If that's the main argument against Di Maria then we would also end interest in Messi or Aguero if they were available because of 'luck'.
If Ed says something remote to truth we can match financial expectations and sign a world class winger for a change.
Just curious if we were to sign Di Maria - which I do not believe will happen - where would he play, formation wise and and who would be dropped for him?
You would be shocked how many times in this thread this question has been asked... along with "how will he fit in the 3-5-2"
I thought the point was that he's good at his job. My main point is that when he actually gets deals done they have all been overpriced.I hope you realise that you just expanded my point. My post was aimed at the guy above who alluded that Woody is stingy.
It's believed (by the Madrid press) that Ancelotti is still working on some sympathisers in the Madrid board to offer a new deal to Di Maria. Meanwhile Ronaldo is said to be trying to talk Di Maria out of demanding to leave.
Perez is not keen, but with Ancelotti and Ronaldo pulling the other way, he's hesitating about the whole, "Get the cash, buy Falcao," idea. On the other hand an "irresistible" offer for a stroppy player who wants to leave, and he'll sell. Allegedly.
There has to be one big signing this summer....if not it would be the biggest anti climax ever with the way we've been playing.
You would be shocked how many times in this thread this question has been asked... along with "how will he fit in the 3-5-2"
Couldn't be arsed reading the thread sorry, I'm too burnt out reading the Vidal saga instead!
So where will he play then....
Look, he would be a great signing. World class. what I dont get is where he fits in for this season. would he accept a wingback role for a season? until we can transition to 433 next year? rooney and van persie are nailed on starters uptop with welbeck and januzaj rotating in. you then have mata and kagawa for the no.10. could you have him in central midfield next to hererra for a year? i just dont see where theres room with our squad makeup and 352.
Look, he would be a great signing. World class. what I dont get is where he fits in for this season. would he accept a wingback role for a season? until we can transition to 433 next year? rooney and van persie are nailed on starters uptop with welbeck and januzaj rotating in. you then have mata and kagawa for the no.10. could you have him in central midfield next to hererra for a year? i just dont see where theres room with our squad makeup and 352.
I'm terrified Chelsea are going to swoop in for him on the last day. Imagine him and Hazard out wide for them.
If we signed him and Vidal I think it would complete the transition of our team into a 4-3-3. Operating in the same position as he did for Madrid last season, without displacing Rooney or Van Persie out of their preferred strikers position. Something like this:
----------Vidal---------
--Herrera-------Di Maria
-----------------------
----------Mata---------
--Rooney-------RVP----
If we signed him and Vidal I think it would complete the transition of our team into a 4-3-3. Operating in the same position as he did for Madrid last season, without displacing Rooney or Van Persie out of their preferred strikers position. Something like this:
----------Vidal---------
--Herrera-------Di Maria
-----------------------
----------Mata---------
--Rooney-------RVP----
Could do a 4-3-3 type, but a diamond with 2 strikers rather then 2 wide forwards/wingers. He'd have a similar role to the one he had at Madrid, and the strikers drifting around. Sort of like:Still slightly lost as to where we can currently facilitate him in the 3-5-2 to be honest.
I do believe van Gaal will seek to implement 4-3-3 next season though.
Perhaps van Gaal feels van Persie will be used sparingly? It's certainly a possibility. I would not like di Maria to be used as a wing-back, feel he'd be wasted there.
Yeah, I'm unsure how comfortable I'd be with di Maria as a no. 8. He played as no. 10 for Real Madrid last season, didn't he?Could do a 4-3-3 type, but a diamond with 2 strikers rather then 2 wide forwards/wingers. He'd have a similar role to the one he had at Madrid, and the strikers drifting around. Sort of like:
De Gea
Rafael Smalling Evans Shaw
Carrick
Herrera -- Di Maria
Mata
Rooney -- Van Persie
If we signed him and Vidal I think it would complete the transition of our team into a 4-3-3. Operating in the same position as he did for Madrid last season, without displacing Rooney or Van Persie out of their preferred strikers position. Something like this:
----------Vidal---------
--Herrera-------Di Maria
-----------------------
----------Mata---------
--Rooney-------RVP----
This I like.Fletcher - Ander
Mata
di Maria - Rooney - Januzaj
If he were to sign, maybe we could use this for the first few weeks whilst RvP+Welbeck are still out? The issue of what happens when RvP is back arises, but I think he could work as a very offensive wingback.
Van Gaal did say himself the reason we don't play a 4-3-3 is because you need top wingers for that, like Ronaldo or Di Maria, and we don't have that. That's why IMO he wants to implement the 3-5-2, as our current wingers are a bit shit going forward minus Januzaj, and Di Maria is not an easy deal to pull off. If we do get him then we can easily switch to a 4-3-3.Convinced it's all bollocks. We've played 3412 every game and the only positions he could play are those filled by our best 3 players.
I'm terrified Chelsea are going to swoop in for him on the last day. Imagine him and Hazard out wide for them.
He also spoke on how he'd have to play with two strikers as he couldn't bench three of 'em.Van Gaal did say himself the reason we don't play a 4-3-3 is because you need top wingers for that, like Ronaldo or Di Maria, and we don't have that. That's why IMO he wants to implement the 3-5-2, as our current wingers are a bit shit going forward minus Januzaj, and Di Maria is not an easy deal to pull off. If we do get him then we can easily switch to a 4-3-3.
Not really, they didn't use one. He was the left sided central midfielder with license to roam out wide now and then when Ronaldo drifted inwards. Wasn't used as a #10 though, and Herrera would still be the #8 and Mata the #10. Just we'd have Di Maria there drifting out wide offering width and hard work but also doing the center midfield stuff, like he did for Madrid. It's hard to put in on paper, and it wouldn't really be a symmetric formation on either side. It'd be like Van Persie more central, Di Maria a bit further wide, Herrera more central on the other side with Rooney a bit more wide. None as proper wingers though.Yeah, I'm unsure how comfortable I'd be with di Maria as a no. 8. He played as no. 10 for Real Madrid last season, didn't he?
Fletcher - Ander
Mata
di Maria - Rooney - Januzaj
If he were to sign, maybe we could use this for the first few weeks whilst RvP+Welbeck are still out? The issue of what happens when RvP is back arises, but I think he could work as a very offensive wingback.
He was just commenting on rumours, nothing to see here.http://www.espnfc.co.uk/club/manche...1983286/red-devils-set-sights-on-rojodi-maria
Here's the Honigstein video.