Zlatan Ibrahimovic |United Player | See the thread in the United Forum

Should we sign Ibra on a free this summer ?

  • Total voters
    1,389
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
Dumbstar said:
That's the lack of effort I'm hoping from Zlat. :p;)
Click to expand...
Tbf, I've only ever seen him play live once when I saw PSG beat Ajax 3-1 in the UCL the other year. He did little, was just ambling around, but then scored a worldy, taking the ball down, turning his man and then drilling it into the bottom corner.
The atmos at the Stade de France was amazing.
 
Jippy said:
Tbf, I've only ever seen him play live once when I saw PSG beat Ajax 3-1 in the UCL the other year. He did little, was just ambling around, but then scored a worldy, taking the ball down, turning his man and then drilling it into the bottom corner.
The atmos at the Stade de France was amazing.
Click to expand...

You mean the Parc des Princes, no? :wenger:
 
Flytan said:
They attempted the premier league at 35? Weird didn't think Suarez was that old...
Click to expand...

Your question
''Name one that had the skill Zlatan had when he was 26-27.

Literally no one.''
Click to expand...

My answer
''Henry or Suarez both played in England in the last decade and i would say both rival Ibrahimovic in terms of skill.''
Click to expand...

The question you posed can mean one of two things depending on how it is interpreted, you are either asking which striker has Ibrahimovic's current skill level when they were 26-27.

Or which other striker had Ibrahimovic's skill level when he was 26-27.

Henry and Suarez fit criteria for both.

If your intention was to ask which striker had Zlatan's current or previous skill level when this other hypothetical striker was aged 35 then you worded the question poorly.
 
Attila said:
Rooney done anything like this?
Click to expand...


Well not quite as good as that but yeah he has. Not sure what your point is though.

I brought Rooney up to demonstrate that international goals don't prove anything about how a player will do in his domestic league.
 
Dobbs said:
Well not quite as good as that but yeah he has. Not sure what your point is though.

I brought Rooney up to demonstrate that international goals don't prove anything about how a player will do in his domestic league.
Click to expand...
So we can't use his domestic league because it's too weak and we can't look at his international record because Rooney scores goals for England. I just had a look at both their records and Zlatans is a lot better since he started hitting a goal a game in 2012. Plus I would say England are a much stronger team than Sweden

Since 2012
24 in 38 games for England (20% of these goals vs San Marino)
34 in 35 games for Sweden
 
Dumbstar said:
It is a shit league. In fact it's so shit that only winning that by February is considered a sackable offence.

Playing for too long in such a shit league lowers ones own standards. Maybe not so much for players looking to break into 'proper' leagues like Mahrez and Martial but not great for done-it-all winding-down types with nothing to prove.
Click to expand...

I wonder if you have *anything* to back this up, or whether it's just another Dumpstar trademarked piece of off-the-top-of-your-head / out-of-your-ass thinking? :smirk:
 
Attila said:
So we can't use his domestic league because it's too weak and we can't look at his international record because Rooney scores goals for England. I just had a look at both their records and Zlatans is a lot better since he started hitting a goal a game in 2012. Plus I would say England are a much stronger team than Sweden

Since 2012
24 in 38 games for England (20% of these goals vs San Marino)
34 in 35 games for Sweden
Click to expand...

They always say you can prove anything with stats, and generally you get people wanting to prove things one way or the other.

Of course, to add balance, you should mention that Rooney hasn't played as the furthest forward man for us in a lot of those games. Which does make a big difference.
 
Attila said:
So we can't use his domestic league because it's too weak and we can't look at his international record because Rooney scores goals for England. I just had a look at both their records and Zlatans is a lot better since he started hitting a goal a game in 2012. Plus I would say England are a much stronger team than Sweden

Since 2012
24 in 38 games for England (20% of these goals vs San Marino)
34 in 35 games for Sweden
Click to expand...

I know it seems like I'm picking holes in his record but ultimately that's what happens if you want to use his record in a lesser league and international football. Genuinely I'm not just trying to find fault. We'll improve by having him here, I just don't think it's the best way to improve.

You've just pointed out that a bunch of Rooney goals came against San Marino. So obviously you see the issue with using internationals.
 
Attila said:
So we can't use his domestic league because it's too weak and we can't look at his international record because Rooney scores goals for England. I just had a look at both their records and Zlatans is a lot better since he started hitting a goal a game in 2012. Plus I would say England are a much stronger team than Sweden

Since 2012
24 in 38 games for England (20% of these goals vs San Marino)
34 in 35 games for Sweden
Click to expand...

:lol:

On a more serious note. If Zlatan played for England, he would have scored much more.
 
Last edited:
Downcast said:
I do remember. You have to know the atmosphere was much more impressive in the 90s and 00s.

You're right to underline Ibrahimovic needs nobody to score out of nothing and shine :)
Click to expand...
I had a preconception of French crowds being quiet, but it was great. The opposite stands were doing chants were one stand sings one bit, then the other the next bit.
The Ajax fans are brilliant. I've seen them six times in the UCL and they've been hammered in every match, but they keep on chanting.
 
