FA Cup Quarter-Final

Manchester United 1:2 Arsenal

Old Trafford

Kick-off
Mon, 9 March 2015 @ 7:45pm GMT
Status

Closed

Discussion Live Updates 63 Your Lineup Prediction

  • Status
    Not open for further replies.
    The Purist said:
    As an Arsenal fan, yeah. We were very lucky that day to the extent the game was almost torturous. Not sure how there is any debate that United were lucky in 1999. Of course you were. We missed a last minute penalty and you were totally outplayed in the CL final on a day where I can't believe you didn't concede more.

    If you take into account the quality of individual players then the Arsenal Invincibles team were the best ever in the English top flight within anyone's living memory.This is supported by the Invincibles achievement.

    As for this game, if we show up at anything near our best we will win. The only problem is we normally don't tend to do that.
    Click to expand...

    Convenient how everyone always forgets that there never should have even been a semi final replay as Roy Keane had a perfectly good goal ruled out in the orginal tie. Utd were also unbeaten in Europe in 99, won 3 trophies and lost less games in all competitions than the invincibles did. Going unbeaten was obviously an impressive achievement but I think Utd and Chelsea have both produced better teams.

    You rarely win anything without luck, Pires diving against Portsmouth and RVN hitting the crossbar with a penalty could easily have gone the other way and Arsenal would never have gone unbeaten.
     
    The Purist said:
    As an Arsenal fan, yeah. We were very lucky that day to the extent the game was almost torturous. Not sure how there is any debate that United were lucky in 1999. Of course you were. We missed a last minute penalty and you were totally outplayed in the CL final on a day where I can't believe you didn't concede more.

    If you take into account the quality of individual players then the Arsenal Invincibles team were the best ever in the English top flight within anyone's living memory.This is supported by the Invincibles achievement.

    As for this game, if we show up at anything near our best we will win. The only problem is we normally don't tend to do that.
    Click to expand...

    You seem to have forgotten that United had a perfectly good goal (scored by Giggs, I think) disallowed in the first game at Villa Park, so you were "lucky" to even contest a replay.

    Regarding the second bolded bit, that's actually quite laughable. Following United's treble in '99, they finished 18 points ahead of Arsenal the following season and ten points ahead again in 2001. A few years later Chelsea walked successive titles with over 90 points each time. Whilst remaining undefeated throughout a season is remarkable, it should be viewed in context - as others have said, Arsenal didn't win another title with that team, they failed badly in Europe, and they were beaten in both the FA and League Cups.
     
    Peter de Laat said:
    De Gea
    Valencia Smalling Rojo Shaw
    Carrick Blind
    Januzaj Di Maria Young
    Rooney
    ​
    Di Maria has been at his best at the centre. We need to get him at his best again. I also want to see more pace up front, especially against Arsenal. Carrick and Blind can control and distribute. Januzaj and Young keeping the field wide.
    Click to expand...

    I'd go with something like this also, the only question mark would be whether to go with Herrera instead of either Januzaj or Di Maria. I do like the thought of Di Maria down the middle against Arsenal, stretching their midfield at pace, but I'm not sure if we'd be sound enough defensively with both him and Januzaj.

    I expect the team to be very similar to the above.
     
    Northstand said:
    You seem to have forgotten that United had a perfectly good goal (scored by Giggs, I think) disallowed in the first game at Villa Park, so you were "lucky" to even contest a replay.
    Click to expand...

    think it was keane who scored, still no idea why it was ruled out, but hey alls well that ends well :)

    gooner fans and there invicible bollocks always crack me up, they lost 5 times that season and picked up one pot (still a great acheivement mind)
    but compared to 98-99 where united lost 4 games and picked up 3 pots its not even in the same league
     
    We have the opportunities to break them on counter and we have the player able to hurt them

    I just hope that LVG will field a good team tonight, able to cope with their speed, close the space in central midfield where their player all play. I would like to field Fellaini / Carrick / Blind, in order to control the tempo, and slow it, and outmuscle them in this area.

    I'm afraid we will revert to a more cautious 3-5-2 tonight.

