Westminster Politics

Both parties are offering austerity, have conservatives social views and agree on foreign policy(Starmer backed the PM bypassing parliament to bomb Yemen and said on tv that Israel has the right to cut off water and food from Gaza)


.

You can disagree with policy decisions and I disagree with quite a few from Labour but in terms of gutter politics and nasty politicians, the Tories are in a league of their own.
 
You can disagree with policy decisions and I disagree with quite a few from Labour but in terms of gutter politics and nasty politicians, the Tories are in a league of their own.
_129301880_ftcry3sauaar9n3.jpg


Also Starmer said on national television that Israel has the right to stop water and power from Gaza. That’s a war crime.


It’s sucks that Labour are now David Cameron Tory party but that is the reality we live.
 
_129301880_ftcry3sauaar9n3.jpg


Also Starmer said on national television that Israel has the right to stop water and power from Gaza. That’s a war crime.


It’s sucks that Labour are now David Cameron Tory party but that is the reality we live.
I thought judges were supposed to be independent of politicians :confused:
 
_129301880_ftcry3sauaar9n3.jpg


Also Starmer said on national television that Israel has the right to stop water and power from Gaza. That’s a war crime.


It’s sucks that Labour are now David Cameron Tory party but that is the reality we live.

I don’t agree with Labours policy on Gaza. But I’ll judge them when they are in power. How much money have the Tories given to their mates and decimated public services. If you are comparing one poster to all of the dog whistle and culture war stuff that the Tories have done then it doesn’t even compare.
 
https://labourlist.org/2023/10/labo...ummary-policy-manifesto-party-conference/?amp
Out of that giant morass of bullet points and ambiguities what would you say are the top 5 headline policies that will define a Starmer government?

I managed to divine nine or ten contenders that seem to contain at least some concrete proposals, some of which might even have their own subclauses:
  • £28bn Green Prosperity Plan (implementation towards the end of the next parliament and highly dependent upon state of economy).
  • Minimum wage to be remodelled as a "genuine living wage" and updated to reflect a yet to be defined standard under the remit of the Low Pay Commission
  • Repeal the 2016 Trade Union Act and other 2022 anti-strike legislation, although this seems to be up in the air
  • Introduce a points based immigration system.
  • Introduce the 'Take Back Control Act', similar to the Conservatives, allowing local authorities to take more control over areas like industrial strategy and transport (bit short on detail).
  • Reduce the voting age to 16 (not sure if this is set in stone)
  • Renationalise the railways as and when contracts expire.
  • Free breakfast clubs and the overseeing of toothbrushing.
  • 13k more community police officers (or PCSO's); halving knife crime in 10 years.
  • 8.5k more mental health staff
There's an enormous amount of guff in the link you provided. Lots of meaningless platitudes like "break down the barriers to opportunity" and "unlock the potential of" or amorphous and materially lacking indications of future endeavours: We learn that Labour will "develop plans which will see", "develop policies to ensure", "set out a clear roadmap for" "deliver a long term plan that" and "introduce standards that will." It all sounds very exciting and yet despite its verbosity is very slight on fundamental detail.

My main takeaway is that that page is going out of its way to sound like it's a lot more than it actually is.


Edit: I confess I did try to read it all but my eyes started to involuntarily glaze over on many more than one occasions.

One down.
 
Last edited:
Well done Charlie Brooker. You won. We are now living in a big Black Mirror episode.
 


They're trying to chin him out of there

He won’t be leading them into an election, that much has been clear for ages. He’s devoid of charm, charisma and gravitas and on the contrary he’s actually a whiney little bitch that gets incredibly petulant under even the most minor questioning. He’s got virtually zero political capital left with any faction.

They will do the only thing they have left - elect an empty vessel of a populist charlatan. Honestly would not rule out a return for Johnson, Farage taking the mantle or someone as daft as Rees Mogg.
 
He won’t be leading them into an election, that much has been clear for ages. He’s devoid of charm, charisma and gravitas and on the contrary he’s actually a whiney little bitch that gets incredibly petulant under even the most minor questioning. He’s got virtually zero political capital left with any faction.

They will do the only thing they have left - elect an empty vessel of a populist charlatan. Honestly would not rule out a return for Johnson, Farage taking the mantle or someone as daft as Rees Mogg.

Well it's not possible for them to elect Johnson or Farage as neither are current MPs. Rees Mogg would be even worse than. Sunak as he has nothing but contempt for anyone other than extreme right wing people and his reputation is as bad as anyone in the Tory party.

