Nucks
RT History Department
- Joined
- Sep 2, 2007
- Messages
- 4,462
but decicion victories under the current system are a joke... that clearly needs to be changed before grinding out decicion after decicion counts...
rua won the last fight... ask any fighter
Ask any fighter? Plenty of fighters had Machida win, as did plenty of judges.
The fight was extremely close, due to the nature of ALL combat sport judging.
Rounds 1 2 and 3 were all very close and Shogun could have stolen any one of those rounds, he also decisively won rounds 4 and 5.
Unfortunately for Shogun fights are judged on a per round basis rather than the body of the entire fight.
If this was a school yard bang up, yes I would agree Shogun won, or would have won soon after the fight ended. It wasn't a school yard row, it was a sporting event and Machida won that. He won it 3 rounds to 2 on three judges score cards if memory serves correctly. In my opinion and in many other opinions he narrowly won rounds 1 through 3, before the work Shogun did in those rounds hobbled him and Shogun had his way with him.
The fight when judged as a sporting event was so incredibly close that I would not be upset had Shogun been given the nod because as an experienced (I've been watching the UFC since 1993 and pride since the early days) and an objective observer I can see the legitimate arguments on both sides for any one of the first three rounds to have been given to Shogun.
So ya, Shogun won the "fight" but he lost the match. The only thing that matters. If you change the rules, the dynamic of the fight changes. Just because you change the rules doesn't mean the ultimate outcome becomes different. Gameplans and strategy change. Shogun's strategy was contingent on the current rule system. If we went back to UFC 1-2 style rules where it was more of a fight, I promise you the fight would have been drastically different. Who would have won? Impossible to say because the approach both men would have taken would have been different. This last paragraph may seem contradictory but it is not. Just because the rules change, doesn't mean the outcome does. IF the rules change the manner in the fight is fought does become unpredictable the result is also unpredictable but this does not necessitate a change in outcome.