Attila said:
So we can't use his domestic league because it's too weak and we can't look at his international record because Rooney scores goals for England. I just had a look at both their records and Zlatans is a lot better since he started hitting a goal a game in 2012. Plus I would say England are a much stronger team than Sweden

Since 2012
24 in 38 games for England (20% of these goals vs San Marino)
34 in 35 games for Sweden
Click to expand...

Probably worth mentioning that zlatan scored against power houses like faroe islands, moldova, iran, Liechtenstein, kazakhstan and montenegro in that run. Over 33% of his goals.

Not sure why san marino was mentioned and not that bunch of shit teams.
 
Not a question i suspect can actually be answered here but why aren't BBC or any reliable journalists reporting this yet after the skysports breaking news last night?
 
nokillingmoths said:
Probably worth mentioning that zlatan scored against power houses like faroe islands, moldova, iran, Liechtenstein, kazakhstan and montenegro in that run. Over 33% of his goals.

Not sure why san marino was mentioned and not that bunch of shit teams.
Click to expand...
Also scored against Croatia, France, England, Germany, Portugal and won the Euro 2016 play off against Denmark on his own.
 
God, we’ve missed a player with some cojones. Of course, those cojones are not big enough for PL, ’cause he comes from the French league.

On what he bought her wife for a birthday, he said: “Nothing. She already has Zlatan.”
Click to expand...

After former Aston Villa player John Carew took a swipe at Zlatan’s ‘pointless’ skills, he said: “What Carew does with a football, I can do with an orange.”
Click to expand...

When talking about boss Pep Guardiola’s treatment of him, he said: “You bought a Ferrari but drove it like a Fiat.”
Click to expand...

After dominating the centre-back Stephane Henchoz, Ibrahimovic said: “First I went left, he did too. Then I went right, he did too.
“Then I went left again, and he went to buy a hot dog.”
Click to expand...

When asked who he thinks would win Euro 2012, he said: “I don’t give a s*** who wins, I’m going on holiday.”
Click to expand...
 
Dobbs said:
Thats very good but have you seen Rooney's recent England record? Does it look anything like his United record?

You can't use international football as a barometer.
Click to expand...

I'd love to hear your reasoning behind this.
 
Man-United said:
Also scored against Croatia, France, England, Germany, Portugal and won the Euro 2016 play off against Denmark on his own.
Click to expand...

True, but Rooney has scored against Poland, Brazil, Uruguay and France, whilst leading his team to a flawless qualification.

I'm not saying Rooney is better but its boring how people on the caf try to belittle everything he does. Zlatan has scored against shit teams, just like rooney, but it was conveniently left out to try to exagerate a point.

His international record is actually pretty good, especially in the past 2 years.
 
nokillingmoths said:
Probably worth mentioning that zlatan scored against power houses like faroe islands, moldova, iran, Liechtenstein, kazakhstan and montenegro in that run. Over 33% of his goals.

Not sure why san marino was mentioned and not that bunch of shit teams.
Click to expand...
San Marino have won one game in their history and regularly concede a shit load of goals.

You can call the likes of Montenegro shit if you like but they managed to get results vs Sweden so the gap is clearly small between them. San Marino aren't getting a result vs anyone

Edit - I see they lost 10-0 today
 
Last edited:
150 people actually said no to signing Zlatan for free? Why in the world would you say no to that? I wouldn't mind splurging 30 mil on this guy let alone for free.
 
What will happen when Ibra finally comes face to face with Arnautovic, who has been doing a shit job of impersonating him for years.
 
Raoul said:
What will happen when Ibra finally comes face to face with Arnautovic, who has been doing a shit job of impersonating him for years.
Click to expand...

Arnautovic said: “He (Ibrahimovic) has always been important to me.

“I copy many things from him. But you cannot make a comparison.

“He has achieved much more than I have and he is capable of doing things that I could only imagine.”

Marko Arnautovic worked under Jose Mourinho at Inter Milan in 2009-10 PA: Press Association
The Stoke forward also opened up disappointing spell playing under Jose Mourinho at Inter Milan in 2009-10.

Arnautovic moved to the San Siro on loan in the Italian side’s treble-winning season, but only made three appearances.

He added: ”My problems with Mou started when I started going out five nights a week.

“I was injured and tried to distract myself in the wrong way.”
 
Quite likely he'll be a success at United..but this a signing I can never agree to.
A huge admirer of his ability but for a club trying to move forward, bringing in a player as a stop gap is just strange and backward thinking.
I remember the Blanc signing..if this was a Larsson type, yeah.
 
It's a decent signing, nothing more than that. I'm not as critical about this one as I was about the Falcao signing but once again I see plenty of people possibly expecting too much of him. He will solidify our front line and I expect him to bag around 12-15 goals in the PL alone because he brings the physical attributes necessary to succeed.
At the same time, I hope he'll understand having to make way for Rashford at times because continuing Rashford's development is gonna be key going forward. It's important to find the right balance and not hamper or alienate the talent we already have on board.
 
KikiDaKats said:
Quite likely he'll be a success at United..but this a signing I can never agree to.
A huge admirer of his ability but for a club trying to move forward, bringing in a player as a stop gap is just strange and backward thinking.
I remember the Blanc signing..if this was a Larsson type, yeah.
Click to expand...

Laurent Blanc joined United in 2001 at the age of 35 years + 8 months
Zlatan would join United at the age of 33 years + 9 months
 
Status
Not open for further replies.