Ander Herrera is a Manchester United Player!

Status
Not open for further replies.
Nytram Shakes said:
well either Mr Norwood is lying, or man united acted very stupidly.
Click to expand...
No. MU could have easily had Ander at Carrington without any permission from the spanish club. If MU going through the release clause route, that's not a transfer, that is unilateral contract breach from Herrera's side. And 36M is damages payed for the breach of the deal. That's how any release clause is structured in Spain.
So the only question now is can United's lawyers close the deal. As for how and why Athletic "turned down a bid" you can read here. They just probably refused to accept payment.
 
Lynk said:
If it falls through why wouldn't you? Honestly I don't get this Pro-Woodward brigade on this forum.
Click to expand...

Well I dont get Anti-Woodward brigade either. They want to blame him for everything that's wrong in this world and it's becoming ridiculous.

Lets wait and see what will happen and not make it its all club's fault cause it isn't right now. We made a mediceal, so what, that can be only good cause it means the deal is nearly done, its just Athletic making things complicated.
 
Look, before we entered into this negotiation we would of known that Bilbao were unlikely to just accept the bid.We would have hired the appropriate lawyers and the research on spanish buyout law.

Whatever sum we have to pay through this method we will be comfortable with, having known so beforehand.It think it is unlikely that we will have ton
pay 50m due to tax anyway.

I know some of you think the club is run by a bunch of idiots that can't get a tranfer through but the reality is a massive club like United will have done its research and be prepared for this situation.
 
Cina said:
certainly not as negative, but the grammar leaves a lot to be desired.
Click to expand...
I guess all the work on grammar makes people insane.
Pogue Mahone said:
This place is the newbs. They've been operating an open door policy for months now. As you've probably noticed. The caf has been a cluster-feck all summer.
Click to expand...
It's way too easy now, but it does lead to more entertaining meltdowns.
 
Berbaclass said:
In what way is us paying tax beneficial to Bilbao?
Click to expand...
Never said it was beneficial. It is beneficial to us not to pay the tax and they know this. They are obviously using this as a way to get more out the deal.
 
I'm not worried, I still fully expect Herrera to sign with us as soon as possible. It seems Athletic Bilbao are cnuts to negotiate with when it comes to transfers.
 
Nytram Shakes said:
well if we brought him to carrighton, it dosnt seem like they where expecting it.

im hoping very much that he wasn't at carrigton, and woodward is not that naive, and has done his research into how the release clause in Spain actually works,
Click to expand...

You wouldn't do everything we have done without examining all the possibilities, especially in a scenario like this one.

This bid was earlier in the week anyway.
 
Pogue Mahone said:
This place is the newbs. They've been operating an open door policy for months now. As you've probably noticed. The caf has been a cluster-feck all summer.
Click to expand...
before you came back the caf was a ghost town compared to the newbs. The new, more lenient policies may have lowered the standards up here but it's certainly more active.

anyway, is this really any worse than last summer? the same spastics were already here back then.
 
Mali_Zeus said:
Well I dont get Anti-Woodward brigade either. They want to blame him for everything that's wrong in this world and it's becoming ridiculous.

Lets wait and see what will happen and not make it its all club's fault cause it isn't right now. We made a mediceal, so what, that can be only good cause it means the deal is nearly done, its just Athletic making things complicated.
Click to expand...
Woodward was culpable just as much as Moyes last season. Fabregas, Thiago, leaving Herrara and Fellaini till the last day and fecking up Coentraos loan deal hardly left us in a great position did it? It's his job to secure deals for the club. Mata aside he's failed so far.
 
Earthquake said:
Yes, I'd imagine this bid was actually rejected days ago, and they're only announcing it now to appease fans(that they fought to keep him) as the other path has been taken and they can do nothing about it.
Click to expand...
Yeah. I gotta agree. This is more face saving and allows them to say they forced us to suffer through all the hoops to get their player, which Bilbao can do nothing about.

Cina said:
Athletic are a rich club who don't want to sell their best players. They always go to extreme measure to keep their players.
Click to expand...
Not just because they are rich. I believe it is because they are a very elitist Basque only club and will only field players of Basque origin. So even if they had a lot of money, finding good players of Basque origin who are willing to join the club is very difficult. Understandably, they are stubborn. I don't blame them. Doing this also appeases the fans, as it shows they are fighting to keep their players.
 
