez chased the ball, did he win the ball back? He didn't did he? One player chasing after a ball is not pressing, it's just wasting energy. Sanchez has always played like that because he has abundant stamina, not all football players are robots designed exactly the same, each of them have various levels of stamina and each of them approach the game differently to last the 90 minutes.
Now if Martial was part of a team that employs pressing as a collective as part of winning the ball back, then you can criticize him for not pressing. Say if he didn't press when playing in a Liverpool or the current City side he'd stick out like a sore thumb and will rightly be criticized.
I have to completely disagree. Like @SS implies, it all comes down to coaching. If José had Sterling when taking over, he'd probably still be as inconsistent as ever (like all of our attackers) whereas if Pep had took over with Martial in his squad he would have most likely gone up a level like Sané and Sterling.Sterling was always good but lacked an end product. Anyone who thought otherwise was a moron. All that's changed is him taking the chances he routinely missed before.
Twice the player Martial is.
Unbelievable, the more I read the caf the less I dismiss the claims that the government is putting something in the waterSomeone said the other day he isn't clinical because he doesn't have 25 goals in the league. He's only had around 40 shots in the competition.
I have to completely disagree. Like @SS implies, it all comes down to coaching. If José had Sterling when taking over, he'd probably still be as inconsistent as ever (like all of our attackers) whereas if Pep had took over with Martial in his squad he would have most likely gone up a level like Sané and Sterling.
Sterling still misses chances but the thing is, the City players know more will come so aren't as pressured into burying there's fearing it might be the only clear cut chance they'll come by. You can tell the pressure weighs on our attackers shoulders to finish their chances because they're hard to come by for us.
I agree. Though, bar that one season where everything just clicked for Liverpool, he's always been inconsistent, imo. Pep deserves a tonne of credit for helping him find the consistency he has this season.Sterling was always better at beating players. He's done it so naturally since bursting onto the scene at Liverpool - I've always rated him higher than most. He had a better season in 2014 than Martial has had in his career - A huge part of a world class attack. This isn't just Pep's work - He's always been an incredible talent. he didn't cost what he did for no reason.
I'm not denying that he's a big part of their success and is a big contributor to how they're able to play, but it's mainly because of Pep and the way he sets his teams up, and I'm not trying to take credit away from Sterling himself but that's the way I see it. Under a more pragmatic manager I don't think he'd be doing as well as he has been, and vice versa for Martial.Obviously he gets more chances - He plays with better players in a better, more attacking team but he's also a huge part of their success. Not saying Pep hasn't improved him but to attribute so much credit to the coach is just ridiculous. Some of his goals and individual displays are just fantastic and far beyond anything Martial has shown. You look at the difference in their off the ball movement - Sterling and is just relentless - Constantly showing short before spinning in behind, constantly pressing out of possession, qualities he's been showing for years - This is where Martial is just awful. There's no urgency to him, even with the ball he's less direct and constantly seems to delay taking on his man, even though he's rather good at it. He's lets the full back off the hook - He should be a nightmare to go up against but instead you see him leisurely strutting around making pretty predictable runs. It's not good enough.
Bar the overrated part, I agree.Martial is obviously extremely talented. But he's extremely frustrating and needs to drop the bad habits - I do think he's seriously overrated among United fans, largely because there's not too many better by comparison in the team.
You really believe that? Imagine Sanchez, Lukaku and Sterling. That would be deadly.See, this is moronic. Put Sterling in our team in place of Martial and we'll be no better off.
That's actually exactly what he shouldn't be doing, trying to dribble past players every time he gets the ball. This is something I constantly hear, people complaining about back-sideway passes. In reality, most should be backward or sideways. Because you can't risk losing the ball all the time. Making the decision on when to dribble and when to keep the ball is difficult for young players, they tend to try and run at defenders all the time and create a bunch of turnovers. That's something you get with experience. But I think Martial does it pretty well. Had he been doing it more often, his dis/uns would look even worse than it already is.My only gripe with him is that he doesn't play with purpose or intensity when he has the ball. Alexis plays with purpose with or without the ball and quickens the tempo which is something that Martial doesn't do as much as I'd like to see because he has the ability. Even Tahith Chong who now plays in the u-23 team immediately upon receiving the ball explodes and wants to make things happen and plays with great intensity wanting to take the game to the opposition. Kluivert at Ajax is another young wide player that is similar to Chong in that regard.
