Scott McTominay image 39

Scott McTominay Scotland flag

2022-23 Performances

View full 2022-23 profile

5.3 Season Average Rating
Appearances
39
Goals
3
Assists
1
Yellow cards
10
Status
Not open for further replies.
Bobski said:
Fantastic defensive performance in the second half. You can complain about the lack of control and put that all on him as usual but identify and accept the things he did well today at the same time.
Click to expand...
Yeah but he ain't good enough. Needs to be sold at the end of the season. Only reason I would keep him is lack of options.
 
Not a great influence on the ball but I think he is showing more defensive nous under ETH. He's put in a good shift, broken stuff up - yes he's given away some fouls but you do have to be competitive in this league and back yourself to defend the odd set play.
 
Was never a penalty - Adams chested the ball onto his arm from 1 feet away
 
Got away with a moment of madness on the handball that wasn’t called, but otherwise worked hard defensively. No need to pile on about his lack of ability on the ball.
 
diarm said:
He was superb today.

This place is a joke with people ignoring what's happening in front of their eyes in their rush to stick the foot in on him. 5.9 average rating is absolutely ridiculous.
Click to expand...
My God he was average. Can we stop this he was superb shit
 
Very good when it comes to defending, but that's that, he's lacking everything else you need in midfielder, first of all composure with the ball.
 
The folks criticising him today are outing themselves as having made up their mind no matter what he does.

He's still poor on the ball, but his fighting and grinding was really important for us today against a Southampton team that were trying to wear us down physically.

If he could get his head up and pass he could be a top player.
 
Very good performance. Playing deeper suits him over the advanced #8 role EtH had him playing in the first two games
 
He was a vital part of that clean sheet today. He is clearly a limited player but he used those limited gifts very well today. One of his best performances for us.
 
The Hilton said:
The folks criticising him today are outing themselves as having made up their mind no matter what he does.

He's still poor on the ball, but his fighting and grinding was really important for us today against a Southampton team that were trying to wear us down physically.

If he could get his head up and pass he could be a top player.
Click to expand...
He has no chance of being a top player when he is poor on the ball. Seems like him putting in a tackle and running around is enough for some people.
 
[/QUOTE="lex talionis, post: 29394079, member: 109475"]
Got away with a moment of madness on the handball that wasn’t called, but otherwise worked hard defensively. No need to pile on about his lack of ability on the ball.
[/QUOTE]

How was it a moment of madness? How could he have avoided it?
 
Think slating him today as some have is unwarranted.

He has played well in the last two games, there is a role for him in cerrtain games I feel.......

But, cant get away from the fact he is a limited footballer, especially for a side wanting to get back towards the top, he isnt the answer. That has been the problem full stop with McFred, both have good attributes....tracking runners, intelligence and passing under any pressure....both though are atrocious.

We certainly still need a second midfield signing in my opinion, but the last two games, I think overall McTominay has done well, one of our better players today.

Other side of the coin, player linke dwith us especially heavily when Ragnick was to be an advisor....thought Bella Kotchap was motm, looks a great prospect
 
He played well and it was a good overall performance. For the criticism he gets when he doesn't play well, he deserves praise for when it does. Hope the injury he sustained late on doesn't prove to be a bad one. Looked pretty grim on the replays, but he continued playing.
 
JeffBoomTetris said:
He did what his abilities allowed him to do which is heads down, defend, tackle & pass it off. Casemiro is the way forward who does everything McT can do plus more
Click to expand...
Lack of height would be the only area I’d disagree on. McT won a lot of headers today!
 
Did a job today but his deficiencies, as usual, are bare for all to see. Nothing player going forward - can't pick out a pass, doesn't show himself to help progress the ball. Defensively, he's alright, but one gets a sense that he's always on the verge of a card and potential penalty in and around our box. Casemiro should replace his spot in the starting line up once he gets up to speed.
 
He's not good enough. We had zero control today. Zero.

I'm not going to praise him for a defensive performance that should never have come about due to his lack of ability to control a game.

And him and Fernandes play a big part in that (De Gea too with his long punts up).

Needs to be kept away from the XI.
 
Slysi17 said:
Yeah but he ain't good enough. Needs to be sold at the end of the season. Only reason I would keep him is lack of options.
Click to expand...
Why should he be sold? He can surely be second to third backup. Liverpool have Milner, Elliot, Chamberlain, Keita as backups. It's really only City that have top top quality in debt.
 
Lecland07 said:
There were three handballs, though. not just one. The last one should have been given, no doubt about it.
Click to expand...

Two handballs by him, either of which on their own wouldn't be looked twice at so why should it be a penalty just because the two happened in quick succession.

The third, and clearly closest to an actual handball of all, was by Adams and not McTominay.
 
Credit is due. He had a very good game, and he offered options to passes (which was one of my biggest concern before). And his height was very important on defence against long-ball Soton.
 
A thought to the agenda driven haters - Fred could not have done what Scott did today. He shielded our defence, made several tackles, headers and clearances.

The front three/four/five were largely anonymous today, yet some want to blame McTominay - who was playing as a #6 - for the lack of attacking fluidity. Nonsense.

I would love to see him get some games alongside/in front of Casemiro, so that he has more opportunity to bomb forward and offer a goal threat, as we saw one instance of today.
 
His best game in a good while, he worked hard and was essential defending set pieces. Cant fault his efforts.
 
Should only come on as a sub when we are defending a score. Terrible otherwise. With him and Bruno on the pitch we can't get the ball anywhere.
 
Walrus said:
A thought to the agenda driven haters - Fred could not have done what Scott did today. He shielded our defence, made several tackles, headers and clearances.

The front three/four/five were largely anonymous today, yet some want to blame McTominay - who was playing as a #6 - for the lack of attacking fluidity. Nonsense.

I would love to see him get some games alongside/in front of Casemiro, so that he has more opportunity to bomb forward and offer a goal threat, as we saw one instance of today.
Click to expand...

How is it an agenda to recognise that he was part of the reason we couldn't control the game in midfield? In the end, the necessity for that defensive performance came from the fact that he failed in his role to bring more stability to the middle with his passing and positioning. It is not an agenda, just recognition that he played a major part of that failure and it needs to be considered in his ratings.

Good defensively, but not very good in the other areas. It is sort of rewarding someone more than they should be due to inadequacies. We are playing Southampton not Manchester City, where something like this would be far more understandable.

The likelihood is that it will be Casemiro and Eriksen - I think it is pretty clear that Ten Hag wants someone good at passing in that other position.
 
In the 2nd half with us bunkering down, he does a good job defending because he has the height and doesn't have to do much reading of the game. He can just defend by winning headers and defending what's right in front of him.

He was helpful in that regard.
 
CarbonStoolBites said:
There’s not much he can do to win over some of the supporters at this point.
He’s been crucial today, I don’t know if we’re winning the game without him, few important clearances from their crosses, read the game well, passed the ball well.

If it was Rodri or Fabinho or someone people would be praising what a great player they are.

He’s been excellent these past two matches, well done Scott.
Click to expand...
Agree 100%.
Some are ready to dish out criticism regardless of performance or some praise with criticism added in.
It's nice to see some to look at the match without an 'agenda ?' and review McTom's performance in the match.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.