FrankDrebin
Don't call me Shirley
Another ETH gem. Thankfully its only a loan deal. Still, a 8 million waste.
His running for the first couple of games he played were ludicrous, it looked as though he was chasing the ball all over the field, keen to impress, problem with that was he left gaps for others to fill.I genuinely feel for him, man's barely had a chance to get any sort of thing going here and basically has 5/10 minute stints in high-tempo games - generally when we're up against it - to try prove himself.
Or kept Fred, who could've been a OK LB option too.Maybe keeping Sabitzer would've been a better option?
Malen and BrobbeyCan’t wait to see what hidden gem ETH finds this transfer window. He’s clearly got an eye for PL ready talent.
I still think he'd be an improvement on what Casimero is serving up currently.
mainoo injury forced the extra body. people forget that. mainoo was excelling in preseason, then got injured. Fred was on the way out, so we were left facing half the season with casemiro as the only defensively minded midfielder in our squad, which would have been madness. we simply needed an extra man and while amrabat has underwhelmed, he looked a reasonably decent and attainable target. A loan also made sense as we didnt need or want anyone who would block mainoos role. The real problem was not signing a top quality defensive midfielder but I think we thought casemiro had another year in him
Yep I remember that being the story. We couldn't sign ambrabat until MCT was sold. As he wasn't sold we went for loan. It did feel like we wanted to make him permanent but were restricted.Sofyan Averagetobat.
If McT had been sold Amrabat would have been a permanent transfer.
Classic case of "International ability =/= Club ability"
He joins the club of Milan Barros, Karel Poborsky, Honda, Podolski and Svennson
ETH has been building a team for Serie A.Classic case of "International ability =/= Club ability"
He joins the club of Milan Barros, Karel Poborsky, Honda, Podolski and Svennson
ETH has been building a team for Serie A.
I dont understand this transfer. He is playing exactly how it was expected. Is Ten Hag surprised?
I honestly don't think he gives a shit. New season, new list of players he wants. He belongs at a club like City where they can refresh the squad every year until he gets his perfect team.ETH has been building a team for Serie A.
I dont understand this transfer. He is playing exactly how it was expected. Is Ten Hag surprised?
If I remember correctly, he was labeled more like a DLP than a DM (Casemiro cover) by people who watched him play more. In that context signing Amrabat for a team that focuses on fast transitions makes little sense to me.It’s not very complicated, I think. Mainoo was injured, McTominay was a possible sale for the summer or winter window, Fred was leaving for Turkey, and there was almost no cover for Casemiro specifically. A loan deal for an experienced midfielder able to shield the defence seems a good way out when we didn’t have the money to reinforce from the high end either way.
If we’d had the same injuries in midfield that we have in defence, or if Mainoo hadn’t defies belief as a kid withe a couple of games’ experience coming back from injury, he would have played a lot.
If I remember correctly, he was labeled more like a DLP than a DM (Casemiro cover) by people who watched him play more. In that context signing Amrabat for a team that focuses on fast transitions makes little sense to me.
Maybe he was the only one available on loan. Still, it's such a weird way to build a squad (letting Fred go, buying Mount, loaning Amrabat).
I don't see your point in context of the discussion we had with Grande.Have you not been watching how Casemiro plays at Manchester United?
I don't see your point in context of the discussion we had with Grande.
Casemiro role is to get the ball back (he's quite effective at that still, unless he needs to chase) and launch it forward. There is not much finesse in what he's doing. Amrabat seems like a really poor DM/tackler and he was more of a player that spreads the ball wide and provides some passing options. But that is not how ETH wants to play based on how the midfield operates this season.You’re saying he couldn’t do what Casemiro does in his absence because he’s a “DLP” (I hate these acronyms but presume you mean deep lying passer?) which is exactly what Casemiro has mainly been doing for us. God knows, if we had a proper, mobile defensive midfielder in our squad we might be a better team but ETH seems to be happy with a fairly immobile player in that role, pinging early long passes forward. Which is supposed to be Amrabat’s specialty.
If I remember correctly, he was labeled more like a DLP than a DM (Casemiro cover) by people who watched him play more. In that context signing Amrabat for a team that focuses on fast transitions makes little sense to me.
Maybe he was the only one available on loan. Still, it's such a weird way to build a squad (letting Fred go, buying Mount, loaning Amrabat).
I posted a while back about this.ETH has been building a team for Serie A.
