What makes you think he was decent for inter
Onana has not worked out. We need a new keeper.
- Thread starter Plant0x84
- Start date
His FC 24 rating?
bad technique strikes again. His footwork is just incredibly poor. Hopefully he can get that sorted with some better coaching perhaps.
I have no idea how bad he is overall. I can only judge how bad he's been here, and he's been absolutely shocking. His failure to do the very basics has me very worried tbh. Yes, there are obviously some factors that have made him look worse, but even without those factors, he doesn't inspire any confidence whatsoever.
Because he like you and I are human.
He is in his first season, the team is having a shit season, he has himself has been up and down, the defense is trash and he's facing record numbers of shots.
It is natural that his levels have dropped under the present circumstances.
Ten Hag got it wrong. Even with no injuries, we do not have the players or system to be able to play out of the back. This should have come first, before spending big on a keeper who is apparently great with his feet, but, as we have seen, is poor with his gloves.
It’s not about levels. It’s about knowing where to be on the pitch. His positioning is shit.
Oh look the DDG fans have crawled back out again. It’s just painful, move on he was awful which is why we him go and even then about three seasons too late.
Disagree with this actually.
Dalot - Varane - Licha - Shaw
That’s a very competent defence for playing out the back when played together. Varane is the weakest of the four, but he’s never the defender to demand the ball centrally, he defers wide, it’s shaw or Licha who demand it in the middle.
Why refer to Martinez by his first name and not the others?
Is Licha a mate of yours or something?
Yes, he was a few (12) years below me at (a different) school (on a different continent).Why refer to Martinez by his first name and not the others?
Is Licha a mate of yours or something?
There's more chance of you starting in goal next season for Manchester United than David De Gea, and that's probably a good thing as I've seen De Gea play and haven't seen you play, so there is a large chance you would be better than him.
I just can't see Onana improving enough to be worth holding onto. Look it is fair that he has never had a settled back four in front of him but he has made so many ludicrous errors. I can't imagine he'd look as bad in a settled back four. Nothing yesterday was an error really but I watched that first goal from all angles and different speeds I genuinely have no idea how he didn't save it. Anything low seems to result in a goal. He is not good enough a shot stopper and his supposed best asset, his feet, is widely exaggerated. Just another Eredivisie level player. Antony and Amrabat too can go. Not premier league standard. Inter walked the league without him if he was such a fantastic player they would surely have struggled.
Peas in a pod then
Inseparable some, but not many at all if any, might say.
Ok I thought the - was he not being an implied he was kind of question. A straight question would have just been, was he any good. Don’t know why you found it so funny to have two laughing facesIt was a question
Hence the not really following Serie A part.
It was pretty funny that you went for me when I didn't imply that I thought he was good.
I suppose, he seemed highly rated in general and I thought he was supposed to have been good for Inter. The assumption was based on us paying pretty big money after one season there. I also remember a thread about him on here during his Ajax days where plenty seemed to really rate him.
And what happens when a couple are injured?
It not just about the back four. Do we have the midfielders who want to receive the ball facing goal? Casimiro - no. Mainoo - yes. Eriksen - no. Bruno, no.
We saw the slow passing out of the back earlier in the season when we had a near full team. It was awful and went nowhere.
Went for you is a stretch
I don't think it is an exaggeration, DDG was awful on the ball. If you believe that playing out from the back is overrated then fair enough, but there's no way we'd be able to do it with DDG.
You're wrong about what happened with DDG. He was originally offered another medium-long term contract on partially reduced wages that would still have made him the highest paid goalkeeper in the country.
Thankfully the club decided against yet another inflated contract for a player on the wane, which would have tied us to DDG for years (not like we could have offloaded him, given that he can't find a club on a free), and offered a short term contract more befitting a backup keeper, that DDG rejected.
Again, Onana doesn't look like the right replacement, but we did need a replacement.
It's less about Pep making it trendy, and more about the rise of high pressing teams. Think how often players need to go back to the keeper, if they're only good for lumping the ball out then without a Fellaini like character to bypass the other team then you reduce your chances of getting on the ball.
He's staying, just accept it and move on.
Onana is the sole reason I'm an XG atheist at this stage. No stat is going to tell me something different than what my eyes see.
What happened to all the good keepers? Toldo, Frey, Canizares, Dida, Kahn etc. seems like there’s only one or two these days and they can’t maintain top level for long.
Andre Onana has 8 clean sheets in tbe league this season despite his team allowing the opposition 20+ shots every game which is a good return when you consider that Ederson who's team allow the opposition very few shots only has 1 more than him and Allisson despite being rated as the best keeper in the league has one less.
I love the faith, you’ve given me the confidence to audition.
I just have a weird feeling that they’ll see he’s still out of work, knows the club and will come back for peanuts. Let’s hope he’s settled at home in Madrid
He still lives over here, there were some video's he released recently of him using the pitch at Altrincham FC for private training sessions.
I bet he outperformed the xG stat last night too.
Playing out of the back is overrated. Vastly overrated. You clearly want to see your defenders be able to handle pressure but consistently trying to break pressures with short passing out of the back invites too much danger and easy chances for the opposition, with little gain in return. Onana's footwork is superior to Dave's but we don't have the back line or the midfielders to capitalize on the perceived benefits of having a keeper who can hit short passes quickly. Many timbers have fallen to make us easy prey for clubs like Palace, but one of them was the downgrade in the keeper, the current keeper being poor at shot-stopping, which under every paradigm of goalkeeping is a crucial attribute to be successful as a keeper.
As for Dave's contract situation, you left out a key fact -- United withdrew the offer it made to Dave once he accepted it. Even if we concede Dave was awful on the ball, that's no excuse for treating him awfully, like trash.
I don't hate de Gea so cut the crap. Both are awful for us. De Gea only for four or five seasons of decline, Onana because he's bobbins.
Again I hark back to old teams here to make my point, Liverpool of the 80s dominated their matches and didn’t have a sweeper keeper to do so, nor a target man up front.
there’s more than 1 way to skin a cat. I think we over compensate on the ball playing. Personally, I’d rather have a keeper with good basics nailed down, shot stopping, arial prowess, command of their box
You like hyperboles and that is on you. How do you describe Onana’s long range kicking i wonder?
I think ETH changed his mind at the end once again and it was handled amateurish by the club. And I’d rather have kept DDG on 150k a week for 2 more years than having Onana on 150k a week for 5 while also paying that stupid 50m fee.
The fee was 45m which is a bargain in a market where Kepa was 75m.
Onana is a better all round keeper than De Gea who was extremely limited and was a complete liability during his last season or 2 currently is.
Depends on the style of play we adopt after we sack the fraud.