Cantona'sCollar
Full Member
This guy.
He's a better dribbler than most wingers he comes up against.
He certainly woke the feck up this season.
He's added goals and assists to his game which is brilliant to see. Hope he keeps it up. Attacking wise, he's the best left back around currently.
At least one of the replay angles made me wonder if Evra's header was even on target (while I couldn't even see Vidic touching it in others). Has anyone analysed it with sexy 3D CGI?Can't believe that he wasn't given the goal today, even though it did glance off Vidic.
I used to always curse his crossing ability, but it does seem to have become more dangerous.
He used to be all dribbling and not much else. I often expected moves to break up with him. That's not being harsh, he was still one of the best full-backs around, just lacked the killer balls of someone like Baines.
He's making me forget all that this season though.
Fair question...had he been this productive around about 2009, would he have been performing at a level comparable to some of the very best full backs to have played the game? I mean, he was genuinely incredible at that point defensively and in the build up, and that was the only part of his game that wasn't top notch.
Whilst the goals are a welcome addition to his game, I also felt there were still defensive lapses in his game on show yesterday. Slow tracking back and lacks urgency I think.
I stumbled across this article comparing Evra, Baines and Cole. At a time when people are still accusing Evra of being lazy and a liability I found it quite interesting the vast difference in defensive contributions.
http://giggsboson.tumblr.com/post/40023686454/left-full-backs-in-england-europe-a-quick
Whilst the goals are a welcome addition to his game, I also felt there were still defensive lapses in his game on show yesterday. Slow tracking back and lacks urgency I think.
Overall still a big improvement on previous seasons though, but I think defensively he is really mediocre at the moment, especially when you consider all the flak Rafael gets for supposed defensive weaknesses.
Yeah. If you watch him immediately after his square pass was intercepted on the edge of the box in the second half, he just stands watching while three other United players race towards the Liverpool player. Bewildering.
Easily. He was ridiculously good at that time, dominating the entire left part of the pitch on his own. It was just his end product that was lacking.
Agreed. The only reason I pose it as a question I think is because I haven't seen all the great full backs (think I said previously that he definitely would've been, but then revised that view when considering that I wasn't really in a position to say). I struggle to believe anyone was a lot better than Evra was during that period, never mind an Evra with better productivity.
I've made as much of an effort as possible to catch up with what I haven't seen of Denis Irwin for example, and as good as he looked I cannot say he looked better than Evra in 2009. Strikes me that Irwin was consistently a 7 or 8 out of 10 performer, but Evra in that calender year really was performing consistently at 8 or 9. It was incredible.
Fair question...had he been this productive around about 2009, would he have been performing at a level comparable to some of the very best full backs to have played the game? I mean, he was genuinely incredible at that point defensively and in the build up, and that was the only part of his game that wasn't top notch.
I argued with everyone last season Amar that his ability as a footballer was as good as ever and imo, way too important in our team to leave out. He wasn't anywhere near as bad last season as some made out, he had a few dodgy games and some poor moments but people just got a bee in their bonnet about him and tried to find ways to blame him for every single goal.
One of our most important players, no doubt. Glad he has gone up to another level this season.
I like to criticise him alot for his defensive play, but still, there isn't better fullback in the world who plays better under pressure, and creates good attack from nothing, only marcelo can be compared to him in that section:
Did Evra lick our crest on the shirt? Found an email in F365 Mailbox mentioning it, but never saw any pics.
Yeah, like a boss.Did Evra lick our crest on the shirt? Found an email in F365 Mailbox mentioning it, but never saw any pics.
Well apparently he did it again this weekend
It's boss, but slightly disconcertingly boss.
I never doubted his abilities as a footballer, he is excellent with the ball, his fitness is excellent, he hasn't lost any pace(maybe little, but it's almost impossible to note the difference), but I have problems with his defensive play, because I think he can do much better at times.
Last year he had lost a lot of pace; some of his runs, particularly where he was destroyed for pace against Lennon, showed that. That was explained by Ferguson as he played with injuries.
This season we are witnessing a fit and injury free Evra, and that is just about world class. I certainly wouldn't trade him for Baines. Evra has pace, technique, aerial ability and offensive contributions that beats that of most rivals.
This year I think he has done much better defensively also. I agree though, with I'm Always Right that he wasn't as bad last season as some would argue. He was unjustly made scape goat for most that happened, goals that were conceded after he conceded a free kick at the middle of the pitch etc. Not his fault that Evans decided to rugby tackle Rio Ferdinand who went for a header!
Yeah, I forgot to mention that last season it did look like he lost some pace, but this season he seems fresh again.