I dont understand this transfer. He is playing exactly how it was expected. Is Ten Hag surprised?
Yeah. But to be honest, most of our players turned out that way. Amrabat, Antony, Hojlund are playing pretty much as expected. Martinez really stepped out, and Sancho is the biggest disappointment.I posted a while back about this.
Forget Amrabat's name and any thoughts you had on him and just think of an overview of his career: 27 year old midfielder who has played for Hellas, Utrecht, Feyenoord, Club Brugge, Fiorentina who the latter want to sell for £20m. He's not really been disappointing, he's exactly about the level we should have expected him to be.
As an aside, I'd be happy to see more of these type of loans though, when you have the option to make it permanent and get to actually see the player first. Makes a whole lot more sense than just splashing silly money left and right.
I think with other names, including the other two you mentioned, it's not the same though. Antony was 22 when he came here, Hojlund was 20, that's very different to a 27 year old where you really can see if they can be elite i.e. someone like Modric who everyone wanted but moved at 27 a Real.Yeah. But to be honest, most of our players turned out that way. Amrabat, Antony, Hojlund are playing pretty much as expected. Martinez really stepped out, and Sancho is the biggest disappointment.
People often make it look like player X has been disappointing, but very often he's actually playing on his actual level.
I posted a while back about this.
Forget Amrabat's name and any thoughts you had on him and just think of an overview of his career: 27 year old midfielder who has played for Hellas, Utrecht, Feyenoord, Club Brugge, Fiorentina who the latter want to sell for £20m. He's not really been disappointing, he's exactly about the level we should have expected him to be.
As an aside, I'd be happy to see more of these type of loans though, when you have the option to make it permanent and get to actually see the player first. Makes a whole lot more sense than just splashing silly money left and right.
You might need to call in one of the Bundesliga faithful to confirm but my understanding is Endo was great for Stuttgart but he had a year left on his deal which made the £15m odd fee seem good. I am not going to pretend I have any understanding of how good or bad he was for the bulk of his career in Japan, but I guess you would have a point is he was average there for so long and only really did well when he went to Stuttgart late in his career, I'm not sure we have ay J League watchers amongst us though.Wouldn’t Endo have a similar CV? Probably worse, seeing as he’s older. He’s been doing ok for Liverpool. Better than Amrabat for us anyway.
Antony has 2 seasons in EPL under his belt and it's not like he made any progress, he's just playing his game. Hojlund is a tough one because he seems fairly limited player that CAN improve, but it's not a given considering his deficiences in technique is not something you get better at at the age of 20.I think with other names, including the other two you mentioned, it's not the same though. Antony was 22 when he came here, Hojlund was 20, that's very different to a 27 year old where you really can see if they can be elite i.e. someone like Modric who everyone wanted but moved at 27 a Real.
You might need to call in one of the Bundesliga faithful to confirm but my understanding is Endo was great for Stuttgart but he had a year left on his deal which made the £15m odd fee seem good. I am not going to pretend I have any understanding of how good or bad he was for the bulk of his career in Japan, but I guess you would have a point is he was average there for so long and only really did well when he went to Stuttgart late in his career, I'm not sure we have ay J League watchers amongst us though.
I don't think this stands up to scrutiny. A 20 and 22 year old could have vastly different career paths to what we imagine they will if we fast forward 30 years. The key is when we bought them there was clearly an idea of there being potential as well as ability, which I don't think you can argue in Amrabat's case given his age.Antony has 2 seasons in EPL under his belt and it's not like he made any progress, he's just playing his game. Hojlund is a tough one because he seems fairly limited player that CAN improve, but it's not a given considering his deficiences in technique is not something you get better at at the age of 20.
In the end I believe we got what was expected from those players, so it's not like they are not delivering, more a problem of identifying the right targets, what was my point.
Oh I am sure there are bargains to be had but I would assume most of those bargains haven't jumped around as many lesser clubs with quick loans thrown in during their mid twenties (it's not like Amrabat came from an unknown league, he's been in Europe his whole career) and are key players wherever they are, like Endo was.I wouldn’t pretend to have a clue about the Bundesliga, never mind the J League. But I do think Endo proves you don’t have to settle for players who you know will never be good enough, just because you don’t want to splash out on a massive fee.
Probably the worst player I've seen in a utd shirt. Don't like being unkind but this is a forum for honest views.