Religion, what's the point?

I have a serious distrust of anybody religious regardless of their religion, I'd call myself a militant atheist, I've no problem telling anybody religious that I think they're absolutely bat-shit crazy. I've started questioning their motives in day to day life and I guess it's getting worse; to the point where I'm asking myself would I rather by on a plane being flown by a religious person or an atheist, would I rather my doctor was religious or an atheist (my girlfriend's doctor is religious and at her surgery they can abstain from prescribing certain treatments), would I rather my child was being taught by someone religious or an atheist, and so on and so on.

Ultimately I'm asking myself who would I trust more to save my life in any given situation, the atheist who understands the value of life and how precious it is and lives for today or the religious nutter who's living for someone else and a supposed afterlife and whose actions (albeit good) are driven be the selfish need to impress some non-entity so they ultimately get rewarded for them.

This is getting worse for me given so many people are religious around me, I'm always questioning their motives, day to day, even at work, at the supermarket (I'd always visit the checkout being manned by someone who wasn't wearing a religious symbol e.g. a crucifix). Perhaps I'm bat-shit crazy too.

Edit, this made me laugh: http://thesciencepost.com/new-law-m...-nurses-to-refuse-care-to-religious-patients/
 
Last edited:
Rudie said:
I have a serious distrust of anybody religious regardless of their religion, I'd call myself a militant atheist, I've no problem telling anybody religious that I think they're absolutely bat-shit crazy. I've started questioning their motives in day to day life and I guess it's getting worse; to the point where I'm asking myself would I rather by on a plane being flown by a religious person or an atheist, would I rather my doctor was religious or an atheist (my girlfriend's doctor is religious and at her surgery they can abstain from prescribing certain treatments), would I rather my child was being taught by someone religious or an atheist, and so on and so on.

Ultimately I'm asking myself who would I trust more to save my life in any given situation, the atheist who understands the value of life and how precious it is and lives for today or the religious nutter who's living for someone else and a supposed afterlife and whose actions (albeit good) are driven be the selfish need to impress some non-entity so they ultimately get rewarded for them.

This is getting worse for me given so many people are religious around me, I'm always questioning their motives, day to day, even at work, at the supermarket (I'd always visit the checkout being manned by someone who wasn't wearing a religious symbol e.g. a crucifix). Perhaps I'm bat-shit crazy too.

Edit, this made me laugh: http://thesciencepost.com/new-law-m...-nurses-to-refuse-care-to-religious-patients/
Click to expand...

I don't think you have any option other than gunning down all the religious people you know.
 
I still think peoples motivations are basically irrelevant, and far too complicated and messy to be as simple as 'for religious reasons'
or 'so they get into heaven'.
Anyway ...

InfiniteBoredom said:
Doesn't entitle it to claim moral absolutism over 20% of the world population and beyond.

And we are falling into the trap of relativism going down that road I.e all are corrupted, hence its fine for religious institutions. Except that the latter serve for no practical purposes that can't be performed by secular ones.
Click to expand...

I didn't say its fine for it to be corrupt, just that i almost expect it from an organisation with that much influence.
As for the second line there isn't always a choice involved. If penna's church group stopped feeding people would a secular organisation pick it up?
 
Rudie said:
I have a serious distrust of anybody religious regardless of their religion, I'd call myself a militant atheist, I've no problem telling anybody religious that I think they're absolutely bat-shit crazy. I've started questioning their motives in day to day life and I guess it's getting worse; to the point where I'm asking myself would I rather by on a plane being flown by a religious person or an atheist, would I rather my doctor was religious or an atheist (my girlfriend's doctor is religious and at her surgery they can abstain from prescribing certain treatments), would I rather my child was being taught by someone religious or an atheist, and so on and so on.

Ultimately I'm asking myself who would I trust more to save my life in any given situation, the atheist who understands the value of life and how precious it is and lives for today or the religious nutter who's living for someone else and a supposed afterlife and whose actions (albeit good) are driven be the selfish need to impress some non-entity so they ultimately get rewarded for them.

This is getting worse for me given so many people are religious around me, I'm always questioning their motives, day to day, even at work, at the supermarket (I'd always visit the checkout being manned by someone who wasn't wearing a religious symbol e.g. a crucifix). Perhaps I'm bat-shit crazy too.

