You'd think that the same thing happening at the same club at the same bloody position as recently as last year would tell them not to jump the gun. What was the name of the RB they signed to replace Alves who was bumped to 90 just because of the transfer and ended up being absolutely shit?
Gaming The SM RedCafe League
- Thread starter Damien
- Start date
Vidal? Forgot all about him
Yes, Alex vidal. They gave him a similar +2 just because he signed for them. No idea where he is in real life or in SM now. You'd think something like that would make them wait.Vidal? Forgot all about him
N'Dombele comes off the bench against Lyon to make the difference. Lads got 3 assists in the last 3 Ligue 1 games now. He's turning into a beast!
+3 for guedes
Hopefully another +3 next review
Hopefully another +3 next review
+2 at most. Valencia aren't in the Champions League.
Alaba at 95 is a joke.
+5 for Hakimi 
1 CL Winner
6 Bundesliga Winner
4 Pokal Winner
1 Fifa World Cup Winner
1 UEFA SuperCup Winner
4 goals, 4 assists last season in the bundesliga. 3 assists in the CL. 1 goal in Pokal. 16 clean sheets last season in Bundesliga alone.
Put that into perspective, Ramos had 5 clean sheets in La Liga last season. He got 7 goals but 0 assists. 1 goal, 3 assists in the CL. Ultimately the system rewards defenders and keepers for that matter who get clean sheets, it's why Atletico defenders are rated pretty highly.
Rotating tonight, will lose anyway. Not even a jinx, just reality.
I bloody hope Portugal are reviewed next. Need Martins and Marcano to rise to 89. Eredivisie would be fun for my young risers, would help my youth table score
Is that the one who is 93 on RM?I bloody hope Portugal are reviewed next. Need Martins and Marcano to rise to 89. Eredivisie would be fun for my young risers, would help my youth table score
Is that the one who is 93 on RM?
Yep. Probably will drop come March though as Portos Club Ranking has decreased a bit. But him being rated 88 is a joke on SM, but they always take the piss out of Portugese clubs.
Review pretty much over for me. I have Pavon, Saracchi and Haidara the only left where i expect rises. Ziyech having a good season but already 90 and Dolberg has been wank.I bloody hope Portugal are reviewed next. Need Martins and Marcano to rise to 89. Eredivisie would be fun for my young risers, would help my youth table score
21 rises so far so i'm expecting 24 in total. Will post the full list when review is over for me. Have to be happy with that, a few SM blunders aside.
I've got 24 players left that haven't been rated yet.
My players left to be reviewed:
Cedric Zesiger (19/78): Switzerland
Kieran Tierney (20/86): Scotland (would probably be summer next year though)
Dante Rigo (18/73): Netherlands (unlikely to get much)
Cedric Zesiger (19/78): Switzerland
Kieran Tierney (20/86): Scotland (would probably be summer next year though)
Dante Rigo (18/73): Netherlands (unlikely to get much)
I focus on the bigger leagues and you on the minnows so not unexpected. lolz
Why? You don't even have cup match.
Bundesliga and the Pokal are almost givens every year though. I don't think a Bundesliga player should be so high personally. Not sure if international football (non club) plays a part, but he's frickin Austrian!
I have 20 players 89+ is the other reason. Need to manage concerns way more after this review.
Bundesliga was the 2nd most successful league in Europe (thats determined by results in Europe). Granted most of their points come from Bayern and Dortmund but the point still stands. However results this season in the CL have shook things up with the Premier League finally getting some form and Borussia Dortmund collapsing with a few poor results from Bayern have pushed them down to 4th now.
Last season it was Spain (miles ahead of everyone else), with Germany 2nd and England a close 3rd. Italy miles away in 4th. Right now however things have switched round with Spain still miles ahead but England have closed the gap, Italy are now 3rd and Germany have dropped to 4th. France aren't too far away in 5th.
Once RS has done the mockups for the site and it is in progress, you'll be able to see all the top ratings. Alaba definitely isn't the strangest rating. Like Phil says, it is a consequence of the ratings being done purely on stats.
