How many ‘good’ players signed post 2013 talk about United with any affection?He doesn’t talk about our club with much affection. Comes across as a right twat.
That’s one has been and two never beens.
How many ‘good’ players signed post 2013 talk about United with any affection?
Sanchez? Sancho? Pogba? Di Maria? Just to name a few of those who clearly weren’t here for football reasons.
The common factor, we had a man with a Disneyland dream handing out the biggest contract in football.
Out of those 2, has to be Sancho. Pogba had some good games. Sancho didn’t put any effort inCan't decide whether Pogba or Sancho is my most disliked United player of the more recent era.
Why is that a surprise? Firstly, it's an interview by the British media and he has spent the majority of his career at United. A lot has been said about his time by fans and media alike. If he wasn't asked about United, it would be strange.He came back and the first thing he does is to talk about United. I feel sorry for the guy. He must have a lot of regret and thinks he could have done way better. I don't agree with that but I can empathize with it. His past expectation is eating himself from the inside.
It’s not even an apt comparison. But maybe you’ve got your own personal reasons why it makes sense to you.Can't decide whether Pogba or Sancho is my most disliked United player of the more recent era.
Pogba was a decent player who could have, but never was, in anything other than flashes, brilliant.
I think it's more from a betrayal of club angle. Oh I just noticed your username!It’s not even an apt comparison. But maybe you’ve got your own personal reasons why it makes sense to you.
Out of those 2, has to be Sancho. Pogba had some good games. Sancho didn’t put any effort in
What is his supposed to do then ? What's the blueprint for when you lose a game ? Cause at that point the damage is done and the rest is just PR irrelevancyTalks about hating to lose, then 5 mins after a defeat will be in the changing rooms dabbing with Lingard. I just cannot take these guys seriously, sorry.
Fergie could afford to have passengers like Cleverley and Gibson playing important games because the core of the team around them was still made up of Carrick, Scholes, Giggs, Rooney, Valencia and later Van Persie. We don’t have anywhere near that kind of quality or commitment in any position right now and the closest we have is Bruno. You start noticing the holes in your lawn when you cut the grass short. Balance is not what made Van De Beek flop, he was just not very good. Mount is a deluxe version of him.You don't get it. SAF won the league comfortably with Cleverley in midfield. He did so not because he wanted to make his life difficult by playing a low EPL table level player but because Cleverley with his workrate provided balance to an ageing Carrick and an ancient Scholes. Balance had always been the key to success. When SAF added Ronaldo he made sure he surrounded him with ample runners (Tevez, Rooney, Park and Gaz) to cover for the Portuguese lack of workrate.
That balance is what United lack and its the reason why our players perform well with their national side but play horribly with us. We're so absorbed into the manager's whacky tactics/philosophies that we've forget the very basis of success.
A- Every player have his strengths and weaknesses. We have to take those into account and the only thing that categorize a player between a success to a failure is that his strengths outweigh his weaknesses
B- If a player has X weakness then somewhere along the line that need to be addressed by someone else. Else that weakness will one day be noticed and once that happens it would be exploited up until the manager's head is on the chopping block.
Some of you need to let that hate go.
I don't understand how it's even a question.Can't decide whether Pogba or Sancho is my most disliked United player of the more recent era.
Doesn't matter what this bellend says or does, he'll always be known as a cheating drug user.
Surprised anyone will want to take him on.
Next stop: Celebrity Big Brother.
Fergie could afford to have passengers like Cleverley and Gibson playing important games because the core of the team around them was still made up of Carrick, Scholes, Giggs, Rooney, Valencia and later Van Persie. We don’t have anywhere near that kind of quality or commitment in any position right now and the closest we have is Bruno. You start noticing the holes in your lawn when you cut the grass short. Balance is not what made Van De Beek flop, he was just not very good. Mount is a deluxe version of him.