Edit, this made me laugh: http://thesciencepost.com/new-law-m...-nurses-to-refuse-care-to-religious-patients/
Click to expand...
You quite impressively sound like a nutter yourself there.
 
Not sure if posted but I love Gervais, talks a lot of sense in a world full of loonies. Love his take on agnosticism :D

 
:lol:@Silva 's post count in this thread is worse than mine in the DM one. Think we are both a tad obsessed.
 
I'm amazed how many churches there are here in this little part of Ohio/WV. My observations of folk however is that most are religious because that's how they were brought up.
 
Rudie said:
I have a serious distrust of anybody religious regardless of their religion, I'd call myself a militant atheist, I've no problem telling anybody religious that I think they're absolutely bat-shit crazy. I've started questioning their motives in day to day life and I guess it's getting worse; to the point where I'm asking myself would I rather by on a plane being flown by a religious person or an atheist, would I rather my doctor was religious or an atheist (my girlfriend's doctor is religious and at her surgery they can abstain from prescribing certain treatments), would I rather my child was being taught by someone religious or an atheist, and so on and so on.

Ultimately I'm asking myself who would I trust more to save my life in any given situation, the atheist who understands the value of life and how precious it is and lives for today or the religious nutter who's living for someone else and a supposed afterlife and whose actions (albeit good) are driven be the selfish need to impress some non-entity so they ultimately get rewarded for them.

This is getting worse for me given so many people are religious around me, I'm always questioning their motives, day to day, even at work, at the supermarket (I'd always visit the checkout being manned by someone who wasn't wearing a religious symbol e.g. a crucifix). Perhaps I'm bat-shit crazy too.

Edit, this made me laugh: http://thesciencepost.com/new-law-m...-nurses-to-refuse-care-to-religious-patients/
Click to expand...

You're discriminating based on religion though. Which you justify by assuming 'religious people are all wrong and atheists are ultimately correct'. And I'm an atheist but atheists can be more immoral than 'believers'.

Plenty of great men and women are religious. Darwin despite his findings was religious. Many women I've had relationships were religious and found solace and comfort from their faith with difficult circumstances. Who really wants to tell them 'sorry love that's a load of shit, you're fecked, there's no hope, now accept it and give up on life'.

I think religion is actually a pretty good defense mechanism.
 
MrMarcello said:
Yes, parental inference and social pressures.
Click to expand...

Also probably a key component of local communities. In some rural areas where feck all happens I imagine it keeps older people in touch, allows people to meet each other etc.
 
WackyWengerWorld said:
You're discriminating based on religion though. Which you justify by assuming 'religious people are all wrong and atheists are ultimately correct'. And I'm an atheist but atheists can be more immoral than 'believers'.

Plenty of great men and women are religious. Darwin despite his findings was religious. Many women I've had relationships were religious and found solace and comfort from their faith with difficult circumstances. Who really wants to tell them 'sorry love that's a load of shit, you're fecked, there's no hope, now accept it and give up on life'.

I think religion is actually a pretty good defense mechanism.
Click to expand...

Darwin was not religious in any sense other than that he was raised as so. He was a self declared agnostic:

"an Agnostic would be the more correct description of my state of mind."
 
Rudie said:
I have a serious distrust of anybody religious regardless of their religion, I'd call myself a militant atheist, I've no problem telling anybody religious that I think they're absolutely bat-shit crazy. I've started questioning their motives in day to day life and I guess it's getting worse; to the point where I'm asking myself would I rather by on a plane being flown by a religious person or an atheist, would I rather my doctor was religious or an atheist (my girlfriend's doctor is religious and at her surgery they can abstain from prescribing certain treatments), would I rather my child was being taught by someone religious or an atheist, and so on and so on.

Ultimately I'm asking myself who would I trust more to save my life in any given situation, the atheist who understands the value of life and how precious it is and lives for today or the religious nutter who's living for someone else and a supposed afterlife and whose actions (albeit good) are driven be the selfish need to impress some non-entity so they ultimately get rewarded for them.

This is getting worse for me given so many people are religious around me, I'm always questioning their motives, day to day, even at work, at the supermarket (I'd always visit the checkout being manned by someone who wasn't wearing a religious symbol e.g. a crucifix). Perhaps I'm bat-shit crazy too.

Edit, this made me laugh: http://thesciencepost.com/new-law-m...-nurses-to-refuse-care-to-religious-patients/
Click to expand...