Balague says; "
It is a way for Athletic to say: we dont sell, they get him away from us and we cant do anything about it. Politics"
 
Lynk said:
Woodward was culpable just as much as Moyes last season. Fabregas, Thiago, leaving Herrara and Fellaini till the last day and fecking up Coentraos loan deal hardly left us in a great position did it? It's his job to secure deals for the club. Mata aside he's failed so far.
Click to expand...

That was last season.

He got rid of Moyes and we have a LVG as a manager. That's a start.
 
Nytram Shakes said:
well MEN yesterday they where confident it would be anouced today and he was defintly at acrrighton blah blah blah.....

could it be that they havn't a clue whats going on?
Click to expand...
Maybe so, but BBC have said exactly the same. BBC won't say it unless they have verified with more than one source that it is correct as is their procedure.
 
I knew Bilbao were up to something. They were way to cooperative.
 
Berbaclass said:
You said it was in their advantage to make us pay tax.
Click to expand...
I said they are using the fact that we might have to pay 15m tax to their advantage. Why can you not see what I'm getting at here?
 
Cina said:
before you came back the caf was a ghost town compared to the newbs. The new, more lenient policies may have lowered the standards up here but it's certainly more active.

anyway, is this really any worse than last summer? the same spastics were already here back then.
Click to expand...

True true. Not to mention that a lot of the most hysterical spacktards have been here for years.
 
Lynk said:
We aren't going to get the worlds best due to the calamity of Moyes and Woodward last season. We have to hope Herrera continues his progression, otherwise we'll be scratching around hoping for someone else half way decent.
Click to expand...

Yeah, as disappointing as it sounds, you are right and I/we have to accept that. I'm just worried we end up with another player pushing the £30m barrier that doesn't do the job we need and we fail to make progress. Natural aprehension I suppose.
 
I respect Athletic's policy with basque players and all, but if a player really want to leave, why force him to stay if you can't get any more money from doing so? Herrera didn't force his way out last summer, he stayed, made no fuzz about it and helped them make top 4. Show him some appreciation.
 
Lynk said:
Woodward was culpable just as much as Moyes last season. Fabregas, Thiago, leaving Herrara and Fellaini till the last day and fecking up Coentraos loan deal hardly left us in a great position did it? It's his job to secure deals for the club. Mata aside he's failed so far.
Click to expand...
Moyes basically just said in an interview that he was the one who didn't want to get Herrera at that price, he was the one who left Fellaini til late on and it's clear that he was the one rejecting Thiago for the unattainable Fabregas.
 
We won't pay all the taxes. We have to find our way around it now or else give up on the player. Athletic won't let him go willingly.
 
Cina said:
Athletic are a rich club who don't want to sell their best players. They always go to extreme measure to keep their players.
Click to expand...
They aren't rich at all. If I am not mistaken their entire revenue is only around 50m pounds or so and they have debt. But agree about the other part, that they want to keep their players at all costs (even if that means benching them, see Llorente). They're cnuts and very stubborn. Bayern apparently had to deal with the goverment there and only after they threatened Bilbao that in case they don't accept Bayern bid (release clause) then the city council will give the money to companies that Bilbao has debt, they made a deal.
 
Richard Cranium said:
So is the taxes additional cost the money that Ander has covered himself or at least offered to in order to force the deal?
Click to expand...

If we want him, it's the player himself who has to deposit the money to the Spanish League and buy himself out of his contract. That money is subject to tax, most likely we'll give Herrera the money to deposit at the Spanish league, but then that counts as income and thus taxable.
 
It does make many wonder if the club have the money? Because if they are haggling over a million, it is a concern, they got to realise the price will increase in a weeks time, and they can't agree a few now ? Unbelievable
 
It sounds like they actually rejected the deal earlier in the week (not today) but Ander Herrera submitted the documents yesterday so I'm assuming (based on nothing at all) that the documents in question would be us giving the player the money to pay the clause? It's just Bilbao being Bilbao by the sounds of things, political posturing, trying to appear in control.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.