Wayne Rooney image 10

Wayne Rooney England flag

2014-15 Performances


View full 2014-15 profile

5.9 Season Average Rating
Appearances
37
Goals
14
Assists
6
Yellow cards
4
Red cards
1
Status
Not open for further replies.
He used to be a game changer or at least had the ability to lift the team up. But that was years ago unfortunately.

But he was United's best player last season apparently, which inspired United to a lofty 7 placed finish....
Because as overrated as he might be at times he is still at least 10 times better than some of our other players. So if I was him I would actually demand 10 times more than those players.
A bit of exxagerated statement but I hope you are getting the point. Also believe it or not, he is still the face of the club, especially in a time where the club itself is in transition on and off the pitch.

Lets hope Van Gaal is not the type of manager to take 'commercial considerations' into account in dropping players who are hopelessly out of form.
 
Does that include asking to leave and publicly claiming Manchester United doesn't match his ambitions? Or maybe angling for a move to Chelsea 2 seasons later?

Don't be obnoxious. Call him world class (I disagree), or say he has been rewarded for not banging a grandma in the past 10 years he has been with United, but please. Loyal and Rooney in one sentence?
Well obviously it does - since he was offered a new deal after 'asking to leave the club publicly' twice. 10 years at the club, on track to finish top scorer and club ambassador, loyal. I bet that is a scorcher.
Are you happy with his consistency?
Yes, not that it makes a lick of difference whether I am happy or not.
 
Well obviously it does - since he was offered a new deal after 'asking to leave the club publicly' twice. 10 years at the club, on track to finish top scorer and club ambassador, loyal. I bet that is a scorcher.

Is that still a serious attempt at discussing the subject at hand or just a "yes he asked to leave the club twice, we all know he was being a disloyal cnut and you are right, but my favoritest playah of all still got new deals, in YO FACE nar nar nar naniii"? :wenger:
 
Is that still a serious attempt at discussing the subject at hand or just a "yes he asked to leave the club twice, we all know he was being a disloyal cnut and you are right, but my favoritest playah of all still got new deals, in YO FACE nar nar nar naniii"? :wenger:
No, I am merely stating the facts. I don't even like the guy all that much but there is no denying that he is a huge part of our last 10 years whether some fans want to act like complete tossers or not.
 
No, I am merely stating the facts. I don't even like the guy all that much but there is no denying that he is a huge part of our last 10 years whether some fans want to act like complete tossers or not.
You are stating facts and glossing over details that are facts as well: wanting to leave twice (officially handing in a transfer request once), publicly undermining the club and only shutting up when he gets a pay rise twice is very much a part of his beautiful and romantic 10 years at United.

He has been here for a long time, and done his job for us but not out of loyalty. Nobody is being a tosser for recognizing that.
 
You are stating facts and glossing over details that are facts as well: wanting to leave twice (officially handing in a transfer request once), publicly undermining the club and only shutting up when he gets a pay rise twice is very much a part of his beautiful and romantic 10 years at United.
I don't care what he does off the pitch.
 
I don't care what he does off the pitch.
That generally makes sense, unless he does things off the pitch that are directly involved with Manchester United (you know, the club you support? Or is Rooney the one you support?) to the point that Ferguson looked genuinely distraught/sad in a press conference where he confirmed Rooney wants to leave... or when he is publicly embarrassing and undermining the club and manager... whom you obviously support (?).
 
That generally makes sense, unless he does things off the pitch that are directly involved with Manchester United (you know, the club you support? Or is Rooney the one you support?) to the point that Ferguson looked genuinely distraught/sad in a press conference where he confirmed Rooney wants to leave... or when he is publicly embarrassing and undermining the club and manager... whom you obviously support (?).
I am not Manchester United, you are mistaking support with vicarious personal investment. Grown men sorting through life's hustle and bustle doesn't conjure up an empathetic response that personally effects how I live my life. ie. Going on message boards ranting and raving about how terrible somebody who plays football is.
 
