He's actually agreeing with you.
Sean Longstaff
- Thread starter Zoo
- Start date
- Status
Midfielders of his age rarely impress. Fletcher especially was a nightmare to watch at his age.
I'd rather give this lad a shot than another primadonna just happy to collect his huge pay packet.
The club don’t just moronically think they are the best players. We have made ‘Manchester United signings’ in buying promising young players, who were coveted by the sort of clubs you would think would also covet Manchester United signings - and those players haven’t stepped up. Those who were planned to be back up have been better, so they have played.
If you take a back 4 of Valencia-Smalling-Jones-Young and then consider that we bought Darmian-Bailly-Lindelöf-Shaw to replace them, only Shaw, and to a lesser extent, Lindelof have actually claimed a place. The Darmian who was also pursued by Bayern and Juve (still is), hasn’t done the job, and the Bailly (I get more excited by these type of unknown signings than I do about signing Di Maria) who was wanted by City and Barcelona has also failed and is likely for sale. Who do you expect we start if they aren’t up to it?
Looks good on the YT video. Does remind me of Carrick in his movement and style albeit a bit quicker paced.
Let's just go for it
Let's just go for it
We buy better. It’s pretty simple for me. I don’t need a long answer explaining what has gone on at the club because I know what has gone on. The squad is overloaded with average players and my opinion will not change on that. We need to buy the correct players which we have struggled to do for years in large numbers.
Can we just use the banned Lukaku chant with him now? Except maybe change a few words here or there.
Easy to say in hindsight. ‘Buy better’ even stretches as far as Paul Pogba for many. The fact that not one player signed post-Fergie has come here and improved should give a clearer indication of the real problem.
We’re not buying rubbish footballers, not by a long stretch.
Didn't he get a bad injury, doubt he'll be fit for start of next season so would say next January would be more likely.
First, I think lot of Newcastle fans aren’t happy with the owner and the board as they don’t really care much about the success but money. Put £20m at max, their board will be tempted to take the money.
Second, The guy hardly even play that much this season, not being overhyped by media, already 21 & they know we aren’t desperate to sign the player so they won’t be silly enough to try to rip our wallet.
I never watch him, but based on that 4 minutes YouTube video he looks similar to Carrick but he looks like more a no 8 than holding mid. But the stats of his passing accuracy is horrendous. 80% only. But pre his injury, he had like rating of 7 in almost all games which is impressive.
I think it’s worth of punt and I’m excited with this signing because I’m sick with crazy money that we spent on deadwood. If we are going to spend big then spend on the right players. If we want to take a punt don’t spend £50m on Fred. Both won’t be in the category of the 4 signings that the news has mentioned as those are supposed to be first XI players. James & Longstaff are backup.
Second, The guy hardly even play that much this season, not being overhyped by media, already 21 & they know we aren’t desperate to sign the player so they won’t be silly enough to try to rip our wallet.
I never watch him, but based on that 4 minutes YouTube video he looks similar to Carrick but he looks like more a no 8 than holding mid. But the stats of his passing accuracy is horrendous. 80% only. But pre his injury, he had like rating of 7 in almost all games which is impressive.
I think it’s worth of punt and I’m excited with this signing because I’m sick with crazy money that we spent on deadwood. If we are going to spend big then spend on the right players. If we want to take a punt don’t spend £50m on Fred. Both won’t be in the category of the 4 signings that the news has mentioned as those are supposed to be first XI players. James & Longstaff are backup.
Looks underwhelming. Did Declan Rice go cold on United as well?
Spot on.
Take Choccy off your list sonny. Man does not deserve to be on a list with those lot. 24 league goals in his first season, and at least 2 or 3 other seasons where he averaged a goal every 2 to 3 games.
He was a great servant to United, with plenty of goals, assists and overall contribution.
I am not on about him as a striker, towards the end of his career he played exclusively in midfield and bang average was the best that could be said about him there, for me it took the gloss off his career
Our new level
And we expect players to be loyal to the club. He was at the club for 10 or 11 years, from his prime, to the embers of his career.
He certainly doesn’t deserve to be in a list of players like Tosic, DD or Powell. He was a great player for United and should be remembered for that, imo.
Absolutely spot on. It blows my mind when people complain about Young. He’s a left winger who came to this club, gives absolutely everything in every game we play and plays in any position he’s been asked to. Without fuss. The very definition of sacrificing himself for the team. All because the players we have signed haven’t stepped up.
Dalot will hopefully add some defensive nous to his game and relieve Young of RB duties. Shaw seems to play better under influence of the stick rather than the carrot. So hopefully Ole goes all Jose/LVG on him so Young can get back to being a winger again.
I don’t think people realise how much trouble we would be in if we didn’t have guys like Young, Smalling, Jones. Who have maintained a decent level throughout the past 6 years.
The point was he was used as midfielder/midfield bench player, in response to an original point which said Sean Longstaff would be our worst midfielder/bench midfielder ever, if you think I wish to denegrate McClairs Utd career you are very much mistaken, however regardless of what went before the last few years were very poor, it is not being unloyal to realise that it is however being blind to ignore it.
For what it's worth McCLair should have retired about 3 years before he did, that does not make him a bad player, however I do think to keep playing him in midfield was one of SAFs more questionable decisions
"Benitez would be reluctant to lose the midfielder but United’s interest is genuine and developments are expected over the next few days".
"United will also rival champions Manchester City for Leicester and England centre-half Harry Maguire, who could cost over £70million".
Last edited:
I would be happy with this signing. Only saw him play for a brief period but he looked like a quality player in the making.
For a decent fee, why not. Problem is his injury
Robson also linking us with him again. Luckhurst was the one who denied this, correct? Guess it's on then. The way he's badmouthing different United players at every chance, I wouldn't give that guy a breadcrumb of info if I were the club.
like Longstaff. As a depth signing for the future, why not?
like Longstaff. As a depth signing for the future, why not?
I like the Fact we are linked with emerging talent every player is a gamble superstar or not (see Sanchez Di Maria Falcao etc) who knows could turn out to be exactly what we need
Bet Woody’s loving these bargain basement players Ole’s after.
Luckhurst was playing down the Daniel James signing too..
Longstaff isn't going to be cheap
Yeah, the completely unnecessary comment of not making an appearance on loan at Shrewsbury, made him come across as such a tool.
Why has he got a long contract?
if we get James, Sessegnon, Collins, Longstaff , AWB and Sancho. #brexitmeansbrexitSigned a new deal in December.
Was in outstanding form before his injury and looked a much needed shining light for Newcastle - they won't be looking to sell cheap.
Id be surprised if this happened this summer but never know.
I doubt he’s on high wages, I think the most we would pay is £40mil.
Make up your minds guys, is Woody a cheapskate or is he a transfer muppet who loves big names and big money signings?
Don’t forget Slabhead
i assumed he was being sarcastic meaning woodward is probably rolling his eyes behind his head buying all these cheaper un known players... but now im not even sure
Ah yes, if only we had creative CMs in the UK. We could have a clean sweep.
Mike Ashley calls the shots, he wouldn't turn down a £30-40 million bid.
Yep, considering he just lost an absolute shit tonne on Debenhams, I bet he wants a bit of a recoup.
- Status