Zidane is obviously better, do you dispute that?
Samuel Eto'o
- Thread starter Brwned
- Start date
Zidane is obviously better, do you dispute that?
Exactly.
so Vidic > Bosingwa at centre back
But lets put Vidic at right back...
Now whos better?
Vidic would defend better than Bosingwa, but as a full back, Bosingwa would offer more in an attacking sense, and still manage to do a decent job defensively.
Therefore at Right back Bosingwa > Vidic.
Your a feckin blind cnut mate.
I said.
Zidane > Bramble at playing in midfield. But admit this...if you threw Zidane in at centre back..he wouldnt have a clue what to do...
Therefore Bramble at centre back (and thats a key point, thats why I've put it in bold) > Zidane at centre back (again, key point)
But as a player, Vidic > Bosingwa.
You cannot compare the two. Their two different players.
...Thus says HsJ.
It could be an endless debate....
Bramble > Zidane.
If you had a one on one, then Zidane would win, of course. But thats because Bramble hasnt a clue on how to attack. Hence Defence Vs Attack. Therefore you cannot compare the two
Compare Zidane and Scholes and the like. Seriously why is this so hard to comprehend?
Compare Zidane and Scholes and the like. Seriously why is this so hard to comprehend?
Its like you dont read it. Just pick out the little points...
You should work for The Sun. Tabloid whore.
It doesn't make sense, could you run it by me one more time with a different comparison?
god your tedious. And you've resorted to insulting brwnd which makes your rubbish argument even more rubbish. Yes you can compare players in different positions. Why do you think they have awards for recognizing the best players in the gAme? All thee players may contribute different things to the team by virtue of their roles and positions they carry out their duties from, but Ultimately they all contribute to the team brig successful. And we can compare their utility.
Vidic is the best centre back in the world.
Bosingwa is an average right back.
Vidic would walk into any team in the world.
Bosingwa wouldn't.
Vidic is in with a chance to win the award for best player in the league this season.
Bosingw is definitely not.
Vidic is breaking records with his contribution at the back for united.
Bosingwa has been average.
Hence vidic as a centre back has been better than bosingwa as a right back . Hope you understood
Vidic is the best centre back in the world.
Bosingwa is an average right back.
Vidic would walk into any team in the world.
Bosingwa wouldn't.
Vidic is in with a chance to win the award for best player in the league this season.
Bosingw is definitely not.
Vidic is breaking records with his contribution at the back for united.
Bosingwa has been average.
Hence vidic as a centre back has been better than bosingwa as a right back . Hope you understood
Quite sure your takin the piss but I'll carry on anyway...
Compare Eto'o and Rio...
Eto'o is better than Rio at taking the ball passed players, scoring, dribbling etc
Rio is better than Eto'o at heading, marking, reading the game, etc
Therefore Eto'o Vs Rio would turn into a defence vs attack situation with only one player coming out on top, goal wise...Eto'o...
does that mean Eto'o is better than Rio? No, because Eto'o is a better attacker whereas Rio is a better defender.
Lacking the necessary logic to comprehend this arguement. Especially the Pigeon.
The two which are in bold are opinion.
The rest are dependent on team performances.
Edit: this isn't just about Vidic and Bosingwa, that is an example. Its about comparing players in different positions. You cant do it.
Not necessarily.
Rio's quite good at going forward, and brilliant defensively. Eto'o brilliant going forward, but rubbish defensively.
I'd bet on Rio winning that match.
...tell me, do you think Kieran Richardson has as much ability as Ryan Giggs? What's your stance on left footed penalty takers?
No I dont. Giggs is way better than Richardson in every single aspect of his game. See you can compare these two as they play in the same position.
Left footed penalty takers have as much chance of scoring than right sided. Theoretically
Player wants to stay. Club wants to keep top player. It's not rocket science
You have a cheek to accuse me of looking stupid while you rehash one of the Rubbermans daftest arguements about comparing players
Does Bramble > Zidane mean nothing to you?!
phew that was a close one. Thought we had another kemo on our hands there...
.....you don't support Bayern Munich by any chance?
I don't know who offered the Bramble > Zidane idea up first. Its a stupid comparison.
as a talent. Sure Zidane is better, theres no comparison. But the arguement is that you cannot compare him to Bramble in a TEAM situation. Because Bramble is a better centre back yet Zidane is a better Midfielder.
But again, its like taking two opposite sides of the spectrum.
Maybe another specification of comparing players is that they should be of similar ability. I.e. only comparing world class players with world class players.
as a talent. Sure Zidane is better, theres no comparison. But the arguement is that you cannot compare him to Bramble in a TEAM situation. Because Bramble is a better centre back yet Zidane is a better Midfielder.
But again, its like taking two opposite sides of the spectrum.
Maybe another specification of comparing players is that they should be of similar ability. I.e. only comparing world class players with world class players.
Depends how much the club wants to keep him, you know as much about it as I do.
I do know all about that, and that left footed penalty takers are more unpredictable, and Richardson was as talented as Giggs.
It means plenty.
you can and I just did. Those are opinions but even if I'm wrong I'm not far off which signifies the gulf between the two.
I don't have the patience for this. You seem like one of those whose just made up his mind and struggles to consider a differenting opinion or take on things actually being the corect one. Could just be slating to this topic though.
No. Does your dad?
I was not aware the Chief once argued Kieran Richardson has as much ability as Ryan Giggs. Can't believe I missed that gem.
.....my dad is Owen Hargreaves.
This maybe true. But I just find things like "world player of the year" a joke. There should be awards for the best full back, centre back, goalkeeper, midfielder, (maybe winger), and striker.
Because everytime a defender wins the world player of the year its branded as a joke.
Didn't answer the question. Again highlighting your lack of ability to read and comprehend.
And how much do you suspect Barca want to keep the best striker in the game right now? Scoring shedloads of goals for them by the game?
Too much WUM'ing on this forum to ever throw a logical arguement up. People trying to throw illogical comparisons in to make you look stupid. Maybe if you grew a brain cell and began to read what people write instead of attempting to set them up you would be able to contribute more to an arguement.
HsJ once again this week showing that he's a retard.
I've never seen you here before either.
HsJ once again this week showing that he's a retard.
I've never seen you here before either.
Mate...your a tool
Math is for losers.
Hur hur hur.
Hur hur hur.
Maybe. But then again its also for people with brain.
Must try harder.