I have to confess that I had Utd & Arsenal as being in similar situations but they have obviously outperformed us.
Yet again, I don't think this is entirely down to being JUST our manager & his approach.
OK, Emery is new to the job which gives him some advantages - also he seems relatively sane & sensible,
.
But he can & obviously has 'gingered up' the motivation - he didn't give Wilshere a contract where we would presume that Wenger probably would have. It's quite a big marker being put down for the other players. He brought in 4-5 new players for extra competition & Utd didn't. Competition for places & a message that things are different now. Also the training is probably fresher, it's different, he might have got them fitter as some have said.
But for the teams & the level of ability & this idea that Mourinho is holding back Utd & the only reason - well there isn't a comparison for me when I re-examine the similar situation question.
Utd cannot transfer the ball around the park like these Arse guys, we can't press like these Arse guys & others, we can't leave our defence attempting to look after itself and trying to pass the ball out from very deep. The supposedly key personnel in the team (let's say positionally) just are not going to be doing that.
I would imagine Mourinho knows this - or he's got a problem if he doesn't. We need the lose this idea or the purity of the idea that we'd be briliant with a new manager, we really do.
I hate to say it but the thread titled about how average Utd are getting is closer to it, than the million of other 'convos' all saying the same thing all round the place.
As for Emery & Arsenal, I would think top London club would be the absolute best they might do but lovely to watch vs. the less good 15 teams in the League. They might even beat us for once if this carries on.