Di Maria a "best player" for United? Really?
Transfer Tweets - Summer 2015 | Stop Spamming - Discussion Should Relate to Tweets
- Thread starter Rado_N
- Start date
- Status
not coming of the back of a great season but still one of the most talented in our squad, yes.
you disagree ?
Yes. Despite a mixed firstly season where he struggled with injuries, struggled with off field problems he still created more chances than anyone else in less games played. To let him go after one season is poor from us.
I'm sure the surprise is the signing of Pedro!
Of course he disagrees. He gets pleasure out of new signings not playing as well as they should, rather than supporting them. Was the same with Herrera about a week after we signed him too. Seems as though people are commited to adm leaving because they are worried they will be proved wrong about him next season.
He also created more chances for our opponents than any other player - and as for his many assists, the majority of them were easy passes or mishit shots.
So you agree with selling him? AdM has turnt in to a bad player in one season? Who'd you bring in to replace him?
Yeah... we shouldn't be selling our best players... De Gea to Madrid and di Maria to PSG would be two of our most talented players gone in one window.
There is agreement and Sergio Romero signed for 3 years to be the new goalkeeper Manchester Utd
Yeh like sale and Man City
So did i.I read that as Sergio Ramos.
Just wait a few days.I read that as Sergio Ramos.
As a United fan I was just imagining Sergio Ramos in goal with Ander Herrera as his backup.
That's very true
Considering he got assigned 'assists' at 2.00 and 2.05 you've got to take his stats with a pinch of salt. Not because he doesn't deserve them, but because he's unlikely to pull off so many flukes next season.
..and an absolutely cringey one to boot.
The cringeness is the element that irks me the most - it's like nails on a blackboard hearing him speak!
Youngs 2 goals came from a tim krul pass and a mix up with hart and a city defender. Should we take those with a pinch of salt too, or just forget that Di Maria is more than capable of creating chances from nothing more so than anybody else on our team? What about the chances he created that were wasted? Do you think all of Fabregas and Hazards assists were perfect through balls and crosses?
"He makes things happen."
Yeah it's funny how Di Maria "gets lucky" every single season.
Or, you know... people need beating with a stick until they stop talking bollocks.
Or, you know... people need beating with a stick until they stop talking bollocks.
Young adds a lot to team play. ADM doesn't. The latter's only redeeming quality is his supposedly amazing end product. I personally think it's an over-inflated statistic which United can't rely upon him repeating. I simply don't see the quality that all the La Liga fans have been harping on about.
He certainly did when he played at RM. Why can't he repeat it? If anything he can only improve it.
Am I right in thinking he has played for LVG before at AZ or am I getting mixed up with another goalie?
If di Maria is sold it will because he has given up on United, not the other way around. Could be that he doesn't like the system or the off the field issues are too much for him and if thats the case there's not a whole lot we can we do to keep him. He showed last season that these things affect his performance (say compared to Ronaldo when he stayed the extra season) so there's no point asking him to be porfessional and see out his contract.
LvG has said it is up to the player. If he goes it is his choice.
What 2? And if the rest were mostly easy passes does it not beg the question why nobody else made that many, if they were all so much better than him?
Don't get me wrong, he wasn't great last season but its not like its inexplicable why that was. To me selling him now would be utter madness, especially if we don't get 100% of our money back for him and even then, who out is out there to replace him?
That was him. LVG bought him from Argentina.
Pedro, Griezmann, Reus to name a few. There are plenty players out there who could replace him.
I don't think it would make any difference, they're too thick. Let's sell ADM and buy Pedro, that must be an improvement, what planet are some people on!
Kind of thing that annoys me.... lets not downgrade his quality, he gets assists because he has quality end of.
He had a poor season, call a spade a spade, lets not act like he doesn't create bags of chances
Maybe he's lost it like countless other players seem to have done (including Nani, whom he's constantly getting compared to). Or maybe he's unable to play under LvG's philosophy and will be shipped out along with Valdes.
I've watched every minute he's had in a United shirt and don't see much worth keeping. If LvG is considering selling him, he obviously thinks the same. It's not like we've been desperate to hold onto him the way we have been with De Gea.
Either way, it's a gamble. But the most important and relevant showings are the ones he's had for Manchester United. Not the ones for Real Madrid. Judging by those, I'd be happy to sell.
Right I thought it was!
I'd add the freekick goal and the two assists for Rooney and Mata's wondergoals to the list.
Or maybe he had a difficult first season in the EPL... I mean its not like its ever happened before
The Prem (as a whole) maybe have better defensive players than in La Liga - its part of the DNA of English football & key players like Di Maria get double-marked - sometimes triple-marked too?
La Liga seem to have quality individual defenders, but not whole teams of them - bar Atletico & Barca; where they both defend as a team unit much more efficiently than the others..
thats him gone then, so long has we get nearly our money back, will be sad to see him go.
so what is better , having players in the team that want to play here or keeping players that clearly don't want to be here (if you believe what is being written)
Best player or not if a player want to leave then let him.
Keegan's just read the Goal France report from 3 weeks ago when PSG "opened talks with United and ADM agreed a pre-contract " and have since met 73 times but no-one has agreed anything
Im already bored of this debate, it would be mad to get rid unless he specifically wants to leave. Its not exactly unusual for players to have a bad season when making a move to a new club and especially country, but if it happens all of a sudden thats apparently their level, it works the same way with players having one good season and suddenly being worth stupid amounts of money and thats why you end up paying 35 million for andy fecking carroll. All we would be doing if we wanted rid is making the same mistake liverpool did but in reverse.
Hopefully it's all b.sKeegan's just read the Goal France report from 3 weeks ago when PSG "opened talks with United and ADM agreed a pre-contract " and have since met 73 times but no-one has agreed anything
Regardless of how you think he did this season, losing him would be a disappointing. I don't think anyone could disagree.
- Status