Martial for someone who has very good dribbling skills and pace is too passive in alot of games considering he has the tools to show so much more.
See, this is moronic. Put Sterling in our team in place of Martial and we'll be no better off.
His movement is actually poor, he's nearly always playing on his heels which gives the opposition time to get into position to shackle him which has thus far resulted in us looking static and him looking very predictable. For someone with his ability he shouldn't be passive for long periods of the game. He doesn't need to dribble all the time, that's not what I said. But there should be an urgency to quicken the tempo like what Sanchez does. Some compare him to Ousmane Dembele, Mbappe and a young Ribery potentially but all three of his fellow country men play with a urgency that I'm not seeing with Martial at all.That's actually exactly what he shouldn't be doing, trying to dribble past players every time he gets the ball. This is something I constantly hear, people complaining about back-sideway passes. In reality, most should be backward or sideways. Because you can't risk losing the ball all the time. Making the decision on when to dribble and when to keep the ball is difficult for young players, they tend to try and run at defenders all the time and create a bunch of turnovers. That's something you get with experience. But I think Martial does it pretty well. Had he been doing it more often, his dis/uns would look even worse than it already is.
Yeah, his movement off the ball is not good at all. It's somewhat better with the ball but as you said, he does lack urgency when he gets the ball. He needs to make his mind up quicker, to not let the defense set.His movement is actually poor, he's nearly always playing on his heels which gives the opposition time to get into position to shackle him which has thus far resulted in us looking static and him looking very predictable. For someone with his ability he shouldn't be passive for long periods of the game. He doesn't need to dribble all the time, that's not what I said. But there should be an urgency to quicken the tempo like what Sanchez does. Some compare him to Ousmane Dembele, Mbappe and a young Ribery potentially but all three of his fellow country men play with a urgency that I'm not seeing with Martial at all.
Yeah he looks like he has come on to prove something today. Some of ithose skills. The roll back pause thing was justThat phase of play ~89:20 today.
He's unbelievable at times.
Ha ha no way Rashford rotates with Lukaku unless or until the latter gets injured. Mourinho doesn't seem to like playing without a targetman type upfront.Hopefully he learns how to be more direct from Sanchez. He'll be a complete player if this happens.
At the moment both him and Sanchez prefer to play on the left so it can be helped. They need to keep rotating on this position with Rashford moved to rotate with Lukaku on striker position. Can't see a formation in which both will play together except if Martial play as a striker.
Exactly. Just let Sanchez roam in the middle, Lingard has been useless these last three games.Sanchez drifts all over the place.
Just place him in the centre and this boy on the left.
His feet are magic.
He will be benched again mostly. Can't really criticize Mourinho for this, Sanchez right now is a better player and having Mata on the right is much better than having Martial/Rashford.Looks ready for Sevilla
It doesn't always work like that in real time. Alexis drifts around plenty, but he still prefers the wide area not being occupied so he can utilize that space whenever he sees fit. He's not a conventional forward or no 10 who naturally stay central, making subtleice move and passing machine.Sanchez drifts all over the place.
Just place him in the centre and this boy on the left.
Exactly. Just let Sanchez roam in the middle, Lingard has been useless these last three games.
His feet are magic.
@GifLordThat phase of play ~89:20 today.
He's unbelievable at times.
Effective how?He's a more effective player, runs and works harder for the team. He would indeed improve us. Not a better player than Martial just a better fit into Jose' system for me...
Honestly in the rare occasions they’ve sort of been in each other’s areas they’ve linked up quite well and done some nice things that bodes well for the future. Personaly I would have had Sanchez right and Martial left, but seeing the brief moments how they’ve worked together I’d probably put Sanchez central. They just from the brief moments I’ve seen have an understanding of what the other wants to do.Good cameo. Eventually we will see him and Sanchez play together and do it well. Patience is needed.
Honestly in the rare occasions they’ve sort of been in each other’s areas they’ve linked up quite well and done some nice things that bodes well for the future. Personaly I would have had Sanchez right and Martial left, but seeing the brief moments how they’ve worked together I’d probably put Sanchez central. They just from the brief moments I’ve seen have an understanding of what the other wants to do.