You're firm in your beliefs that govern how you behave. Sounds like a religion to me. So you're basically super religious.
 
shamans said:
You're firm in your beliefs that govern how you behave. Sounds like a religion to me. So you're basically super religious.
Click to expand...

No, he's dogmatically anti-religion - that doesn't make him religious.

The main religions are dogmatic, that's how they've survived, but don't confuse anyone who dogmatically believes something with someone who submits their reality, rightly or wrongly, to an organized, established religion.

Opposing dogmatic religion is very difficult to do without asserting your own views dogmatically.

People are often literally born into the main religions - or they're born into an area which leans heavily toward one of the main ones - and in many cases, to break free from that type of institutionalized psychology must take a lot of self-assertiveness and soul searching in which developing a dogmatic approach might be needed in order to defeat the 'other' dogma that the person was born into.
 
Rudie said:
I have a serious distrust of anybody religious regardless of their religion, I'd call myself a militant atheist, I've no problem telling anybody religious that I think they're absolutely bat-shit crazy. I've started questioning their motives in day to day life and I guess it's getting worse; to the point where I'm asking myself would I rather by on a plane being flown by a religious person or an atheist, would I rather my doctor was religious or an atheist (my girlfriend's doctor is religious and at her surgery they can abstain from prescribing certain treatments), would I rather my child was being taught by someone religious or an atheist, and so on and so on.

Ultimately I'm asking myself who would I trust more to save my life in any given situation, the atheist who understands the value of life and how precious it is and lives for today or the religious nutter who's living for someone else and a supposed afterlife and whose actions (albeit good) are driven be the selfish need to impress some non-entity so they ultimately get rewarded for them.

This is getting worse for me given so many people are religious around me, I'm always questioning their motives, day to day, even at work, at the supermarket (I'd always visit the checkout being manned by someone who wasn't wearing a religious symbol e.g. a crucifix). Perhaps I'm bat-shit crazy too.

Edit, this made me laugh: http://thesciencepost.com/new-law-m...-nurses-to-refuse-care-to-religious-patients/
Click to expand...


I am curious, why do you think that atheists know that "life is precious"?

I don't believe in a god, I think we are the products of Evolution, but I can't find any "precious" qualities in the process. It took billions of years of self replicating genes to build intelligent beings (us) who ended up asking questions about the purpose of life. But ultimately, this process doesn't seem to have a goal, so I wouldn't call it "precious".

I'd say I am jealous of religious people. At least, they believe in a purpose that transcends this process of life and death. To them perhaps life is precious because it is just a step to something bigger.
 
I have a deep mistrust of religious people. They either want my money or my arse.
 
nick2004 said:
I am curious, why do you think that atheists know that "life is precious"?

I don't believe in a god, I think we are the products of Evolution, but I can't find any "precious" qualities in the process. It took billions of years of self replicating genes to build intelligent beings (us) who ended up asking questions about the purpose of life. But ultimately, this process doesn't seem to have a goal, so I wouldn't call it "precious".

I'd say I am jealous of religious people. At least, they believe in a purpose that transcends this process of life and death. To them perhaps life is precious because it is just a step to something bigger.
Click to expand...
On the same token, for a non-believer, wouldn't life be seen as precious because it's all you've got?
 
nick2004 said:
I'd say I am jealous of religious people. At least, they believe in a purpose that transcends this process of life and death. To them perhaps life is precious because it is just a step to something bigger.
Click to expand...

I'm jealous because they can go through life, and see criminals succeeding, and sincerely believe that they will rot in hell. For a non-believer like me, I know that Hitler lived a good life and tortured and killed millions with no punishment.
 
berbatrick said:
I'm jealous because they can go through life, and see criminals succeeding, and sincerely believe that they will rot in hell. For a non-believer like me, I know that Hitler lived a good life and tortured and killed millions with no punishment.
Click to expand...
I think I know what you want to say, that he lived a good life according to him and his followers. Am I right ?
 
berbatrick said:
I'm jealous because they can go through life, and see criminals succeeding, and sincerely believe that they will rot in hell. For a non-believer like me, I know that Hitler lived a good life and tortured and killed millions with no punishment.
Click to expand...
Yeah but at least he died cowering in a bunker with the Red Army at his doorstep after watching his "1000 year Reich" crumble after just 5 years of fighting the "racially inferior" Soviets. His last thoughts before biting the capsule and pulling the trigger had to be tortureous.
 