    NERVES !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
     
    There was a guy who used to play five-a-side with us when we were teenagers. He took it proper seriously, and just before the game was about kick off, he'd shout things like 'COME ON LADS, LET'S F*CK 'EM!!!'.

    And we all be like 'Hmm. Well, can't we just beat them at a game of football, and then go home, if it's all the same to you?'.

    But his shouts were meant to be inspirational, and that's kind of how I feel right now. Like the guy who shouts mad things to cultivate an atmosphere of determination and will to win.

    Really, really want to see us get the victory here.
     
    Arsenal are the only top team I never get nervous about playing. Even Moyes' United managed to get the better of them. Bring em' on! :devil:

    ---------------DDG------------
    Valencia--Smalling--Rojo--Shaw
    ---Herrera---Blind---Fellaini----
    Di Maria------------------Young
    ------------Rooney------------
     
    NessunDorma said:
    There was a guy who used to play five-a-side with us when we were teenagers. He took it proper seriously, and just before the game was about kick off, he'd shout things like 'COME ON LADS, LET'S F*CK 'EM!!!'.

    And we all be like 'Hmm. Well, can't we just beat them at a game of football, and then go home, if it's all the same to you?'.

    But his shouts were meant to be inspirational, and that's kind of how I feel right now. Like the guy who shouts mad things to cultivate an atmosphere of determination and will to win.

    Really, really want to see us get the victory here.
    Click to expand...

    I know exactly what you mean. I've been suppressing a few choice words myself today. It's the best part of the football fan experience. The nervous tension, leading up to a game, where you're fully invested in the result and hopefully culminating in beating the feck out of Arsenal.
     
    Roboc7 said:
    Convenient how everyone always forgets that there never should have even been a semi final replay as Roy Keane had a perfectly good goal ruled out in the orginal tie. Utd were also unbeaten in Europe in 99, won 3 trophies and lost less games in all competitions than the invincibles did. Going unbeaten was obviously an impressive achievement but I think Utd and Chelsea have both produced better teams.

    You rarely win anything without luck, Pires diving against Portsmouth and RVN hitting the crossbar with a penalty could easily have gone the other way and Arsenal would never have gone unbeaten.
    Click to expand...

    Yeah, that goes pretty much without saying.
     
    8c3d20044d080d8a7d3a5c1509cfdcb7.jpg
     
    Siorac said:
    Forlán won the penalty, not RvN.

    And Keown, Lauren, Parlour, Cole and co. demonstrated that day that they were some of the biggest cnuts ever seen in English football. It was vile. That Arsenal side were a hateful bunch of utter twats.

    I sort of miss them though, the rivalry has no edge to it anymore :(
    Click to expand...
    Yeah the entire lot (including the United team) were a bunch of twats. But you know, as long as they're in your team you love them. These days players swap shirts and hug the guy who stamps on them. It's beyond ridiculous.
     
    Krovv said:
    Yeah the entire lot (including the United team) were a bunch of twats. But you know, as long as they're in your team you love them. These days players swap shirts and hug the guy who stamps on them. It's beyond ridiculous.
    Click to expand...
    You mean Andre Santos does? Not necessarily having a direct go at Wenger but it's hard to imagine players at many clubs feeling they could get away with swapping shirts at halftime.

    Something clearly dropped away from Arsenal's winning mentality after the so-called "Invincibles" (who were draw-experts, let's be honest.) Granted, Arsenal had the stadium to pay for, but Wenger has to take some responsibility for precipitating a squad acceptance of relatively regular thrashings and enabling the type of mediocrity which is demonstrable by their winning of one title in nine years...
     
    Siorac said:
    Forlán won the penalty, not RvN.

    And Keown, Lauren, Parlour, Cole and co. demonstrated that day that they were some of the biggest cnuts ever seen in English football. It was vile. That Arsenal side were a hateful bunch of utter twats.

    I sort of miss them though, the rivalry has no edge to it anymore :(
    Click to expand...
    I was at that game. Atmosphere was fecking immense! Hope it is tonight.
    If it had been the other way around United would have been punished far greater IMO.
     