Aye, we've got the benefit of having a system which not only rates clubs but also rates leagues depending entirely on results. I don't do anything to sway the results at all, simply update the stats and let the system churn out the results. That's the whole point of it, it's completely objective, all players, clubs and leagues share the same rules.
Fair enough. Stats versus reality
Am assuming thats supposed to be the Club world cup? Otherwise can someone please tell me what year is it and did Austria win a world cup recently that i didnt hear about?
Fair enough. Stats versus reality
Stats versus opinion.
German Clubs had a higher points per game ratio than every country except Spain in Europe for the past 3 seasons. Not my fault if they're simply better than the rest of us.
Yah missed Club. I dunno why they call it Club World Cup. It's daft right?
More reliable than how SM have been doing. Added you to the RM convo - look at the last page for the England review comparison of RM to SM.Fair enough. Stats versus reality
New formation, 3:1 loss to Norwich and one of my players gets MOTM. No idea how they work that one out.
De Gea (94)
Kimmich (91) Ramos (95) Alaba (93) Roberto (91)↓
Isco (93)↓
Kroos (95) Pogba (93)
Eriksen (92)↓ --------------------------------- Bale (95)
Griezmann (95)
Subs: Monreal (90)↑, Matip (91), Goretzka (91), Dele (91), Sterling (91), Bernardo (91)↑, Martial (90)
↑
Injured: Brandt (90)
Suspended: Boateng (94)
Did not travel: Mercado (89)
Key:
= Goal
= Assist
= MOTM
↓ = Subbed off
↑ = Subbed on
De Gea (94)
Kimmich (91) Ramos (95) Alaba (93) Roberto (91)↓
Isco (93)↓
Kroos (95) Pogba (93)
Eriksen (92)↓ --------------------------------- Bale (95)
Griezmann (95)
↑Injured: Brandt (90)
Suspended: Boateng (94)
Did not travel: Mercado (89)
Key:
= Goal = Assist = MOTM↓ = Subbed off
↑ = Subbed on
Lost as expected. Ronaldo had 5 commentary chances and missed every single one and got a 9 rating. So broken.
The 2D engine doesn't even work on firefox half the time. I have to end up playing the first half on fast forward and if none of the other matches have got a goal after 20 mins I know it is broken and have to switch to chrome for my biweekly disappointment.
Lost 4-0 and silva got sent off again thats 3 reds in 4 games for him
Leo Messi didn't score against AFC Bournemouth.
So broken.
So broken.
Sounds about right. I had a crap record against you IIRC.
He didn't even have a shot in commentary so kinda hard to score then. Messi not even taking a shot in a game is still more unrealistic than Ronaldo missing 5 tbf.
1:1 draw away to bogey team Bournemouth.
De Gea (94)
Aurier (91) Matip (90) Boateng (94) Roberto (91)
Goretzka (90)↓ Bernardo (91)
Brandt (90)↓ Sterling (91) Bale (95)
Martial (90)↓
Subs: Ramos (95), Messi (99)
Did not travel: Dele (91), Monreal (90)
Key:
↓ = Subbed off
↑ = Subbed on
Hah, Leo scored off the bench for me in the good old days of when I could get a point in a league game.
I bloody hope Portugal are reviewed next. Need Martins and Marcano to rise to 89. Eredivisie would be fun for my young risers, would help my youth table score
Waiting for the eridivisie too
Lozano should be a 92 for sure lol
I expected a loss.New formation, 3:1 loss to Norwich and one of my players gets MOTM. No idea how they work that one out.
Subs: Monreal (90)↑, Matip (91), Goretzka (91), Dele (91), Sterling (91), Bernardo (91)↑, Martial (90)
De Gea (94)
Kimmich (91) Ramos (95) Alaba (93) Roberto (91)↓
Isco (93)↓
Kroos (95) Pogba (93)
Eriksen (92)↓ --------------------------------- Bale (95)
Griezmann (95)
Injured: Brandt (90)
Suspended: Boateng (94)
Did not travel: Mercado (89)
Key:
↓ = Subbed off
↑ = Subbed on
Was even more suprised when Griezmann got the MOTM.
"Have".