The only person who could realistically lead the party into a GE campaign and get any kind of boost would be Maudant, but honestly, changing leader now would be political suicide. Everyone can see that it's just desperate to change leader a few months before an election and will be used as a stick to beat them with in the campaign. They may as well simply accept their fate now and get it over with. Prolonging this and talking of changing leader again could finish their chances of being the main opposition party, which may not be a bad thing!
 
"For the first time, global warming has exceeded 1.5C across an entire year, according to the EU's climate service."

Only 1 day after "Labour ditches environmental policy". Coincidentally also pretty much the only Labour policy anyone outside the Labour party could name. You couldn't make it up, and yet...compared to the government this party looks like geniuses!
 
"For the first time, global warming has exceeded 1.5C across an entire year, according to the EU's climate service."

Only 1 day after "Labour ditches environmental policy". Coincidentally also pretty much the only Labour policy anyone outside the Labour party could name. You couldn't make it up, and yet...compared to the government this party looks like geniuses!

Quite agree with you. I am very disappointed in Starmer U turn and it shows how weak he.
 
There's a chance that wellingborough won't be won by Labour - Even though the bookies have them as 7 to1 on to win, a lot of their core vote is upset with starmers pivot away from the left. . So any votes the tories lose to Reform (that ghoul Ben habib) will be cancelled out. Wonder if that will finally raise alarms with starmers people. The muslim vote is also finally starting to organise, with independent candidates starting campaigns in many so called Labour heartlands...
 
Good. Teaching labour a lesson will warm my heart whilst every national institution and freedom is further ground down under five more years of Tory government.
 
There's a chance that wellingborough won't be won by Labour - Even though the bookies have them as 7 to1 on to win, a lot of their core vote is upset with starmers pivot away from the left. . So any votes the tories lose to Reform (that ghoul Ben habib) will be cancelled out. Wonder if that will finally raise alarms with starmers people. The muslim vote is also finally starting to organise, with independent candidates starting campaigns in many so called Labour heartlands...
He will see the Reform vote and think “oh it appears I am in fact not far enough to the right”
 
Good. Teaching labour a lesson will warm my heart whilst every national institution and freedom is further ground down under five more years of Tory government.

Well, under Starmer's leadership you're effectively going to get another five years of it anyway.
 
He won’t be leading them into an election, that much has been clear for ages. He’s devoid of charm, charisma and gravitas and on the contrary he’s actually a whiney little bitch that gets incredibly petulant under even the most minor questioning. He’s got virtually zero political capital left with any faction.

They will do the only thing they have left - elect an empty vessel of a populist charlatan. Honestly would not rule out a return for Johnson, Farage taking the mantle or someone as daft as Rees Mogg.
Well it's not possible for them to elect Johnson or Farage as neither are current MPs. Rees Mogg would be even worse than. Sunak as he has nothing but contempt for anyone other than extreme right wing people and his reputation is as bad as anyone in the Tory party.

The only person who could realistically lead the party into a GE campaign and get any kind of boost would be Maudant, but honestly, changing leader now would be political suicide. Everyone can see that it's just desperate to change leader a few months before an election and will be used as a stick to beat them with in the campaign. They may as well simply accept their fate now and get it over with. Prolonging this and talking of changing leader again could finish their chances of being the main opposition party, which may not be a bad thing!
It will be Penny Maudant or whatever her name is.
I honestly don’t understand why Sunak doesn’t just say feck it and call one now.
 
You're right. Might as well vote Tory while we're at it.
You are. This version of Labour is basically the 2010-2015 Tory party.

It's just that the political landscape has shifted so far right that the current Tories are even worse.
 
On a day when the news ought to be focusing on Labour Green Agenda U turn, it seems that the narrative is more about Sunak stupid comment yesterday about what a woman is.
Has Starmer got away with it. Hope not because while I support Labour, I am annoyed at the watering down of a clear election pledge.
Especially on the day that we all learnt that our planet has warmed +1.5C.
 
You are. This version of Labour is basically the 2010-2015 Tory party.

It's just that the political landscape has shifted so far right that the current Tories are even worse.
What do we do though?
 
You are. This version of Labour is basically the 2010-2015 Tory party.

It's just that the political landscape has shifted so far right that the current Tories are even worse.
Yeah, and I absolutely hate how far we've shifted. I'm just detecting hints, yet again, of "don't vote Labour because they're just as bad" from some folk when we saw how that turned out last time. South Park's douche and turd episode springs to my mind.
 

I don't think either come off well here - to politicise and point score over the tragic death of Brianna Ghey just shows how far our politicians and parties have fallen. We're living in truly desperate and pathetic times when we have idiots like Sunak and Starmer as the best representatives of the two biggest political parties. England is finished, man.

Also, what was the jibe (re the 99% bit)? That totally went over my head.
 
