It was outside the box so red card maybe, but not a pen
VAR, Refs and Linesmen | General Discussion
- Thread starter Samid
- Start date
I really don't understand this UAE and Saudi argument. Infact, it actually dilutes the issue completely and we're almost allowing our referees to be incompetent because of these silly conspiracy theories.
The penalty on Sunday was obviously a foul but there are similar offences that go unpunished. The Haaland one later on was a penalty but there doesn't seem to be any consipiracy calls for that?
not sure i quite get the arguments about the freelancing either. If refs were freelancing in USA does anyone really think united would get favorable results? Think it just masks the problem that these refs are just incompetent or unwilling to overrule other refs and make them look bad.
Either way VAR should have flagged it for an OFR but didnt because they are terrified to give any decision Man Utds way.
Conflict of interest doesn't mean corruption. If refs were freelancing for Glazer owned businesses, then there is conflict of interest.
Pretty sure media would have run shows about it, if that happened.
The Glazers don't run the MLS, but if they did and they were paying these refs to come there and referee then it would warrant questions.
Michael Oliver (and others) are literally employed by Sheikh Mansour to do a job for them, and then they come home to England and we're supposed to believe that there is no way that he could be biased in any way, shape or form?
And you mentioned that they're unwilling to overrule each other but here we have a perfect example of a referee being happy to overrule his mate and throw himself into a situation that happens every game without ever being given, for Manchester City, just a few weeks after failing to send Kovacic off for two fouls that could both have been red cards in their own right.
You're looking at the argument from the wrong angle. This isn't about conspiracy theories, it is about conflict of interest, which have been proven by research time and time again to have a great effect on influencing the subconscious part of the human mind. It's a reason there are strict policies regarding gifts, especially in politics, but also all kind of other stuff like bidding/voting processes.
Would you see the problem if Liverpool decided to pay refs in the PL to freelance for Liverpool kids matches for 50k a game, or if United decided to gift refs expensive gifts before every game at Old Trafford? It's basically the same thing.
I'm not on any conspiracy train. in fact, It is the oposite. I'm close to positive that Oliver and any other ref in PL is doing their best to make as fair decisions as possible. Which should highlight the problem.
So would you agree that VAR in genereal would be better off staying away from intervening in these kind of offences? If not, they should intervene in all of them.
I wouldn't know as I didn't see second half but I'm sure there are plenty conspiracy calls for that one as well.
"Ball goes out for a corner and linesman pretends he doesn't see it and gives the rags a throw-in! fecking cheat." - BlueMoon, on a corner, 2-0 up.
The essence of my post was about something else though.
Start of this game is exactly what you knew would happen. 2 yellow cards for absolutely nothing.
And our club stay silent.
And our club stay silent.
Aye, just kills us straight away with yellows for nothing. It's getting ridiculous now.
But Joelington avoided one, when he just pulls a player back from behind…clear tactical foul that warrants a yellow and the ref just says it’s a foul
Anthony Taylor has been demoted to the Championship after a controversial decision during Wolverhampton Wanderers' 2-2 draw with Newcastle United.
Although the PGMOL has not offered a formal apology to Wolves for the penalty decision, Taylor has been demoted from refereeing Premier League games this weekend.
Instead, he will take charge of a Championship fixture between Preston and Coventry on Saturday. It will be his first time officiating in the second tier since 2019.
Although the PGMOL has not offered a formal apology to Wolves for the penalty decision, Taylor has been demoted from refereeing Premier League games this weekend.
Instead, he will take charge of a Championship fixture between Preston and Coventry on Saturday. It will be his first time officiating in the second tier since 2019.
Just before the Pool game, they realized Taylor was unfit to referee at this level.
Meanwhile Oliver who openly supports Newcastle is free to referee every other team in the PL bar Newcastle
It'd be interesting to see an overview of the decisions he gives against Newcastles direct European rivals.
Because he always seems to find a way to feck United over.
And that's the problem. We have a referee making such a bad decision that the referee gets demoted, yet according to the VAR protocol it was still not wrong to let the decision stand (paraphrasing from Dale Johnson's VAR review).
We should accept that the game moves too fast sometimes and that on-field refs will see contact where VAR shows that it's been embellished by the player, but it should be up to VARs to correct such mistakes. It should be the VAR that gets demoted for letting such a decision slip through, but instead he's fecked his colleague by "not wanting to re-referee the game". I bet Anthony Taylor is chuffed with his mate costing him £1.5k by denying him a match fee for the next weekend.
You'd struggle to find a club that like Taylor..Seems he change his fav from season to season
England's best ref my anus. Oiliver is next
England's best ref my anus. Oiliver is next
At least English refs haven't got this bad!
Woah woah give it time if happens against our favour in which case the media will be hahah how funny or in our favour or against dippers favour and there'd be a media campaign to get the ref dropped.
Making it up as they go along
No other club gets this treatment.
feck me, I've never seen a goal that analysed. Piss off
Hahahaha
feck var
They’re really trying everything to disallow this
VAR once again. This agenda against us is patethic. Just take out the team.
This thread will never die
This is not clear and obvious
I fecking hate VAR with a burning passion. I want it gone so badly.
Feck it. It's all too technical. Football is play on the pitch and not on fecking video slow motion. No one understands the law anymore
I give up
cnuts
That was an effing joke.
What a joke. If the club take this without complaining we deserve it. Despicable and a clear agenda.
Did i just heard the commentator said the officials termed it as a "subjective" offisde? How can an offisde be subjective wtf???
Ball is past him when he swings a leg at it and it’s too high for either player. What’s the point?
A subjective offside. Var can feck off. Also Ten Hag needs to give it to the refs. Fergie would have been absolutely furious in his pressers.
Fekkin cheating bastards
I don't even really care but that's ridiculous. That was absolutely not what VAR was invented for. Not even the most desperate Fulham fan would have complained about that goal pre-VAR.
The definition of clear and obvious has changed.
Surely to feck trying to play ball should impact the opposition? The only player that’s impacted by the attempt is Garnacho timing his pass across?