This is called a strawman argument. You create a point that doesn't exist (not in Onenil's post, at least) and then attack it. The doubling down is good, too. But the fact remains that Onenil didn't try to absolve anyone, they were only saying that both Biden/Harris and Trump being terrible (or disgusting, to satisfy Dumbo) for the Israel/Palestine situation doesn't mean that they're both equally terrible (or disgusting). Are you suggesting that's not true?
(And since you seem to need that sort of comment, I'll make clear that I'm not denying that Israel is enacting a genocide in Gaza.)
Yeah, it's fecking not, and no, I fecking don't.
He's absolutely trying to water down Biden's administration criminal handling of 10/7 by downplaying it through the now all too common trope "Yeah it sucks, but a Trump administration would've been even way worse". As if it were true or some kind of badge of honor worth wearing.
Here are his exact words.
While it might be completely unsatisfactory [the official 45k Palestinian deaths], I do think the Biden admin is exerting more pressure behind the scenes than a Trump admin would have given Trump's actions as President.
The truth is that there's been absolutely no pressure whatsoever from the Biden administration, which has steadily supplied weapons and provided constant diplomatic cover (It used
four vetoes in favor of Israel at the UNSC in less than a year and doing its hardest to prevent the issue of a warrant against Netanyahu and Gallant). Every single so-called "red line" drawn by Biden have been joyfully violated by Israel without any kind of repercussions. On the contrary, weapons and money kept flowing at a rate completely unheard of since 1948, date of the creation of the State of Israel.
This despite multiple nazi-like declarations and actions taken by eminent members of the most extremist,
ultra-right Israeli government in history which were either ignored or downplayed by the likes of Blinken, Miller, Kirby and other assholes currently festering the White House.
Even better, a certified supremacist war criminal was officially invited to the Congress to take a royal shit on the US and American citizens protesting against his handling of Gaza, with both Democrats and Republicans cheering on and gleefully bending over to take God's chosen penis up their behind.
The Biden administration has agreed to and supported everything Israel's done since 10/7, and that includes the invasion of Lebanon and the strikes on Iran, despite the ongoing genocide in Gaza and the risks of a full-blown regional war. It sent a former IDF soldier born in Jerusalem (Amos Hochstein), as a "special envoy" for the United States in the Middle-East. How this guy got a security clearance and access to such a key position in the US administration is beggars belief. Or not.
That's what the Biden administration is and what it will be remembered for. That's what Kamala Harris is part of, and she never even remotely tried to put any kind of distance from it. Anyone believing in Kamala magically finding her shining armor and white horse to set Israel straight after the elections, is either deluded or an absolute cretin.
So no, for anyone who has closely followed the situation in the region, it's hard to think how Trump would've gotten it worse, aside from a "nuke them all" which would've prompted an instant rebuke from the whole world and I'm fairly certain that even the orange psychopath wouldn't let it go that far.
On a side note, words matter. I find the use of
"unsatisfactory" absolutely despicable. It tells volumes about the poster's mindset and his view on the conflict. It's even more disheartening because he's certainly not a braindead MAGA supporter. I've read and appreciated many of his posts on other matters.
However he's not the first poster whose brain crashes to desktop when it comes to Israel. There's plenty of otherwise great posters on the CAF trending the same way.