    The Invincibles were indeed the best league side England has ever seen. Say what you want about it, but none could beat them in the league, which is a spectacular achievement. There was a bit of luck involved, sure but the fact that no other team managed it over a 38-game season shows how difficult it is.

    Also feck Chelsea. They were a great side but they also had the advantage of being one of the first to be backed by unlimited cash. In that respect they did benefit from having a top manager who knew exactly the kind of players he wanted to buy and a market that had only one club with loads of cash in the bag. The fact that even with such favourable circumstances they couldn't win the title unbeaten shows how big an achievement it is.

    For those saying Arsenal couldn't replicate it and hence they weren't a great side, you need a bit of context. We won the league in 2001-02 and were on course for the title in 02-03. We completely blew the chance to do it on the trot that year and the players have often spoken about how much they wanted to win the league because they knew they were the better side. That entire group stayed on for the following season, with the addition of mad Jens (Lehmann) and Reyes in January, and proved that they were the best side in England at the time. It speaks volumes about their mentality that they remained unbeaten throughout. That's in spite of Chelsea buying some big players (Crespo, etc) and having one of the best United sides as rivals.

    That Arsenal team peaked in 03-04 and from then our era of austerity began because the club had sanctioned the new stadium. Chelsea's takeover was well-timed and credit to them for capitalising on our lack of financial power in the seasons to come. I still feel the Invincibles were broken apart too soon but that is ancient history now. What doesn't change is the fact that it was indeed a brilliant achievement and will be increasingly hard to equal in the years to come. Chelsea could have done it in 04-05, but I don't think any other team in the PL era was anywhere near being invincible.
     
    What sort of reception will Welbeck get tonight?

    Applauded? Booed? Indifferent?

    I would be guessing at indifferent. He is one of our own but never really amounted to much here, and jumped ship in a somewhat sideways move as soon as it looked like his game time would be restricted. I'm going for indifferent.
     
    ipodnani said:
    You mean Andre Santos does? Not necessarily having a direct go at Wenger but it's hard to imagine players at many clubs feeling they could get away with swapping shirts at halftime.
    Click to expand...
    Not just that, but stuff like Liverpool players being all paly with morons like Costa in the League Cup semi and the pack of rabid wolves that comprise Chelsea's playing XI.
     
    Roosney said:
    This. Although I'm quite excited about tonights match I feel the rivalry is long gone.
    Click to expand...

    I have the same feeling. Probably due to the commercialization of football. Now that cash is king, there simply is less and less room for homegrown and born players and staff, it all has to be bigger and better in the global perspective. Players nowadays play for more clubs in their career, coaches getting sacked after 2 bad results, in the EPL most coaches aren't even British and the same goes for the players. No wonder rivalry is dissappearing on the field when most people on the field do not have any ties to club or country. You just play for the club that is willing to pay the most. I am not condemning it, I am no hypocrite as most of us would most likely choose money over a job. Especially with the huge wages that are being paid now, being financially independent for a lifetime with one signature. There is no room anymore for romanticism in football, it is all about the money.
     
    Krovv said:
    The Invincibles were indeed the best league side England has ever seen. Say what you want about it, but none could beat them in the league, which is a spectacular achievement. There was a bit of luck involved, sure but the fact that no other team managed it over a 38-game season shows how difficult it is.

    Also feck Chelsea. They were a great side but they also had the advantage of being one of the first to be backed by unlimited cash. In that respect they did benefit from having a top manager who knew exactly the kind of players he wanted to buy and a market that had only one club with loads of cash in the bag. The fact that even with such favourable circumstances they couldn't win the title unbeaten shows how big an achievement it is.

    For those saying Arsenal couldn't replicate it and hence they weren't a great side, you need a bit of context. We won the league in 2001-02 and were on course for the title in 02-03. We completely blew the chance to do it on the trot that year and the players have often spoken about how much they wanted to win the league because they knew they were the better side. That entire group stayed on for the following season, with the addition of mad Jens (Lehmann) and Reyes in January, and proved that they were the best side in England at the time. It speaks volumes about their mentality that they remained unbeaten throughout. That's in spite of Chelsea buying some big players (Crespo, etc) and having one of the best United sides as rivals.

