Absolutely not. You either commit to a manager and his vision or you don't.
If you want an easy out quietly put a close in his contract, don't do it in a way that makes him look weak to his players/potential signings
Ole Gunnar Solskjaer | W15 D2 L4
- Thread starter Tom Van Persie
- Start date
Absolutely not. You either commit to a manager and his vision or you don't.
If you want an easy out quietly put a close in his contract, don't do it in a way that makes him look weak to his players/potential signings
Lets wait and see. May come crashing down or we may continue this incredible form till the end of the season.
I was scared as feck after reading Avram G as Avram Grant instead of Glazer. Took me some time realizing that shite
I thought the same. With each game that passes the idea of changing for Poch seems more strange.
I have completely changed my view. I wanted Poch but now am all behind Ole.
There was a bit of me that didn’t want Ole in case somehow his legendary status is tarnished in case he was unsuccessful but it just seems the logical thing now, he’s done so well. Love the guy even more than before if that’s possible.
The Di Matteo comparison really annoys me. First just because it didn’t work out for one club doesn’t mean it won’t work out for another club.
And I’m sure Di Matteo wasn’t doing that badly in his second season anyway. Chelsea’s expectations are too high. I’m sure they were 3rd when he was sacked.
Has anyone else heard “insider” news re Ole? PM me if you have, I just want to triangulate.
It is an absolute certainty that he will get the job. Can't wait for all these games in February.
For one moment, I thought Avram G in your post was Avram Grant until I realised it was Avram Glazer!
Love everything about him. Great manager and great man. Ridiculous if we don't stick with him while he's successful to try our luck with another manager. I'll prefer to stick with Ole, and he has shown he's not just about guts and motivation. His tactics have been top notch.
Let's create our Zidane.
Let's create our Zidane.
Get into the next round of the CL and win one of the Chelsea/Liverpool games and he has the job.
Ok,
If Ole don't get the job now I think it could split the fans ore far worse, fans leaving the club as well.. At least I think the board would face massive protest from the CORE fans if we start looking elsewhere at this point !
It's starting to look impossible for Ole not to get the job if it continues like this ....
If We hired someone else now, would you protest at this point?
If Ole don't get the job now I think it could split the fans ore far worse, fans leaving the club as well.. At least I think the board would face massive protest from the CORE fans if we start looking elsewhere at this point !
It's starting to look impossible for Ole not to get the job if it continues like this ....
If We hired someone else now, would you protest at this point?
Anybody basing their opinions of whether Ole deserves the job off the PSG tie needs to give their head a wobble. It's a fecking cup game - anything can happen. Same as the Chelsea game - if we win great but if not, doesn't mean a whole lot as far as management is concerned.
It's the league we should be looking at - it's the bread and butter. And so far he has been borderline flawless.
At this point, I'll be fecking depressed if we let him go and appoint a fecking Spurs manager.
It's the league we should be looking at - it's the bread and butter. And so far he has been borderline flawless.
At this point, I'll be fecking depressed if we let him go and appoint a fecking Spurs manager.
We're producing title winning form. How do you improve on this? His Cardiff stint is irrevlant as top managers are never suited to small clubs. Big clubs that have to play in certain way is more about the fit and this is the right fit. Hence why Barcelona can employ the likes of valvrede, Enrique, vilanova etc and still continue to win.
The only improvement we can make like someone earlier mentioned is better players.
Ole in for the next 10 years.
The only improvement we can make like someone earlier mentioned is better players.
Ole in for the next 10 years.
For every story about a failure there are equal amounts about successes. The opposite is true too. It's basically a lazy discussion point. Look at Zidane or Pep no managing experience before taking on huge clubs and have done well but there are other comparisons which equally don't work out. You have to take each situation on it's own merits.
Let's be honest in another other career and they said "oh come in and have a trail period before a full time contract is offered" and they did the type of job Ole is doing you would be silly to say that he shouldn't be considered. If people want to give him more time before deciding but come on he's done enough to be very carefully considered about getting the job full time.
Don’t think we need to make any decisions until the end of the season. It’s not like Ole is going to go elsewhere.
I’m in favour of giving him it though, but we don’t have to do it right now.
