Seamus Coleman

NYAS said:
Has a decent reputation but anyone who thinks Everton will sell Coleman in the middle of the season for £16m can't be all that reliable.
Click to expand...

to be fair, he is only mentioning a mourinho interest.
 
Hes 28 and he would cost us a bomb. Everton players are ridiculously overrated.
 
devilish said:
As long as they do the job for us we shouldnt hive a crap of what players do with their prior club
Click to expand...
Ah I see your point. The problem is Aurier is well known for his indiscipline. People were talking about potential unsettlement he caused for us, not about his past scandal. He has this Joey Barton negative self imploding aura around him. Cantona or Zlatan have the complex character but possible leader aura. Evra is very likeable person. The trouble was with that maniac coach, a momentous problem. Different thing altogether, doesn't bode well. The first group is detested by their own teammates. The former group is well respected (made captains, leading figures for their team)
 
Last edited:
Good player but that's about it.

Another one in the very long list of Everton players that lots of people like to hype up beyond all reasonable recognition.
 
Lurpak99 said:
As far as I know he's a right back, who happens to play in midfield now for whatever reason.
Click to expand...
It's not just now. Last season he played 18 out of 44 matches at defensive midfield. He even played 12 the season before. (Source: Transfermarkt).
I know very little about the player, really, but that's a bit concerning, I'd much rather have someone whose game time all comes from RB.
 
Coleman is a fantastic player and would fix what I think is a problem position for United.

Seeing the cash we splash these days, I'd offer Everton up to £30m.
 
Decent player but in replacing Darmian - is this really the shift in quality and squad improvement we seek??? I think not.
 
Do not want. Plus I am fed up with us signing or being linked to former Everton players/manager.

Hell I hope the only business we do with them anytime soon is to return Rooney!
 
Has days he looks very good but overall he is quite average I think, he functions perfectly at the level he is at really. Would prefer we go for somebody else. On another note, is he not quite injury prone?
 
Lurpak99 said:
As far as I know he's a right back, who happens to play in midfield now for whatever reason.
Click to expand...

That's because his replacement Sidibe is actually better than him in the position. They also have one of the most talented right-backs around in Almamy Toure. He's a good player, but it seems he's more useful as midfielder to Monaco currently.
 
bucky said:
That's because his replacement Sidibe is actually better than him in the position. They also have one of the most talented right-backs around in Almamy Toure. He's a good player, but it seems he's more useful as midfielder to Monaco currently.
Click to expand...
Yeah I was going to say, surely Sidibe would be a better choice, if we were looking at Right Backs in Monaco.
 
Would be a great quick fix, think he's comfortably better than Valencia and 16times better than Darmian... He could play top football for another 4 years and I dont see many alternatives out there. EPL proven. Hes also a player who I feel could work hard and push himself even more if he came. Would only prefer Cancelo over him..
 
If we are to go for a fullback we should do our best to sign a right back that is young, quick and attack very well (given Shaw's preference to defend). It may be ridiculous to suggest but I think we should do everything possible to get Bellerin.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.