    That Arsenal team peaked in 03-04 and from then our era of austerity began because the club had sanctioned the new stadium. Chelsea's takeover was well-timed and credit to them for capitalising on our lack of financial power in the seasons to come. I still feel the Invincibles were broken apart too soon but that is ancient history now. What doesn't change is the fact that it was indeed a brilliant achievement and will be increasingly hard to equal in the years to come. Chelsea could have done it in 04-05, but I don't think any other team in the PL era was anywhere near being invincible.
    Click to expand...

    I'm sorry, but there is no way I'm accepting that, or that anyone outside Arsenal fans would accept it.

    For me, it's impossible to call a side 'the best league side England has ever seen' when they had one good season, and even then only in one competition. That's nonsense.

    Liverpool won 7 out of the 9 championships between '76 and '84 and probably had a couple of teams better than Arsenal's '04 team during that time. I couldn't be bothered looking at how many FA Cups and European Cups they won in that time - I'm not into sadomasochism.

    United of '99 was better than Arsenal of '04, achieved way more.

    United winning three in a row between '07 and '09, while winning one CL and getting to another final, and in a period that both Liverpool and Chelsea got to CL finals (showing the strength of the league) was a greater side than Arsenal in '04.

    Even in the midst of a very subjective conversation, the claim that the Invincibles were 'the best league side England has ever seen' is objective nonsense.
     
    United 99' or Arsenal 04' I just think that we will struggle tonight against an in form team with an impressive away form recently, when we are playing shit since November
     
    Chaky_Best said:
    I just think that we will struggle tonight against an in form team with an impressive away form recently, when we are playing shit since November
    Click to expand...
    I think you lot will either win or this will go to a replay. Can't see us winning tonight. Playing "shit" or not, your team is very hard to beat.
     
    Most important game of our season. We need to win this. I'm pretty sure if we win this match, this will give the squad a big boost of morale ahead of our run-in and we will go on to finish in the top four.
     
    Krovv said:
    The Invincibles were indeed the best league side England has ever seen. Say what you want about it, but none could beat them in the league, which is a spectacular achievement. There was a bit of luck involved, sure but the fact that no other team managed it over a 38-game season shows how difficult it is.

    Also feck Chelsea. They were a great side but they also had the advantage of being one of the first to be backed by unlimited cash. In that respect they did benefit from having a top manager who knew exactly the kind of players he wanted to buy and a market that had only one club with loads of cash in the bag. The fact that even with such favourable circumstances they couldn't win the title unbeaten shows how big an achievement it is.

    For those saying Arsenal couldn't replicate it and hence they weren't a great side, you need a bit of context. We won the league in 2001-02 and were on course for the title in 02-03. We completely blew the chance to do it on the trot that year and the players have often spoken about how much they wanted to win the league because they knew they were the better side. That entire group stayed on for the following season, with the addition of mad Jens (Lehmann) and Reyes in January, and proved that they were the best side in England at the time. It speaks volumes about their mentality that they remained unbeaten throughout. That's in spite of Chelsea buying some big players (Crespo, etc) and having one of the best United sides as rivals.

    That Arsenal team peaked in 03-04 and from then our era of austerity began because the club had sanctioned the new stadium. Chelsea's takeover was well-timed and credit to them for capitalising on our lack of financial power in the seasons to come. I still feel the Invincibles were broken apart too soon but that is ancient history now. What doesn't change is the fact that it was indeed a brilliant achievement and will be increasingly hard to equal in the years to come. Chelsea could have done it in 04-05, but I don't think any other team in the PL era was anywhere near being invincible.
    Click to expand...
    I would argue (strongly) that the Chelsea side of 04-05 were a lot better than the Arsenal invincibles
     
    I recall reading in Gary Neville's book that he believes the invincibles weren't the best Arsenal team he had faced. I think he said the (02?) side were a a much better team than the invincibles.
     
    Not going to lie, last time I was this exited for a match was against Real Madrid in 2013. Gutted I wont be able to attend the game tonight.
     