I think we agree on most things except Cleverley. Fergusons late stage teams were adept at making very few mistakes and punishing opponents severely for their mistakes. He solved the premier league winning algorithm by around 2006 and kept spamming it even after losing the quality of Ronaldo. This on the contrary is a side that makes a lot of mistakes on the ball, invites pressure, lacks workrate and then struggles to finish chances even when winning the ball in good areas.Cleverley was anything but a passenger. Sure he was technically weak but his superb work rate provided the legs that old CM needed. That team was geared solely on squeezing the last gram of juice from a technically superb but ageing side. We played a painfully boring football (ok not to the extent of LVG's football or ETH's football against Villa) with loads of mature heads out there who created a limited but still significant amount of chances for RVP to score.
Fast forward time and that's exactly what we lack. We play a RB as a LB because the England national team full timer and ETH's protegee are always injured, Martinez is the pocket sized version of De Ligt (both are very aggressive, ball playing CBs that aren't gifted with tons of pace), Mazraoui is good but he's injury prone, in midfield Casemiro is ancient and we lack the midfield for a single pivot (neither Ugarte nor Casemiro are good enough for that role), Mainoo is still too young, Eriksen/Mount are 10s playing as an 8 and Bruno is another no 10. On the flanks we've got Garnacho and Rashford who think that they are Cristiano Ronaldo (in terms of workrate) but has 1/10 of his talent while no one cares who we got upfront simply because the ball is not going there.
This obsession with playing two no 10s in CM is stupid. You need a Rodri or a prime Keane for that. We don't have that and even if there was a Keane or a Rodri around we would probably not afford it
I think we agree on most things except Cleverley. Fergusons late stage teams were adept at making very few mistakes and punishing opponents severely for their mistakes. He solved the premier league winning algorithm by around 2006 and kept spamming it even after losing the quality of Ronaldo. This on the contrary is a side that makes a lot of mistakes on the ball, invites pressure, lacks workrate and then struggles to finish chances even when winning the ball in good areas.
Regarding Celverley, he was still around for Moyes in a side that was relatively unchanged outside of Scholes retiring and stuck out like a sore thumb week after week, forcing Moyes to play a center back like Jones to have that exact work rate you’re talking about him offering while not being an utter liability on the ball.
It’s funny isn’t it. Players used to leave here and we’d either support them on their journey after or forget about them the second they leave.I don't understand why people are so bitter towards him and other players. We've become a graveyard for talented players. We'll ruin anyone who comes here. There is no player who can't be made to look like a league 2 player at United but let's continue to berate each and every one of them.
Some right weirdos on here who are frothing at the mouth Souness style whenever his name is uttered. Pogba was our best player for a few years. At his best, a joy to watch. He had magic in his boots.This fanbase is so angry and bitter these days I get it in a way because we’re shit, but practically every ex player of ours gets so much bile thrown their way.
It was obvious Pogba wanted out, our shite board should have acted accordingly and helped everyone out.
Pogba was doomed the moment we brought Bruno. We also ruined VDB career and unless injuries ruins him first then we'll probably do the same with Mount. This two no 10s nonsense needs to stop.
Pogba spent most of his time here trying to leave. The club knew he wanted out, you couldnt avoid the circus. Bruno was a creative replacementPogba was doomed the moment we brought Bruno. We also ruined VDB career and unless injuries ruins him first then we'll probably do the same with Mount. This two no 10s nonsense needs to stop.
Yes and no.He was able to ply a proper midfield role for France. He didnt put in the same effort without the ball for us
He was able to ply a proper midfield role for France. He didnt put in the same effort without the ball for us
Every man and his dog knows that Pogba plays like a child. Scholes said it and Pogba himself admitted that the deeper he plays the less effective he becomes. He needs experienced players at his back to do the dirty work for him and to keep him under control
I'd say there were three spells where he was really really good - the time you mention with Matic and Herrera doing the legwork, the lockdown period where him and Bruno really seemed to have worked something out, and a brief period after that where he found himself playing left wing.He was amazing under Ole, particuallary during Ole's 1st year. I remember thinking it was a joy to actually watch Pobga play.