I’m in favour of giving him it though, but we don’t have to do it right now.
Some stat this.
It’s getting to the stage where it’d Be crazy to not give him the job. It would take a complete reversal in our form to convince me he isn’t the right man for the job.
If Ed appointed someone else now the fans would never forgive him.
If Ed appointed someone else now the fans would never forgive him.
There are three ingredients that go into making a successful top tier manager:
1. The ability to get your players to operate better as a whole than the sum of their parts through playing good football at a high level.
2. The ability handle egos and man-manage everyone to believe in you.
3. The ability to motivate your players in crunch games and get them to be psychologically strong enough to win trophies when the pressure is on.
Ole is doing 1 and 2 at the moment, and has done 3 in Norway.
Poch has only ever done 1 and 2 and has repeatedly come up short on 3.
I can't envisage Pochetinno bringing success to United as easily as I can see Solskjaer achieving it.
We need to stop hiring managers with recent histories of less than 3 out of 3 requirements: Mourinho had 1 and 3 (until inevitably losing the belief of his squad), LvG had 2 and 3 and Moyes arguably had a small degree of 1 and 2 at Everton.
Pochetinno would be a return to that flawed strategy of 'making do' with a manager that needs a leg up.
1. The ability to get your players to operate better as a whole than the sum of their parts through playing good football at a high level.
2. The ability handle egos and man-manage everyone to believe in you.
3. The ability to motivate your players in crunch games and get them to be psychologically strong enough to win trophies when the pressure is on.
Ole is doing 1 and 2 at the moment, and has done 3 in Norway.
Poch has only ever done 1 and 2 and has repeatedly come up short on 3.
I can't envisage Pochetinno bringing success to United as easily as I can see Solskjaer achieving it.
We need to stop hiring managers with recent histories of less than 3 out of 3 requirements: Mourinho had 1 and 3 (until inevitably losing the belief of his squad), LvG had 2 and 3 and Moyes arguably had a small degree of 1 and 2 at Everton.
Pochetinno would be a return to that flawed strategy of 'making do' with a manager that needs a leg up.
Reading Ole's interview before the Fulham game, he mentioned that it's easy to motivate players for the big games, but the challenge is to keep them focused on the smaller games. I like this comment a lot. I remember a player once revealed that SAF would surprisingly have very little to say before big games, as he knows the players are already focused and do not want to cloud their mind. However when Utd plays some minnows, SAF would surprise the team with very detailed plans and tactics against the smaller teams. This was his way to let them know that every game was equally important
It's easy for Ole because he's a natural leader and top manager. It's so easy for him that he doesn't even realise he's doing it.
It's not so easy for Poch, whose team have been habitual bottlers.
There is no question if Ole should be appointed. He will be .
he has inherited a squad that was not built for the long term.
He will correct that in the summer.
He also has a strong staff. As important as Ole's appointment is, Phelan also needs to be made a permanent appointment.
I feel very confident about next season.
Mind you we will do well this season too.
he has inherited a squad that was not built for the long term.
He will correct that in the summer.
He also has a strong staff. As important as Ole's appointment is, Phelan also needs to be made a permanent appointment.
I feel very confident about next season.
Mind you we will do well this season too.
which remind us under jose team used to perform poorly against bottom teams and better against top teams. His exact words:
So basically he was not motivating his squad at all and they were self motivated against top teams. And its possible that he had no clue why. I doubt a man with that gigantic ego ever introspect.
Hell of a stat
Especially when it includes Spurs and Arsenal away.
I wonder if Ed or the Glazers read and absorb what is being told here.
Never ignore/underestimate fan consensus in the Cafe.
Never ignore/underestimate fan consensus in the Cafe.
Unless there's a serious nosedive between now and May, he deserves a chance.
I'm not going to say if he wins all these big games he should get it because that's just daft. He's more than likely going to lose at some point during those fixtures, just like any other manager would. You've got to judge his tenure as a whole.
What's the worst that can happen, honestly? At least we'll be entertained with him in charge.
I'm not going to say if he wins all these big games he should get it because that's just daft. He's more than likely going to lose at some point during those fixtures, just like any other manager would. You've got to judge his tenure as a whole.
