Sofyan Amrabat | 2023/24 Performances

Status
Not open for further replies.
I’m struggling to see it personally, looks a very ordinary player to me. Hopefully we see more over the next few games but I haven’t seen any major improvements over McFred at the moment, although early days.
 
Looks like a decent squad player, much better in second half. Not great in first half but in fairness it’s tough because Bruno was shit and Mctominay was AWOL so it’s a tough job for him.
 
Looked far better when Erikson came on. I personally think he is a good signing and will prove to be a top CDM.
 
M Bison said:
I’m struggling to see it personally, looks a very ordinary player to me. Hopefully we see more over the next few games but I haven’t seen any major improvements over McFred at the moment, although early days.
Click to expand...
He's not outstanding by any means but knows his job. He positions himself well, and doesn't give stupid giveaways needlessly. You'd think that's a given for a professional footballer in the highest tier, but you've watched United for the last 10 or so years, so it's great to at least have that
 
Glorio said:
He's not outstanding by any means but knows his job. He positions himself well, and doesn't give stupid giveaways needlessly. You'd think that's a given for a professional footballer in the highest tier, but you've watched United for the last 10 or so years, so it's great to at least have that
Click to expand...

He gives away plenty of freekicks
 
Nearly broke the woodwork with his strike. It would’ve been an amazing goal
 
M Bison said:
I’m struggling to see it personally, looks a very ordinary player to me. Hopefully we see more over the next few games but I haven’t seen any major improvements over McFred at the moment, although early days.
Click to expand...

He’s bang average and a downgrade on Fred but an upgrade on Sabitzer, albeit in a slightly different position.

He’s not a United level first team regular player, but ok as a squad option.

I’d be disappointed if we took up the option to sign him permanently.
 
I think, he was alright and his effort at the crossbar was nice for sure. His mobility is helping us. Still pretty sure, he will be killed when played as DM. He is way too weak in the tackle or in 1on1s. This was to be expected to a degree. I'd hoped though, he would be balancing it out a bit more with his passing. Which is alright (the passing I mean) but 9 out of 10 passes are easy passes to the guy next to him. Granted, having experienced Fred and McTominay, that comes across as a pretty special thing and keeping it simple has its uses but occasionally, he should make use of his long passing, put on a little more zip and try to be less foreseeable. Looked better 2nd half but most likely because Sheffield dropped deeper and gave him more time and space.
 
Last edited:
I don’t know what people expect of him. He looks very good to me. Good attitude, Assured, works hard, knows his limits, doesn’t try to over complicate things like Casemiro. Sure he has some weaknesses but overall he’s been very good imo.
 
BuzzKillington said:
He’s bang average and a downgrade on Fred but an upgrade on Sabitzer, albeit in a slightly different position.

He’s not a United level first team regular player, but ok as a squad option.

I’d be disappointed if we took up the option to sign him permanently.
Click to expand...
He's been here a just over a month and injured for most of it. Today was better from him, but let's give him some time.
 
kaku06 said:
I don’t know what people expect of him. He looks very good to me. Good attitude, Assured, works hard, knows his limits, doesn’t try to over complicate things like Casemiro. Sure he has some weaknesses but overall he’s been very good imo.
Click to expand...
Generally agree with this.
 
The only midfielder we have who can play the #6 role in possession. But we still went direct which seems to be what ten Hag is instructing the players to do in the first phase. And that is likely due to who is playing at CB, and Maguire definitely is more suited to playing in such a way due to not having to play the game in confined spaces, which is a problem for him. Hence going direct and forcing the opposing block to retreat opens up the game for Maguire to make the big diagonal, which he's good at.

It's about getting results and hopefully Shaw and Martinez are not out injured for too long because they're two of our best players in the build up phase in confined spaces and can progress the ball.
 
