Transfer Tweets - Summer 2015 | Stop Spamming - Discussion Should Relate to Tweets

Status
Not open for further replies.
If Pogba signs for City we'll not hear the end of it. Operation Small-time will rush into effect.

I was expecting him to go there when it first became clear he was leaving us - it felt like the Tevez situation all over again, right down to the sulking. A little ironic that he'd be succeeding Toure there since I remember a thread in the United forum after (I think) the Kompany-winner derby that asked who we could get to match Toure, and some mentioned that we didn't need anyone since we had Pogba coming through in the ranks :mad:

Our best hope is I think if the Spanish two come in for him then he'd go to them, as we all know that no player can resist Real or Barca. Except Aguero obviously... damn :(
 
High comedy if true. Isn't that what we bought him for.

It's an impossible situation for us.

We started negotiations over a new contract for him in early 2013 when he had been here for less than 2 years and had over 3 years left to run. A perfectly reasonable timescale on our part.

So it's dragged on with no signature for 2 years now which begs the question; what is the right thing to do in this situation?

1. Bite the bullet and sell him last season for proper money. Well Real weren't sniffing last season and had just bought Navas so that wasn't a likely option, especially if we are actively looking to sell the price goes down. I'm glad we had him this year and seeing that the word is that he is genuinely unsure it would have been a bit hasty.

2. Sell him for the highest possible price this season. With only a year left on his contract and only Madrid in the running, we really can't expect too much.

3. Make him stay and see out his contract. What sort of player will we see? An uninterested and unmotivated one? If Madrid can't sign him next summer due to their ban we could really ruin his career plans and that doesn't reflect well on any club for incoming players.


So what can you do? My take on the scenario is that Mendes has fecked us over. De Gea has known for a while he's wanted to leave and they are quite happy to run the contract down and negotiate on their own terms.
 
@Pexbo So I'm not the only one that heard about contract negotiations for a long time?
 
3. Make him stay and see out his contract. What sort of player will we see? An uninterested and unmotivated one? If Madrid can't sign him next summer due to their ban we could really ruin his career plans and that doesn't reflect well on any club for incoming players.

He's a keeper, a pro and presumably desperate to start for Spain at Euro 2016. He'll try to keep the ball out of the net even if he wears a "feck Woodward" t-shirt under his jersey.

Having money is for employing world class players in their prime.
 
I wonder how his wages compare...

Not picking on you, but I hate this sort of comparison. Fulham never had a chance at any time to sign Marchisio, Khedira, Pogba or Pirlo and Vidal moved to Leverkusen at 20, so they would have had to have been in for him at 19 or younger.

It's like Real Madrid about to get De Gea for 18 million pounds. Atletico paid about 2/3rds of that for Oblak, but it's disingenuous to compare them. I guarantee they'd have shelled out the extra 6 to buy De Gea back if that was an option.
 
There's a realistic narrative here in that Benitez is rumoured to want to move Cristiano up front to make the team more solid defensively, which would mean reducing Benzema's minutes, so if he then leaves for us, Arsenal, or whoever, they would need a 9 willing to sit on the bench and come on with 15 minutes to go and Icardi makes sense for that role.

If he wants to go and they'll pay enough to satisfy Inter, I don't think a new contract would stand in the way. It might give Inter enough leverage that Madrid end up shopping elsewhere.

There's no chance Icardi, one of the best young players in world football, having just signed a new contract to 2019 at Inter, would be willing to go to a club where he will warm the bench.
 

Just fecking imagine if Falcao goes to Liverpool after all of their fans laughed their heads off and made fun of him nonstop all of last season. :lol:
 
Just fecking imagine if Falcao goes to Liverpool after all of their fans laughed their heads off and made fun of him nonstop all of last season. :lol:
And the Chelsea fans didn't?
 
And the Chelsea fans didn't?
Yes, but if we signed him he'd be 2nd or 3rd choice because we already have a world class #9. They'd be signing him as a major player that would get significant playing time.
 
Just fecking imagine if Falcao goes to Liverpool after all of their fans laughed their heads off and made fun of him nonstop all of last season. :lol:
Yeah, just imagine if he goes to Liverpool and starts banging in goals like he used to.
 
Yeah, just imagine if he goes to Liverpool and starts banging in goals like he used to.

That has about same chance of happening as Torres did at Chelsea... After they both came from injury they never looked to be the same player. Let Liverpool have him...doubt he'd want to go there tho.
 
It's an impossible situation for us.

We started negotiations over a new contract for him in early 2013 when he had been here for less than 2 years and had over 3 years left to run. A perfectly reasonable timescale on our part.

So it's dragged on with no signature for 2 years now which begs the question; what is the right thing to do in this situation?

1. Bite the bullet and sell him last season for proper money. Well Real weren't sniffing last season and had just bought Navas so that wasn't a likely option, especially if we are actively looking to sell the price goes down. I'm glad we had him this year and seeing that the word is that he is genuinely unsure it would have been a bit hasty.

2. Sell him for the highest possible price this season. With only a year left on his contract and only Madrid in the running, we really can't expect too much.

3. Make him stay and see out his contract. What sort of player will we see? An uninterested and unmotivated one? If Madrid can't sign him next summer due to their ban we could really ruin his career plans and that doesn't reflect well on any club for incoming players.


So what can you do? My take on the scenario is that Mendes has fecked us over. De Gea has known for a while he's wanted to leave and they are quite happy to run the contract down and negotiate on their own terms.
If DDG and Mendes have actually screwed us over having planned the damn thing, wtf would we care if we throw a spanner in his "career plans". It is not like we are chopping away his limbs or selling him away to slavery
We have supposedly offered him a hige contract and the chance to continue playing for one of the biggest clubs in the world. Of RM get a transfer ban and DDG is unable to join them, well bad luck.

As for whether it would affect any new players from joining us, I really really doubt that will happen. We are not willing to get bent over and that is a normal scenario. If players were put off by such small things, Spurs would never be able to sign another player, ever!
 
There's no chance Icardi, one of the best young players in world football, having just signed a new contract to 2019 at Inter, would be willing to go to a club where he will warm the bench.

Madrid aren't "a club", especially to an Argentine, and he ain't one of the best young players in world football.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.