    It’s true that if we manage to beat even unconvincely Arsenal tonight, it’s going to be a big boost for the rest of the season and another big game next Sunday against Spurs at home. It can be the victory to say “We are here despite all of you say, we can beat teams of the Big Four, and the second best team in England in 2015”.

    We have the weapons to hurt them, to win this game, at home, to go to Wembley and been one step from the final, and make our end of season even more exciting. I’m just afraid of the level of our players and I’m not sure if they can be up for the fight tonight.
     
    SiRed said:
    I would argue (strongly) that the Chelsea side of 04-05 were a lot better than the Arsenal invincibles
    Click to expand...
    Utd have had better sides too. And the fact Arsenal never retained really points towards them not being that great at all
     
    Score draw for me. Think they'll score first with us coming back I the 2nd half. Rooney to be motm
     
    I was so confident until today, nerves have hit me for some reason.
     
    Chaky_Best said:
    It’s true that if we manage to beat even unconvincely Arsenal tonight, it’s going to be a big boost for the rest of the season and another big game next Sunday against Spurs at home. It can be the victory to say “We are here despite all of you say, we can beat teams of the Big Four, and the second best team in England in 2015”.

    We have the weapons to hurt them, to win this game, at home, to go to Wembley and been one step from the final, and make our end of season even more exciting. I’m just afraid of the level of our players and I’m not sure if they can be up for the fight tonight.
    Click to expand...
    This all day long. Agreed, I always have the feeling that our current batch of players are just not as mentally strong. We will see tonight though. I'm really hoping they prove me wrong.
     
    I think Rooney will win this for us.

    3-1 with Di Maria and Rooney x2

    Hope to see :
    ------------------DeGea-----------------
    Valencia-----Jones--Smalling------Rojo
    -----------Carrick--Blind----------------
    Januzaj---------Mata-----------Di Maria
    -----------------Rooney-----------------

    Herrera, Wilson and Shaw(if fit enough for the bench) as subs
     
    Status
    Not open for further replies.
Post-match discussion

Man of the Match

David de Gea image David de Gea 76% of 632 votes

Runners-up

Show more results

Player Ratings

5.2 Total Average Rating

Highest Rated Player

Lowest Rated Player

Compiled from 467 ratings.
Submit your ratings
View full results

Score Predictions

396,68,50
  • Man Utd win
  • Arsenal win
  • Draw

Detailed Results

  • 38% Man Utd 2:1 Arsenal
  • 13% Man Utd 2:0 Arsenal
  • 8% Man Utd 1:0 Arsenal
  • 7% Man Utd 3:1 Arsenal
  • 7% Man Utd 1:2 Arsenal
  • 6% Man Utd 1:1 Arsenal
  • 3% Man Utd 3:0 Arsenal
  • 3% Man Utd 3:2 Arsenal
  • 2% Man Utd 0:2 Arsenal
  • 2% Man Utd 5:0 Arsenal
  • 2% Man Utd 2:2 Arsenal
  • 2% Man Utd 1:3 Arsenal
  • 2% Man Utd 0:0 Arsenal
  • 1% Man Utd 0:3 Arsenal
  • 1% Man Utd 0:5 Arsenal
  • 1% Man Utd 4:0 Arsenal
  • 1% Man Utd 4:1 Arsenal
  • 1% Man Utd 5:2 Arsenal
  • 0% Man Utd 0:1 Arsenal
  • 0% Man Utd 1:4 Arsenal
  • 0% Man Utd 4:2 Arsenal
  • 0% Man Utd 2:3 Arsenal
  • 0% Man Utd 4:3 Arsenal
  • 0% Man Utd 5:1 Arsenal
  • 0% Man Utd 5:4 Arsenal
Compiled from 514 predictions.
Show more results Score Predictions League Table

Match Stats

  1. Man Utd
  2. Arsenal
Possession
58% 42%
Shots
10 11
Shots on Target
5 8
Corners
3 3
Fouls
22 11

Referee

Michael Oliver

Man Utd Lineup

Substitutes

Lineup Predictions League Table View your Lineup Prediction