I prefer players who are consistent in their applications. he rarely makes unforced errors like Bruno, Casemiro and Fred. he does not have moments of brilliance but you can trust him to play his role consistently. you need that in your team. I don't like erratic and chaotic players like Bruno. everything is inconsistent. failing to make a pass that any amateur player will make then producing a world class pass later. Bruno performance range from 0 to 10 in a single game. it so strange
 
Adnan said:
It's about getting results and hopefully Shaw and Martinez are not out injured for too long because they're two of our best players in the build up phase in confined spaces and can progress the ball.
Click to expand...

Strange so many so called United fans don’t grasp how important this is to our style of play.

They are huge misses and irreplaceable in the current squad.
 
TheReligion said:
Strange so many so called United fans don’t grasp how important this is to our style of play.

They are huge misses and irreplaceable in the current squad.
Click to expand...
When you're missing Martinez, Shaw and Varane it takes away the ability to progress the ball in possession as well as having the ability to control the defensive transition which both Varane and Shaw are good at. So it's about getting results or else you're going to be in trouble. And the game tonight was about playing to the strengths of the players you have at your disposal and going direct is what ten Hag chose to do.

He's a coach that wants to play through the thirds but playing through the thirds is very difficult and extremely risky with personnel who are uncomfortable playing in confined spaces.
 
Adnan said:
The only midfielder we have who can play the #6 role in possession. But we still went direct which seems to be what ten Hag is instructing the players to in the first phase. And that is likely due to who is playing at CB, and Maguire definitely is more suited to playing in such a way due to not having to play the game in confined spaces, which is a problem for him. Hence going direct and forcing the opposing block to retreat opens up the game for Maguire to make the big diagonal, which he's good at.

It's about getting results and hopefully Shaw and Martinez are not out injured for too long because they're two of our best players in the build up phase in confined spaces and can progress the ball.
Click to expand...
Just saw the interview with Ten Hag with the Dutch media and one of the things he told the team at half time was that they needed to focus on playing their own game instead of mirroring the direct style Sheffield played. So no those weren't his instructions apparently. Think our play is suffering a lot from having to play CBs or midfielders as fullbacks and having some players out of form.
 
ArjenIsM3 said:
Just saw the interview with Ten Hag with the Dutch media and one of the things he told the team at half time was that they needed to focus on playing their own game instead of mirroring the direct style Sheffield played. So no those weren't his instructions apparently. Think our play is suffering a lot from having to play CBs or midfielders as fullbacks and having some players out of form.
Click to expand...
We did play our own game by going direct.
 
If his crossbar shot had gone in, the Cafe would be creaming themselves. Solid performance tonight
 
Before we bought him I said he looked like a Europa level player to me, and so far that's what he is.

That said, he's not bad, can move the ball about and keeps possession well. He's fine in a pivot. His game falls apart when things gets frantic because he's rather slow and his first touch isn't clean enough
 
Adnan said:
When you're missing Martinez, Shaw and Varane it takes away the ability to progress the ball in possession as well as having the ability to control the defensive transition which both Varane and Shaw are good at. So it's about getting results or else you're going to be in trouble. And the game tonight was about playing to the strengths of the players you have at your disposal and going direct is what ten Hag chose to do.

He's a coach that wants to play through the thirds but playing through the thirds is very difficult and extremely risky with personnel who are uncomfortable playing in confined spaces.
Click to expand...
I can see your point, but don't you think, if that would be the case, we'd be a little more compact? This is the thing, I don't get at all - I think being pragmatic with our injury list makes sense, play to our strength as long as thats the best bet. But why are we so out of sync all the time? There were many occasions, when McTom bombed forwards, Dalot went into midfield and pushed up. But the long, direct ball then is powerless and dumb which then comes back when we are completely out of balance.
 
Thought he was very good tonight. Neat, tidy, calm, composed. Nothing flashy but very effective. Dare I say Carrick-light.
 
Thought he was pretty good tonight, he has the energy to get up and down the pitch and the awareness to snuff out danger, was solid on the ball, and almost scored a worldie.
 
Meh.

First half was a classic Cleverley performance. Looked better in the second half but I’m not convinced. Not a bad player but he looks like a player you can find 50 clones of across Europe.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.