I am not Manchester United, you are mistaking support with vicarious personal investment. Grown men sorting through life's hustle and bustle doesn't conjure up an empathetic response that personally effects how I live my life. ie. Going on message boards ranting and raving about how terrible somebody who plays football is.
Seeing how powerful a medium the internet is nowadays, I fail to see what is childish about discussing football topics on it as opposed to discussing them in a pub full of drunkards or in an office with a bunch of suits surfing the net for porn?

A very old fashioned and easy road to take when one is faced with things he doesn't want to face: "I am above discussing this with you on the internets, on a messageboard."

And I am certainly not letting his behavior affecting my opinion of his footballing qualities on the pitch, I am merely reacting to a ridiculous statement of yours: that he is rewarded for being loyal. More like the club gave in to his demands twice, so he stayed.
 
Seeing how powerful a medium the internet is nowadays, I fail to see what is childish about discussing football topics on it as opposed to discussing them in a pub full of drunkards or in an office with a bunch of suits surfing the net for porn?

A very old fashioned and easy road to take when one is faced with things he doesn't want to face: "I am above discussing this with you on the internets, on a messageboard."

And I am certainly not letting his behavior affecting my opinion of his footballing qualities on the pitch, I am merely reacting to a ridiculous statement of yours: that he is rewarded for being loyal. More like, the club gave in to his demands twice, so he stayed.
You're not even arguing about anything anymore though - you're obviously upset that Wayne Rooney is a big part of United's history and you can't deal with that. The fact is - he's signed extension deals for whatever reason and is still at the club. Once again if that burns you then it burns you. No amount of trying to horshite around a lack of loyalty paradigm can change that.

He puts on the shirt, the captains armband and walks out onto the field and gives 110% every time. If he scores, looks pub spec, couldn't trap a sack of oranges, looks sharp as a razor then what more can he do? If you can't handle that then it's not my problem.
 
But he was United's best player last season apparently, which inspired United to a lofty 7 placed finish....


Lets hope Van Gaal is not the type of manager to take 'commercial considerations' into account in dropping players who are hopelessly out of form.
That's not what I said and LvG didn't decide to give him those wages. It was SAF!
 
History smishtory, no one can argue he has been a very good player for is, and a very large piece of our success over the last decade, what people are concerned about is his performance recently and his current effect on the team. Both clubs and players lost any right to talk about loyalty a Long long time ago. All clubs, ours included won't hesitate to ship a player out when his benefits no longer outweigh his cost, look at keane for a perfect example, and on the flip side players in general have absolutely no qualms about heading for the door the minute they don't get what they want, not just Rooney, 99% of players. What people are asking is are we at a point where rooneys and rvp inclusion in the team is detrimental to our overall style of play, personally I think it's too early to say and unfair to with the utter shit in misfield failing to provide anything for them, but as the season wears in it is a valid point and an important discussion to be has now stop being so precious.
 
You're not even arguing about anything anymore though - you're obviously upset that Wayne Rooney is a big part of United's history and you can't deal with that. The fact is - he's signed extension deals for whatever reason and is still at the club. Once again if that burns you then it burns you. No amount of trying to horshite around a lack of loyalty paradigm can change that.

He puts on the shirt, the captains armband and walks out onto the field and gives 110% every time. If he scores, looks pub spec, couldn't trap a sack of oranges, looks sharp as a razor then what more can he do? If you can't handle that then it's not my problem.

Horseshite around a lack of loyalty? I thought I called you out exactly because you called him loyal, so isn't this what our discussion is about (loyalty) or have you yourself taken too much personal offense because of my 'attack' at your beloved Wazza?

Nah, I am mildly annoyed at weirdos like you who still manage to call him "loyal" without choking on it. I follow it up by presenting you the facts, but you are trying to tiptoe around that by narrowing your view of determining what constitutes as loyalty (hands over your ears "Rooney is running hard on the pitch with an armband, waheyyy") and are trying to make this a case of a 'typical Rooney hater' lashing out because you yourself seem not able to handle reality when confronted by the facts.
 
Does that include asking to leave and publicly claiming Manchester United doesn't match his ambitions? Or maybe angling for a move to Chelsea 2 seasons later?

