Ubik
Nothing happens until something moves!
- Joined
- Jul 8, 2010
- Messages
- 19,408
Labour's lost Leigh, which had been a 50/50 tossup on the BBC exit poll.
I haven't made any incoherent statements.
I guess we will have to disagree, I've read too much philosophy to give any credence to an ideology that isn't rooted in the axioms of the left, yet we can agree the campaign and the last 2 years have been a disaster.
Maybe, but there were several different iterations of leave so it makes more sense to show people what it would actually be like. I agree though there were people who wouldn't want to take the risk.Might be what made them lose by a large margin. I know Corbyn himself is said to be the main problem but I see Labour voters also dropping away, probably Brexit Labour voters who don't want to give remain a second chance so you force their hand by putting remain back on the table.
Good post. Now do me a favour and try to see what I'm saying, if I can word it right that is
I'm not advocating for a return to new labour and all that, you guys just assume that's the go to because it's all left and right. That's literally all you lot care about right now, and that's not without reason.
However, regardless of brexit, Labour is split and Corbyn has failed to hold them together. Ed failed too. How much longer do you allow these failures before change is needed? You are we shouldn't lost what Corbyn has built, but we kind of have tonight no? This is an absolute humiliation. I said the other day we need a stronger speaker who can convey his core beliefs better, people kept saying we shouldn't have to have that, I said tonight that they should consider looking to move in slightly if only to claw back the floaters, I have been told if the right won't move why should we? (And also that I should vote Tory ). There basically seems no ideas or desire to even contemplating thought on anything, and when suggested we do, you guys instantly go to worst case scenario as if I'm suggesting you give up all you believe just because I'm telling you, and I am telling you, that this will keep happening over and fecking over until Labour get their act together.
What gets me is you keep saying the centre is dead, but what about all those floating voters. Of which I'm one? I'm not a true centrist at all, but I'm also not represented. It's flat out wrong to suggest everyone is now left or right and that's it, it's doing exactly what Labour have clearly done all through this campaign, completely missread the situation.
We need to stop these excuses, pick ourselves up and the Labour party need to find some way to pull itself together behind a real leader. And for god's sake, stop ignoring everyone and everything else and step outside the bubble and realise there's a lot more to this than brexit.
If I'm wrong to think all that, so be it. But at the end of the day, we keep losing and now extremely badly. I can't see how staying exactly as we are is going to change anything. Not in today's climate that's for sure.
On the subject of killing thousands of people, I am anti-war. Are you?If your vote can literally contribute to killing thousands of people, then don’t expect people to defend it for you.
Link?Jess Phillips going off live now. Can't say I disagree with most of what she's said about the loss.
You are a terrible person.If the Brexit Party hadn’t stood at all, the majority would be even more. As bizarre as it seems, Labour are holding seats due to the Brexit Party.
I think the party needs a night watchman while they groom the next leader for the next election. There’s no point in installing the next leader now and giving the Tories a 5 year at turning them into a boogey(wo)manLow turnout, ok in remain areas, devastated in leave.
For Labour to win in 2024, not just Corbyn but the left (Momentum) I think needs to get out for at least 5 years. A left platform will not be accepted by voters, something has chnged in 19 compared to 17. The centrists have a voting base to build from (young + professionals) and probably worse conditions in 5 years after the promised Brexit.
You are a terrible person.
On the subject of killing thousands of people, I am anti-war. Are you?
Sorry guys, we are, in fact, living in a country of xenophobic racists. Not only that, they appear to be predominantly traditional Labour voters.
Bang goes my plan of retiring to the South of France
And you chose to vote to feck the poor.I am analysing the situation - look at the figures. These are facts.
Isn't a lot of the shift from Labour to Brexit though? Not sure those people would have voted Tory, otherwise they probably just would have.If the Brexit Party hadn’t stood at all, the majority would be even more. As bizarre as it seems, Labour are holding seats due to the Brexit Party.
And you chose to vote to feck the poor.
This deserves a proper response tomorrow when I've had a few hours sleep.
For now, if you will indulge me, do you mind if I ask what your parliamentary seat is?
The reason I ask is that whilst I would of course love to persuade you and all other centre-left/liberal voters to join the green industrial revolution, to me it looks like Labour's more prescient problem in this election is winning votes from areas that have been devastated by Thatcherism and austerity and have feel ignored and taken for granted by New Labour.
that's what i'm hoping for as wellThe only hope we have is that, with a significant majority, despite what you think, Johnson has a Liberal outlook and will expunge the far right elements in a cabinet reshuffle.
Jess Phillips is fecking brilliant.
I work for the NHS. This shit ain't fair.He's rich and protecting his property. It's fair, selfish and perhaps short sighted but fair. Working class in the North and in Wales... dear god.
Sorry guys, we are, in fact, living in a country of xenophobic racists. Not only that, they appear to be predominantly traditional Labour voters.
Bang goes my plan of retiring to the South of France
That was my point exactly. New guy is AmericanBucket head is a fake now anyway, binface is the guy who was the original buckethead
Too right. Gotta be bin it to win itBuckethead has become too right wing - just look at the quality of his clothes. Binface is a Man of the People™