AFC NimbleThumb
New Member
- Joined
- Apr 21, 2019
- Messages
- 8,363
Good post & the first paragraph is exactly why I also found the outrage of the Super League quite funny. If we go through how many teams have won the EPL since it’s inauguration it’s a rather small/elite group & it’s in effect a bunch of domestic Super clubs. Leicester somewhat an outlier of course.Actually around the super league time I made systematic posts about the football league pyramid and how inflation (which yes part of it was down to our ownership) has shut off the dream for many clubs. I have a soft spot for a town I use to live in (Plymouth, get to that in a minute) so I can firmly see things from both angles. The reason I struggled to join in the outrage (which in my opinion was only as ferocious as it was because Gary Neville whipped the country into a frenzy on almost certainly the orders of his employers) was because in my opinion the PL and UCL are both super leagues in all but name.
The worst thing for the pyramid was the TV money and parachute payments. Granted it was a by-product of the Fizsman, Roman, Sheikh etc using their resources to propel their respective sides to titles and improve the PL brand but not one club decided to take a stand against such inflation of 'reward' money.
It means the likes of Norwich and Fulham can just get relegated and buy promotion again without breaking sweat (£180m is the "reward" for finishing bottom). In 2007 Colchester United made a genuine push for the Championship play off narrowly missing out, three years later Blackpool actually went two better and made the big time. That route is now cut off for clubs like that barring extraordinarily good coaching and about 1000 other things falling neatly into place. Look at this years Championship table as a reference point, utterly dominated by recent PL clubs. Two of the clubs relegated the season before last bounced straight back and the other is almost certain to follow suit this season (alongside a team relegated last campaign). None of those clubs are particularly well run yet because of the parachute payments they don't need to be to outmuscle most of that league.
I know someone connected to Plymouth and pre TV money they believe the plan and structure they now have in place would have got them to the top flight, now they'll settle for just being a mid table Championship club because they simply cannot compete with the teams yo yoing off TV money.
People slate clubs down the bottom for binning the cups to focus on avoid relegation but look at two that didn't, Birmingham and Wigan, they went down the same season they won a domestic Cup and it was at a very bad time (with reward money slowly becoming very prominent) and probably won't see the light of the top flight again in our lifetime.
What I do take issue with is ‘the worst’ statement. TV Money in itself isn’t the issue but as you tackle later on the parachute structure in place rewards failure. That said, how is that anymore damaging than an oligarch giving a club a £1.5bil loan they never have to pay back simply because, PR. I genuinely think that’s more damaging as it can’t be collectively bargained. As you said no club took a stand against reward money but in effect it’s something you can change whereas you’ve effectively been given 7/8 parachute payments + any actual competition payments you’ve seen in the process.
I actually don’t have a problem with what your club did, it broke the United dominance & gave new breath to the competition so it’s easy to see why people turned a blind eye. What I do have a massive issue with are people normalising the financial doping that has taken place, ‘we’re self sustainable’ well yes with a £1.5bil debt/loan you’re not asked to service.
You’ve obviously faced similar points before as a Chelsea fan so all those points are right, there are other issues in the game but what Chelsea were allowed to do hasn’t just set the game back it’s broken it. I’m reminded of the Ashley Cole transfer, not only does it inflate wages it destabilised a rival in a way unlike a bosman transfer. You’ve then got Jon Obi-Mikel’s fiasco of a transfer. It’s was rather unsavoury early on.