Don't be obnoxious. Call him world class (I disagree), or say he has been rewarded for not banging a grandma in the past 10 years he has been with United, but please. Loyal and Rooney in one sentence?
No. He went for something a bit younger this time.
 
I am firmly in the camp that believes he should have been sold a year ago, and that United will continue to struggle for as long as we try to play him and Persie in the samr team - although I think the reaction to his performance yesterday is excessive.

He wasn't great, but he is definitely not where I would start when looking at poor performers.

That said, the sooner he is dropped or injured or whatever the occurrence needs to be for us to not have to start him is the sooner this team gets going. Him, Persie and Mata will never work - and Persie is easily the better player for me.

He is still at the club due to the off field ramifications of selling him, I firmly believe that.
 
Horseshite around a lack of loyalty? I thought I called you out exactly because you called him loyal, so isn't this what our discussion is about (loyalty) or have you yourself taken too much personal offense because of my 'attack' at your beloved Wazza?

Nah, I am mildly annoyed at weirdos like you who still manage to call him "loyal" without choking on it. I follow it up by presenting you the facts, but you are trying to tiptoe around that by narrowing your view of determining what constitutes as loyalty (hands over your ears "Rooney is running hard on the pitch with an armband, waheyyy") and are trying to make this a case of a 'typical Rooney hater' lashing out because you yourself seem not able to handle reality when confronted by the facts.
You really must be incredibly bitter. Unable to string a coherent argument together without resorting to childish insults and going off topic to justify your hatred. (Of WR, don't really care what you say about me. WR is neither here nor there to me.)

He plays for the club when selected and gives everything he can for 90 minutes, I don't really know what more he can do apart from that. If you're burnt because of some crap that happened a few times off the field and want to have a big moan about it then more drama for you, enjoy.
 
That said, the sooner he is dropped or injured or whatever the occurrence needs to be for us to not have to start him is the sooner this team gets going. Him, Persie and Mata will never work - and Persie is easily the better player for me.

He is still at the club due to the off field ramifications of selling him, I firmly believe that.

Yep. I believe the people celebrating the fact that he has been made captain after a very short evaluation period (van Gaal himself said he had to make quick decisions because of his late start with us) and thus can not be dropped, will be disappointed in a year or so. He is holding this team back.

Scholes was right, he has peaked a few years ago.
 
You really must be incredibly bitter. Unable to string a coherent argument together without resorting to childish insults and going off topic to justify your hatred. (Of WR, don't really care what you say about me. WR is neither here nor there to me.)

He plays for the club when selected and gives everything he can for 90 minutes, I don't really know what more he can do apart from that. If you're burnt because of some crap that happened a few times off the field and want to have a big moan about it then more drama for you, enjoy.

That edit :lol:

You felt the latter paragraph was not enough and had to squeeze in an extra bitter appetizer to still your anger because I called Rooney disloyal. Heh...
 
He should have been sold a year ago, but Moyes thought otherwise and I don't blame him for that, he was in a weak position as Mr. Nobody in top level management, selling one of his stars to Chelsea would have sent the wrong message [am sure that's what he was thinking]. If Ferguson had stayed one more year, Rooney wouldn't be at United - Van Gaal has indulged him though and has handed him the captaincy = he can't be dropped, it's amazing.
 
He has been a problem in both games so far. He's dropping too deep meaning the opposition defence can close on the other striker in our system. When he gets the ball he has one option in front of him which then means he goes sideways. He doesn't seem to understand that he has to remain up top as a No.9.

Of course, the alternative view is nothing is happening so he goes looking for the ball. Well, my take is that's the role for Mata. He needs to stand up and start making it happen. Rooney needs to stay on the shoulder of the opposition and give us options.
 
He should have been sold a year ago, but Moyes thought otherwise and I don't blame him for that, he was in a weak position as Mr. Nobody in top level management, selling one of his stars to Chelsea would have sent the wrong message [am sure that's what he was thinking]. If Ferguson had stayed one more year, Rooney wouldn't be at United - Van Gaal has indulged him though and has handed him the captaincy = he can't be dropped, it's amazing.


