This gets better and better...
cider says Fletch is the first on the teamsheet and you gave four players that you put before him but neither of you has mentioned Rooney yet so I'm going to stick him in too so now we're up to six players who could all arguably be the first on the team-sheet and now you come in with Carrick - that's seven names out of eleven that could be "first on the team-sheet".
Shit squad we've got, isn't it?
It doesn't make any sense, TMRD, i'm as baffled as you are.
Our midfield four at the moment picks itself:
Giggs-Scholes-Fletcher-Nani
We then have Carrick, Anderson, Gibson and maybe Hargreaves to act as back-up in the position that we're supposedly the weakest; that's £50m worth of central midfield players possibly sat on the bench.
We rely on Scholes and Giggs because they're two of the best players in the world who have proven track records of reliability; they're not young anymore, but they're not injury prone players either and each very rarely suffer from dips in form; when they retire one would assume that they'd be replaced with new signings, but whilst they're at the club and performing then it'd be stupid not to utilise them.
Even without those two - and the point is that we do have those two - our midfield is adequately covered. Aside from the unfortunate and unforeseable side-lining of Valencia we still could line up:
Park-Anderson-Carrick-Nani
Park-Anderson-Fletcher-Nani
Park-Anderson-Gibson-Nani
Park-Carrick-Fletcher-Nani
Park-Carrick-Gibson-Nani
Park-Gibson-Fletcher-Nani
Rooney-Anderson-Carrick-Nani
Rooney-Anderson-Fletcher-Nani
Rooney-Anderson-Gibson-Nani
Rooney-Carrick-Fletcher-Nani
Rooney-Carrick-Gibson-Nani
Rooney-Gibson-Fletcher-Nani
Bebe-Anderson-Carrick-Nani
Bebe-Anderson-Fletcher-Nani
Bebe-Anderson-Gibson-Nani
Bebe-Carrick-Fletcher-Nani
Bebe-Carrick-Gibson-Nani
Bebe-Gibson-Fletcher-Nani
Obertan-Anderson-Carrick-Nani
Obertan-Anderson-Fletcher-Nani
Obertan-Anderson-Gibson-Nani
Obertan-Carrick-Fletcher-Nani
Obertan-Carrick-Gibson-Nani
Obertan-Gibson-Fletcher-Nani
That's without even considering a five-man midfield, John O'Shea in center, Fletcher on the right or Hargreaves' potential return.
Sure we'd probably be weaker without Scholes and Giggs in the side, but so would any team if they lost two key players; and, as i've mentioned, they are in the side. If SAF couldn't pick a workable midfield four our of the many combinations above then he's just not doing his job properly; they're good players, good 'squad' players as fredthered might say, and we have a good squad.