Is he actually an aweful manager though? What are his tactics like, in game management etc?
From what I understand from reading the Plymouth forums their owner or upper management wanted to play a certain style of football and he is trying to implement that. People are calling for a more pragmatic approach, particularly away from home where they've been dominated often so can assume that the style is somewhat open. Someone saying they wished they played more like Millwall who are playing ugly but effective football.
There's a thread wishing for Mark Robins to replace Wayne but others saying they doubt they could afford him and that he'd want too much money. Some pining for their former manger Steven Schumacher. Plymouth are run on a small budget for that division. They only just stayed up last season too, so it's not like their position is completely unexpected.
Still, the signs are just not good. As
@SilentWitness pointed out, their stats are awful. I posted some up the other day and they seem fortunate not to be bottom of the league. Their stats would normally be indicative of a team who are bottom. Of course, football isn't played on stats, actual goals scored and actual points matter so that's one good thing that's happening for them. You do wonder though, what would happen if they stopped getting that good fortune. They'd likely go down unless they actually start playing better.
They have:
Conceded the most goals in the division and have the worst goal difference (
@SilentWitness again)
The most xG conceded in the league
The most shots and shots on target against them of any team
Let their opponents have 551 touches in their box, by far the worst, next worst is Oxford with 430, that's just shocking to be so far behind
Made the 2nd most tackles of any team - not always the case but often points to a team under a lot of pressure
Made the most clearances of any team, see above
Attacking wise they're a little better as they've scored more than the absolute worst but there's still a lot of worrying indicators:
Scored 18 in 17 matches, ranked joint 16th of 24 in that regard but have perhaps been fortunate to score so many.
They've created the least xG in the division.
They have the lowest xG per shot at 0.07 xG so their chance quality is poor, they just seem to fly in a bit more often that you'd expect so far for whatever reason.
Are ranked 22 out of 24 for touches in their opponents box
Are ranked joint 23rd out of 24 for touches in their opponent's attacking third of the pitch
Opta
produce an expected points table, they're bottom (click the expected tab). They "should" be on 11.60 points if their results matched their metrics which is last place.
The good news is that they're not last and that the 6 points they have on QPR and 5 on Portsmouth is actually quite significant, albeit Portsmouth have 2 games in hand and have a home match tonight.