Transfer Tweets - Manchester United - 2023/24
- Thread starter mazhar13
- Start date
- Status
For a squad player to pay 40M seems to me to be a bad decision. Sign players who are going to be starters and for squad depth young players from the academy. Or players who finish their contracts.
Just don‘t, I beg of you.
Exactly!
Some of you clearly don't watch Leicester or KDH. If you want someone who can recieve the ball under pressure, carry the ball well and pass the ball forward extremely well he would be a fantastic signing. 10 goals and 12 assists this season. He is clearly not average and he has come into his own this season.
United's plan is to sign him on a discount. There's no other reason to inquire about him otherwise. Leicester can value him at £40m all they want, but United aren't necessarily looking to bring him in at all costs. From the original article, if Leicester don't get promoted, then he has a gentleman's agreement to leave the club for a lower fee. That's where the £25m guaranteed fee comes from in the UtdDistrict Tweet.
The original Tweet with the key context (Tier 2):
Have you seen him play ?
I have no idea how good or bad this guy is but if he is being signed to improve the starting eleven, I am all for it. I am against the idea of spending millions of pounds on squad fillers when we have gaping holes throughout our team. We need players who will come in and improve the starting eleven.
Absolutely agreed, hence why I'd be more than happy taking a look at him.
Direction of travel
Well I think most signings are to improve the squad, it's up to them to make the starting XI. He is better than Eriksen and Amrabaat and they've played a fair few minutes for us.
Spot on, not entirely sure where he'd fit, but I assume an Eriksen replacement.
I have very much seen this lad play. He was on loan here at Blackpool and he has great vision, can pick a pass, and the lad can score goal‘s too. Is he united Quality no idea but look how Maddison who is doing well at spurs and this lad is just as Good and he has a great attitude to go with it.
In my opinion he's been the best player in the championship this season and oozes class every time I've watched Leicester. Whether we buy him or not the lad is destined to play at a higher level.
He's playing in the Championship, those sort of numbers don't mean anything. He got 2 goals and 2 assists in his last PL season. Diallo got 13 goals and 3 assists for a weaker team in the Championship and he hasn't got a look in. KDH is probably being looked at as a cheap squad option due to Leicester's financial issues that would also count as home grown. This is the type of deal I'm ok with only if all our more important positions are addressed first. Tbh, at 25 years old I don't think he's good enough for Utd at all.
South
For 40M United would be interested in signing him? In other words, that 15M difference can bring the signing down? I have never seen the player.
That's because the guy in charge would rather see Antony stink up the place.
Dewsbury hall is the sort of player the CAF turns their noses up at who will go to a Chelsea or an Arsenal & then moan why “we don’t make these type of signings”
For a player like him, yeah, especially when United have other needs to address, such as a new striker and a younger, more athletic centre back. A midfielder like him would only be an opportunistic signing, and he'll fight for a place in the team as an attacking #8 along with Mount, McTominay, and Bruno.
Like him hes a good player, for the right price would be a good option
Or he's the type of player who Chelsea would sell to Spurs.
With this Jim takeover , we are going to be linked with 100x the amount of players we were linked with last season.
Extended quotes:
Last edited:
Exactly, watching him against Chelsea he looked very much the best midfielder on the pitch as well.
Of course they do. So what, he's clearly improved since? Diallo isn't even a similar player, don't really understand the comparison.
He's being monitored because he's good. If you want a cheap squad option, you don't look at the best player in the championship.
Are we really going to act like Chelsea are a gold standard for making good signings?
He may have improved but it's too hard to judge a player's level just from the Championship. The level is too low. The Diallo comparison was just to show that good numbers in the Championship don't necessarily translate to the PL.
James Garner looked a star in the Championship and while he's been solid for Everton, he was deemed to not be good enough for Utd. Ethan Laird had an excellent loan in the Championship and was deemed not good enough. Josh Brownhill had a great season from midfield last season getting 7 goals and 8 assists and certainly hasn't been anything special in the PL this season. Same with Oliver Norwood. If you go one more season back I'd say you'd find one of the bigger successes of the step up in Philip Billing who got 10 goals and 10 assists and has been pretty good for Bournemouth in the PL. Despite this, would many here genuinely want Utd to go out and sign Philip Billing?
There are some occasions where the player can make the transition, but they're pretty rare and it's not like EDH is 19 or 20. We should certainly be prioritising the cb, lb, dm and striker positions first.
What a beautiful disaster this will be
Yes - and look what happened when Diallo got a chance against Liverpool.
Too much smoke about Southgate it’s kinda worrying. Does Jim want his very own yes-man?
There have been no reputable reports that I've seen. Once the International games are out of the way it'll go quiet, I suspect.
Amen. Honestly there's at least 2 or 3 academy midfielders who would be more than capable squad members and contributors to our team right now. Mainoo has clearly shown this. Oyedele and Gore immediately come to mind. If we are spending in midfield, it needs to be on truly special talent.
@mazhar13 The media seem to be getting into a frenzy about Dewsbury-Hall as the new Scholes.
I take it you've seen no reliable sources on this?
I take it you've seen no reliable sources on this?
We have no young central midfielders who are anywhere near the level of first-team football at United.
Those Drewsbury-Hall links are weird. If we wanna go for a cheap squad player im CM, I'd rather get Barkley on a free. The latter at least had a good season in the EPL.
The Caf. Knows. Nothing.
His break out game for me; he looked so good in several aspects not just dribbling. His other cameos were not so good, let‘s not pretend otherwise.
Oyedele couldn't get into the squad for a Forest Green side battling to stay up in the 4th tier, he's clearly nowhere near ready to contribute here.
We only have 3 former United players at Boca now, so I'm sure they could tell him more.
- Status