Vince is clearly still an unbelievable businessman. Dare I say age catches up slower in the business sector with billion dollar dealings a domain where 77 year old sociopaths can still thrive. However, he’s long fallen short as a creative force and is way out of sync with the younger generation. Not only that, his management is dreadful and the younger pros are used to higher standards of care when it comes to wellbeing and sensitivity.
Vince vowed over the weekend to stay out of the ‘weeds’ but Raw (and WrestleMania night 2) had his mucky fingers all over it. Incoherence, poor pacing, laziness in storytelling and numerous reports that scripts were torn up, segments were cut late and worker morale crashing.
It’s as if he sees this Endeavor deal as his redemption. He’s free now to dominate and make everyone who can possibly do something better than him kiss his ass, even/especially his family. His ego is still going wild and he feels bullet proof. He isn't a person to own his failings, to reflect and be a better human being. Public disgrace just motivates him to want to stick it to people even more.
I'm not a proponent of the idea of Triple H as a creative genius, either. The last 9 months or so in WWE has followed a similar course to black and gold NXT. Boring but steady TV shows, great PPVs. Sensible, coherent, largely empowering but not especially cutting edge booking. Bloodline/Sami has been great but apparently it's been predominantly a Heyman brain child (and credit to Triple H for letting him shape it).
Despite this, the product has been a lot better and the goodwill towards WWE from the wrestling community and seemingly the talent themselves is so much stronger than it was before Vince stepped down. The marketing and business side of things is a behemoth and Vince has played a huge role in that. But better (although still not exactly sparkling) creative and improved morale has only served to up the numbers, as WrestleMania 39 and TV ratings prove.
Vince McMahon needs to stay out of creative and talent management. Permanently. He's sucking the life out of the product.
I don't know how his ego can actually take this on board. Is there any value in creating a petition or something? I guess it's immaterial unless it affects the shareholders. The last few years (apart from the Triple H era) have shown that WWE can largely put out complete dross and still continue to grow commercially. Unfortunately, I don't have much hope it'll be worth watching on a sustained basis while Vince is there. Pretty much all my hope for the creative future of WWE has been deflated in 2 nights.