Carolina Red said:
Yeah but at least he died cowering in a bunker with the Red Army at his doorstep after watching his "1000 year Reich" crumble after just 5 years of fighting the "racially inferior" Soviets. His last thoughts before biting the capsule and pulling the trigger had to be tortureous.
Click to expand...

Agreed. If only it could have been drawn out and extended over a long period of time.
 
Carolina Red said:
Yeah but at least he died cowering in a bunker with the Red Army at his doorstep after watching his "1000 year Reich" crumble after just 5 years of fighting the "racially inferior" Soviets. His last thoughts before biting the capsule and pulling the trigger had to be tortureous.
Click to expand...

Very true.


Silva said:
He did have one of balls shot off tbf.
Click to expand...

There is a god after all.


RedTiger said:
Does that make you feel angry or just ambivalent?
Click to expand...

If I think about it, angry at Hitler, and a little resentful that there is no heaven and hell. Then I get thankful that they don't exist, because if any religious text is to be believed, I'll probably end up right alongside Hitler.
 
Carolina Red said:
Yeah but at least he died cowering in a bunker with the Red Army at his doorstep after watching his "1000 year Reich" crumble after just 5 years of fighting the "racially inferior" Soviets. His last thoughts before biting the capsule and pulling the trigger had to be tortureous.
Click to expand...
And yet... if he got down on one knee and asked 'god' for forgiveness and given himself to the lord at that point, he'd be in heaven.

Something seriously screwed in that logic
 
JASR said:
And yet... if he got down on one knee and asked 'god' for forgiveness and given himself to the lord at that point, he'd be in heaven.

Something seriously screwed in that logic
Click to expand...


If i walk down the street this morning, see a stunning looking woman and think to myself "cor, I'd feck the arse off that" I'm breaking one of the Ten Commandments and unless I go to a confession booth I'm condemning myself to the fiery pits off hell.

Alternatively, if I walk into my office with an AK 47 and kill every single person in the building all I need do is head to confession and in the eyes of the church am absolved of sin and can happily pass into heaven.

The logic is seriously flawed.
 
Is there anyone who is actually religious posting in this thread or are they all scared away?
 
This is a "Religion - what's the point" thread. So basically a thread for atheists and non-believers. Hardly 'any point' posting in this thread if minds have already been made up. What we need is a "The Religion" (not the poster, he's a twat :p ) thread where we can discuss, er, all the religions.
 
Randall Flagg said:
Is there anyone who is actually religious posting in this thread or are they all scared away?
Click to expand...
I do very occasionally, but there's not much point (for me). You believe or you don't believe, you have your own journey to faith or away from faith. Sometimes that changes over the course of a lifetime, sometimes people are decided one way or the other all their lives. It's either extremely important to you or of no importance at all.

There are good people who are people of faith, there are good people who are atheists. Similarly with people who aren't so good.
 
Dumbstar said:
This is a "Religion - what's the point" thread. So basically a thread for atheists and non-believers. Hardly 'any point' posting in this thread if minds have already been made up. What we need is a "The Religion" (not the poster, he's a twat :p ) thread where we can discuss, er, all the religions.
Click to expand...

What's stopping anyone from doing that here ?
 
One view.

When we killed - or exiled - God, we also killed ourselves. Did we notice this sufficiently at the time ? No God, no afterlife, no us. We were right to kill Him, of course, this long-standing imaginary friend of ours. And we weren't going to get an afterlife anyway. But we sawed off the branch we were sitting on. And the view from there, from that height - even if it was only the illusion of a view - wasn't so bad.
 
Dumbstar said:
This is a "Religion - what's the point" thread. So basically a thread for atheists and non-believers. Hardly 'any point' posting in this thread if minds have already been made up. What we need is a "The Religion" (not the poster, he's a twat :p ) thread where we can discuss, er, all the religions.
Click to expand...
I would say if religious people werent ridiculed on here you might see more of a 2 sided argument
 
Penna said:
This is probably true. Personally, I don't really want to be ridiculed during my forum-browsing leisure-time. :)
Click to expand...
Indeed

FWIW Im not religious at all. But I dont like to see people who dedicate their lives to something get slagged off
 
You must log in or register to reply here.