Yeah, and I absolutely hate how far we've shifted. I'm just detecting hints, yet again, of "don't vote Labour because they're just as bad" from some folk when we saw how that turned out last time. South Park's douche and turd episode springs to my mind.

Don't worry, they'll be fine this time. They're appealing to the hateful majority of Britons. You can safely vote Green and The Tories won't get it. If enough of us do it, they might even start thinking there's some voter capital in not totally fecking up the world.
 
I don't think either come off well here - to politicise and point score over the tragic death of Brianna Ghey just shows how far our politicians and parties have fallen. We're living in truly desperate and pathetic times when we have idiots like Sunak and Starmer as the best representatives of the two biggest political parties. England is finished, man.

Also, what was the jibe (re the 99% bit)? That totally went over my head.

Is it that trans people are 0.1% of the population?

Does make you wonder. Is it not a strange fate that we should suffer so much fear and doubt for so small a thing?
 
I don't think either come off well here - to politicise and point score over the tragic death of Brianna Ghey just shows how far our politicians and parties have fallen. We're living in truly desperate and pathetic times when we have idiots like Sunak and Starmer as the best representatives of the two biggest political parties. England is finished, man.

Also, what was the jibe (re the 99% bit)? That totally went over my head.
I heard this argument on the radio earlier. That it was actually Starmer who conflated Sunak’s comments with Brianna Ghey’s mother being in the house and therefore it is Starmer that is political point scoring. I’m no fan of Starmer but honestly that is such a tenuous argument. Flip it on its head and Starmer says nothing and it’s Starmer that is taking all the flack because he let the comment go without highlighting how inappropriate it was. He was right to highlight it and to suggest otherwise it’s both sides bollocks.
 
If it's not a priority why does the British media and politicians mention it every single day. You, yourself said the boat people needed to be solved first. They do not want it solved. Distractions everywhere.

It is a priority for the media and politicians, who both crave the spotlight, they raise the issue in ways that attract attention. Yes, they know it cannot be solved quickly, without proper due diligence and a comprehensive migrant policy to back it up and that takes time, so they 'suck it up' with the public, takes peoples minds of energy bills, etc.

Where do you get the impression that wages in the EU are lower than the UK. The Uk were before the referendum( and still are) in the bottom half. Yes some Eastern European countries were below but they're catching up fast and will soon overtake the UK

Of course, remember Farage and his warning of millions of Romanians (under freedom of movement) turning up in the UK, its was this fear that the eastern EU countries will seek higher wages in the UK than they could get in their own country and in so doing affect wage rates in the UK. It was true in some cases but much over blown by Farage and his ilk! This kind of media coverage was the sort that remainers (in government) failed to address properly and it fueled some support for Brexit, especially with those living outside the main UK conurbations.
Paul you make regular comments here and elsewhere about how stupid its was to vote for Brexit, but you fail to also shed light on how weak and ineffective the Remainers were in countering such arguments... and the reason is because at the time, they couldn't. Like all successful lies, somewhere inside is elements of truth, Farage and co. were very successful in ensuring this essential ingredient in the issue of immigration.

How does replacing European workers with agency workers from third world countries increase UK salaries? Those lower waged people did the jobs the British workers refused to do and still refuse to do. So what are the British being trained to do if their better paid jobs will be taken by the newly favoured better trained immigrants.

It doesn't directly, companies in many parts of the UK economy have had to raise salaries in the traditional low paid jobs, especially after Covid and as you say after many people in the UK have been declaring themselves inactive in the labour market. Because of the low numbers available it became a 'rob Peter to pay Paul] (not you of course). EU workers as you rightly say are being paid better in their home countries and wont travel to the UK for work, so workers from the third world are sought. Trades Unions in the UK are at an all time low in their effectiveness, because when they get 'sandbagged' by employers they still tend reach for the 'strike' weapon, to solve all problems, not just pay rates. Consequently it will be up to Starmer to change this mentality, one way he might do it is to get something like the ITB's up and running again... but don't hold your breath!

Strange that the health service, education service , training services , infrastructure, transport etc etc etc are far superior in France than the UK , from personal experience , and yet they're in the EU. And French people moan about it. They really don't realise how lucky they are.

Not at all, as I've said in other posts, it was my experience in the UK that the companies I met who spent more time, trouble and expense getting their recruitment, training and management development right, were inevitably foreign owned. This issue in the UK pre-dates the EEC, let alone the EU, joining the EEC in the 70's did nudge UK employers to up their game, but not as much as it was required. This is an urgent problem for Starmer when he takes power, but I have to admit I doubt if it will get the attention it needs, not in a first term anyway... but we live in hope.