SolidState
You don't even know how ITK he is
- Joined
- Feb 12, 2013
- Messages
- 1,821
Posted this one of him v Barca earlier too but the thread has jumped 10 pages since then, so...
Just watching now, many thanks.
Posted this one of him v Barca earlier too but the thread has jumped 10 pages since then, so...
so fellow caftards is this on?
Yup. That'll do me
I've learned something new today anyway. Never knew the beeb was so conservative on stories like this. You live and learn.
so fellow caftards is this on?
so fellow caftards is this on?
He has played as an attacking midfielder all season long, I am not sure it is the best signing but if it becomes reality I hope he proofs me wrong.
His passing accuracy is really poor, even as a CM he always averaged 80% passing accuracy without too many touches and passes per game. The only trait he has of absolute world-class quality for a DM is his tackling, he is brilliant in that regard but I think he is better as an AM than as a CM/DM.
Bit of a scary transfer if true, he is far from the absolute world-class CM's we should be after but he has all the potential to be a world-class CM if he hits another gear as well.
I'll admit to being a bit of a crap transfer muppet but I genuinely had no idea that the beeb were supposed to have this 100% accuracy record on all things transfer-related.
It certainly looks as though those Spanish reports are being rehashed. Will cool my jets until I see a reputable journo put his name to it and refer to sources at United.
Well that post rained on my parade a bit.
That's Cesc, mate.
United would have gone back in for Herrera if Moyes was still in charge.
His passing has been 81% accurate on the last 2 seasons but I am not sure that this is because he isn't good at it, or because of the system how Bilbao plays. If you look at their players (I am not counting defenders), Muniain has the best passing stats with 83% while most of their midfielders/attacking midfielders passing stats vary from 78% to 83% (with some as low as 72% or so). I guess it is more because of their system rather than because of their individual qualty.He has played as an attacking midfielder all season long, I am not sure it is the best signing but if it becomes reality I hope he proofs me wrong.
His passing accuracy is really poor, even as a CM he always averaged 80% passing accuracy without too many touches and passes per game. The only trait he has of absolute world-class quality for a DM is his tackling, he is brilliant in that regard but I think he is better as an AM than as a CM/DM.
Bit of a scary transfer if true, he is far from the absolute world-class CM's we should be after but he has all the potential to be a world-class CM if he hits another gear as well.
Is he any good?
After Everton refuses five joint offers for Barkley and Baines.Probably. Decent end-of-August €54m signing
That would make him a true Manchester United signing then, not quite there yet but with all the potential in the world to be moulded into a fantastic player over the next few years. I'm happy with this.Bit of a scary transfer if true, he is far from the absolute world-class CM's we should be after but he has all the potential to be a world-class CM if he hits another gear as well.
Nah not Cleverley. Need a proper creative player in the midfield. As much as Sneijder has been poor in the WC, it's that kind of calibre of player we're talking or at least the comparable role you should be thinking of.
If we don't sign anyone for that role I expect Mata/Kagawa to slot in there.
I think you guys are right. But couldn't Kagawa and Mata play as a front 3 of a 433 along with RvP? They are goalscoring no. 10s. We have seen similar systems at many clubs and NTs like Dortmund, Spain, even Chelsea iirc.I don't think there's any chance of that happening seeing as we're overstocked with excellent footballers who like to play as a #10.
I think it is important for midfielders to score goals because the forwards can a lot of times become committed to the inside of the box and if we don't have anybody decent to take shots in the space behind them and the midfield, then that's a lot of opportunities wasted. All those Scholes goals come to mind.Maybe he doesn't score many goals or take a lot of shots but the way i see it is that if he can help get the ball moving into attacking areas quicker than our current midfield crop... we wil score more goals as a team so the fact he may not score many himself doesnt worry me.
28m is the amount of release clause but apparently we aren't using it but we're doing a 'friendly' deal with them.Interesting that we got him for the £28m. Guess that mean we got the club to accept a bid rather than using the actual buyout clause? Or we found a way around the tax problem?
Would be strange if we actually convinced them to sell as they'll have difficulty replacing him with their Basque only policy.
Yeah, he's not like most of the current or new breed of Spanish midfielder in terms of his passing or touch. It's still good but not close to the consistency and consistent accuracy of Thiago or Koke. I wouldn't say it's 'poor' though.
He still has the quick-thinking and vision of a typical Spanish midfielder though, and the energy and doggedness of a typical English midfielder, so I think he'll be okay. He's a good blend of both.
After Everton refuses five joint offers for Barkley and Baines.
28m is the amount of release clause but apparently we aren't using it but we're doing a 'friendly' deal with them.
Pretty sure that's just his actual release clause.Interesting that we got him for the £28m. Guess that mean we got the club to accept a bid rather than using the actual buyout clause? Or we found a way around the tax problem?
Would be strange if we actually convinced them to sell as they'll have difficulty replacing him with their Basque only policy.
What number is Cleverley?So what number will he get?
He has played as an attacking midfielder all season long, I am not sure it is the best signing but if it becomes reality I hope he proofs me wrong.
His passing accuracy is really poor, even as a CM he always averaged 80% passing accuracy without too many touches and passes per game. The only trait he has of absolute world-class quality for a DM is his tackling, he is brilliant in that regard but I think he is better as an AM than as a CM/DM.
Bit of a scary transfer if true, he is far from the absolute world-class CM's we should be after but he has all the potential to be a world-class CM if he hits another gear as well.
What number is Cleverley?
If he's Steven Gerrard in his prime, then bring it on.Last year I read Herrera referred to as the "Spanish Steven Gerrard". Hope that hasn't ruined peoples celebrations.