What's the worst that can happen, honestly? At least we'll be entertained with him in charge.
You omitted the silver generation of Molde that lasted from 1994 to 2000, which were successful years for that club. As stated before prior to Old appointment, Molde finished second, so it was not like their team did not have the capabilities to finish anywhere above mid table. Regardless, the Norwegian league is a poor league and you can not equate managerial achievements in that league unless, the manager took a second division team and consistently made them champions, which Ole did not do.
No need to bother posting to me, when I countered your argument and all other posters did was clarified the data I presented. After, clarification, I understood Ole achievement in a poor league, but that doesn’t change the fact that prior to his appointment Molde was in second and showed the capabilities to fight for the title. A mid table team consistently languish mid table, which Molde with that second place finished did not. If a manager does well in a league in Thailand, I wouldn’t be arsed about his achievements because the quality of football their is nothing like the top league in Europe. As stated before, it is a waste of time for me and unless those achievements are produced in either a European cup competition or in a top league, then it is irrelevant. Unless, the manager takes a second tier team and make them consistently champion in their division.
In May 2009, I wasn’t even a football fan - I only started following football during the World Cup in South Africa the following year, and I became a United fan in about October/November 2010.
10 year contract right now.
Time for a new dynasty in the true United traditions.
Time for a new dynasty in the true United traditions.
he doesnt stop, does he ??
I haven't heard a strong argument yet for the board making a decision sooner rather than later. Everything is going as well as anyone could have dreamed so far, and what do we gain from announcing Ole as the long term manager now? It's clear Ole is treating it like he is the permanent manager, from the way he's talking about the players, and talking about the future of the club. Another person in his position might start making comments to the press about how he wants the job permanently to force the boards hand but Ole isn't that sort of guy. To him it's all about what's best for the club and it's beautiful.
I think come the end of the season assuming this carries on, Ole will become the least risky choice out there and the idea of pushing Ole out and bringing in Poch will seem idiotic. If this beautiful dream comes to an end, and we crash out of the top 4 and the cups then Poch may seem like the less risky choice. But this is a decision for April/May, not now.
I think come the end of the season assuming this carries on, Ole will become the least risky choice out there and the idea of pushing Ole out and bringing in Poch will seem idiotic. If this beautiful dream comes to an end, and we crash out of the top 4 and the cups then Poch may seem like the less risky choice. But this is a decision for April/May, not now.
Ole has done an absolutely amazing. It’s actually fun watching United again. If he doesn’t get the job for next season it would be a travesty. We’ve tried big names and what did that do for us!
No decision needs to be made public now, but it would irresponsible by management not have internally made the decision to stick with Ole for, say, a 2-3 year contract.
The case for keeping Ole is overwhelming. The case for not keeping Ole is weak. But an announcement can wait for another month and it shouldn’t come at the end of the season.
The case for keeping Ole is overwhelming. The case for not keeping Ole is weak. But an announcement can wait for another month and it shouldn’t come at the end of the season.
Not sure if this has been posted before
Interesting perspectives on the appointment of Ole as caretaker.
Interesting perspectives on the appointment of Ole as caretaker.
While that’s true it just helps keep him hungry. We made the same mistakes with Mourinho. Ole wants the job so he will be happy to wait until the summer. I’m sure he’d rather it that way.
Right now I see no other candidate coming close either, but things might go wrong, will he be able to turn it around? That’s what we need to know.
What's most important? Offer artificial incentive to someone who's spent his entire life competing at the highest levels preparing for this, or offer certainty to players considering contract extensions? Surely likes of DDG will consider future prospects of the club making their decision.
Sarri and Emre both started very strong and positive and look at them now! I mean should we wait at least till May to decide whether Ole can maintain what he has done so far?
Get a grip.
Yes. For me the point is: why not wait? We're getting a DoF, who will have a lot to say about transfers, albeit hopefully in discussion with the manager. So there's no desperate rush to choose the manager right now in order to start pursuing signings for the summer. So let's just wait and see - every single game gives us more insight into what life under Ole permanently would be like, so let's keep assessing as all these big games start to come through.