I’m worried for Labour. This isn’t going to be pretty.
There's definitely discussion to be had. But I think the obvious excuses cover 80% of the actual reasons.
Someone will do an analysis of where BXP stood / stood down and how this affected Con/Lab. In some examples it's really obvious where the shifts were, but a full picture when all the results are in will be interesting.
But...but...it's ok for Corbyn not to have an opinion, nor details of his great plan.
It just makes a mockery of a lot of opinions on this.
The Labour party need to look at just how they got this so drastically wrong, not just use it as an excuse. Add to the list things like not getting through their skulls how unpopular Corbyn actually is, and the lack of dealing with the anti-semite issues quickly.
I'm not saying you are, I just think we need to keep these issues in the minds of people because changing out Corbyn won't stop them. We really need to do something about the way press run the elections and campaigns of disinformation because they are anti-democratic in nature.
They've got so much wrong. You and the others who were out deserve praise for trying though on our behalf.
Meanwhile another Labour guy talking reflection and blaming brexit. This is never going to end is it ffs.
I’m worried for Labour. This isn’t going to be pretty.
The swing to the Tories happened in 2017. This time they kept what they gained and built on it, Labour crumbled.To be fair it’s not difficult to see there’s not much swing to the Conservatives, it’s Brexit Party taking votes which has caused for the seats to change hands.
How will SNP force a Scottish independence referendum? They are legally bound to the constitution aren’t they?
As an individual I can relate to Corbyn's position, but as a popular message it seemed profoundly stupid. Brexit is complicated enough as is, what was required was a simple message. It's not a simple problem but there's obviously no point in passing on that complexity to the voters. It just seemed like a denial of the fundamental reality of politics.
He wanted change and he's going to get it, just in a different way. Interesting to see how Labour re-position from this point. I suppose by the next election Brexit will still be there, but just an irrelevant nuisance, and they'll go back to the old battle grounds. But it'd be very surprising if they don't move much closer to the centre as a result.
I’m worried for Labour. This isn’t going to be pretty.
I'm not really sure what you're saying, that Labour should've ran on a Leave platform?Every single one of them are blaming it and banging on about "reflection".
They've got this completely wrong, of course Brexit was the biggest factor, but it's a complete lack of awareness to use it as an excuse. They screwed it up, big time. Totally missread the public opinion on that, Corbyn's popularity and god knows what else.
That's not a party who look to be actually "reflecting" with a view to change it's the same old soundbites and nothing more. Now we are fecked, and for a long time too.
It’s upto political parties to have a message that the media will support. What’s so hard to understand about that?Blair had the media.
If people think it's all just a coincidence then yeah it's going to be a struggle.
But either way I'm not sure how they'd approach changing that.
The swing to the Tories happened in 2017. This time they kept what they gained and built on it, Labour crumbled.
And then what? Show Boris your hairy balls at Hadrians wall?We are getting our kilts on as we speak and then we march.
The Conservatives gain Ashfield from Labour.
Gain after gain
Why didn't Labour (and Richard Burgon, Shadow Justice Secretary) highlight stuff like this more
Why didn't Labour (and Richard Burgon, Shadow Justice Secretary) highlight stuff like this more
All night long I've been told they shouldn't and won't. It's frankly depressing people can't at least see this cannot go on.
There's even talk of brexit fecking the cons, but really? They'll just make their own excuses when it fecks up and people will lap them up. Meanwhile momentum will make another shit choice and Labour will be just as ineffective.
They are well and truly fecked.
The Conservatives regain Kensington from Labour
Sam Gyimah was running there
I'm not really sure what you're saying, that Labour should've ran on a Leave platform?
In hindsight that might have improved tonight's results but realistically they've been in a lose-lose situation for years.
They gained 5% in 2017. That's my point - they gained a lot but it was masked by greater Labour gains, which have now evaporated. That's why looking at their smaller gain tonight doesn't tell the whole story.Where was the swing, Labour greatly increased their majorities in 2017 on the back of the kipper collapse. Now BXP has taken back the kippers and more.
Closer than I thought it would be given other results.Stoke on Trent Central- Snell (Lab) loses
Another Tory cnut out but letting another in by the back door.
Wonder if he had won had the Lib Dems stepped down, was under 1000 votes i thinkCloser than I thought it would be given other results.
Fair enough, it's a fast-paced thread.Christ, I'm not going through this again. I've a hell of a lot of posts since last night, I might not always have been the clearest, but my thoughts are pretty consistent I feel.
Read some of them if you fancy it mate, I'm too tired to keep going round in circles. No disrespect to you meant by that btw, just been a long frustrating night.
I think it's normal to go through denial after this kind of loss in fairness. Let's let the dust settle and give people some time to reflect! The message from momentum and others is very jarring, and it does feel like people are living more firmly in their bubbles than ever before...but let's stay optimistic!