To be fair nobody would have blamed Moyes if Rooney had gone. Fergie had already offered Moyes the way out. It was the shambolic summer transfer window which put Moyes in a weaker position to want to desperately keep him. As soon as Rooney got his shiny new contract, his performances predictably dropped to the base level of the rest of the team
I'd don't blame Van Gaal for making him captain as well as he has just come to the club and has to clear up the mess . Rooney's been at the club for 10 years , he is English, and is the most experience established members of the team, and frankly like the midfield yesterday, there is not a lot of alternatives as the leadership of the team/squad went in this summer window. But I don't think Van Gaal is the kind manager who will hesitate to drop him or even sell him for the good team.
 
He has been a problem in both games so far. He's dropping too deep meaning the opposition defence can close on the other striker in our system. When he gets the ball he has one option in front of him which then means he goes sideways. He doesn't seem to understand that he has to remain up top as a No.9.

Of course, the alternative view is nothing is happening so he goes looking for the ball. Well, my take is that's the role for Mata. He needs to stand up and start making it happen. Rooney needs to stay on the shoulder of the opposition and give us options.
He's dropping deep because the ball isnt getting to the forwards.
 
ahh, and so it's all Rooney's fault.

Funny, because on all the other player by player threads, it's their fault too!
 
Why does everyone assume Ferguson was going to get rid of him? The last thing he said as a manager was that Rooney was going nowhere. And there was reports that Ferguson blocked Rooney's move to PSG.
 
Why does everyone assume Ferguson was going to get rid of him? The last thing he said as a manager was that Rooney was going nowhere. And there was reports that Ferguson blocked Rooney's move to PSG.

Fergie said Rooney asked for a transfer. Fergie and Rooney obviously weren't seeing eye to eye with each other. Fergie saying Rooney isn't going anywhere means that Fergie doesn't want United to lose leverage in any potential deal.
 
I did make that point in the post
You claim mata should be doing that but he isn't either. Our Ball is stuck in midfield with two high quality forwards who don't even touch it cause the middle three has failed miserably to advance the ball. They are forced to come deep or we just wont get anything going at all.
 
You claim mata should be doing that but he isn't either. Our Ball is stuck in midfield with two high quality forwards who don't even touch it cause the middle three has failed miserably to advance the ball. They are forced to come deep or we just wont get anything going at all.

Mata is 5 times more intelligent than Rooney can ever be. Don't even dare compare the two. It's like comparing Andy Murray to Tim Henman.
 
Nothing's changed with him. Thought a summer and the captaincy would improve his game but its the same shit. He's so fecking slow its embarrassing. He never ever ever looks to run in behind centre backs. Why does he need to feint shoot so much it's so obvious everytime. He plays every match the same way. His every move is so slow and predictable.
Some of what you've said is harsh. We're only two games into the season and all our players are still learning to play in a different system. Once the team plays more games, we'll see better performances from all our players who are learning to adapt to a precise system. On the armband: giving him the captaincy isn't going to improve the weak elements of his play - what it will hopefully accomplish is raise his level of consistency, which has been a major weak point of his for a while now. What I do have a problem with, however, is Rooney's sluggishness on the ball. This deserves to be criticised and it has nothing to do with players not making movements or him not being given service against Sunderland (for those saying it does depend on those two factors).
 
Said a few weeks ago that the Rooney bashing would reach epic proportions this season, what with him being captain now.

And I don't much like being proved right, but there you go . . .

Pages and pages and pages of people criticising his ability.

While RvP, who was just as bad if not worse (as he was for the whole of last season as well), gets off nearly scot free.

Still think he's going to have a good season, personally, and will improve as it goes on. Just like the team in general.

And i'm not writing him off after two games, in one of which he actually scored a great goal.
 
It's demented. Every season the fans need a whipping boy. Combination of a herd mentality and desperate need to find someone to blame for any adversity (the last bit is a very modern phenomenon?).

Rooney is the most talented and productive whipping boy I can remember, which makes the witch hunt all the more ludicrous.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.