Leftback99
Oscar the Grouch.
- Joined
- Jan 11, 2015
- Messages
- 16,089
Apart from City, not really no.Are our results any more inconsistent compared to other big teams? Genuinely asking. The fixture list is relentless.
Apart from City, not really no.Are our results any more inconsistent compared to other big teams? Genuinely asking. The fixture list is relentless.
Circumstances wise I would have. Injuries are coming thick and fast. We weren't good today but we still ended up missing two open goals. Last 15 minutes is what bothers me. I understand he didn't have an attacker for Bruno. But why change the shape and play 5 at the back with 3 midfielders who can't pass the ball. That was a poor tactic and not surprisingly cost us the game. He probably wanted to run away with 1-0 amd focus on west ham but now with no martial, cavani and probably even rashford we might see another 0-0 against west ham.The result isn't the problem. Do you think we would have been happy if it ended 1-0 with such performance ?
To be fair he should be able to produce SAF era attacking football with McTominay and Matic in the midfield. Fergie did it with Park and O'SHea didn't he?He needs five more world-class players before his team can stick three passes together!
Circumstances wise I would have. Injuries are coming thick and fast. We weren't good today but we still ended up missing two open goals. Last 15 minutes is what bothers me. I understand he didn't have an attacker for Bruno. But why change the shape and play 5 at the back with 3 midfielders who can't pass the ball. That was a poor tactic and not surprisingly cost us the game. He probably wanted to run away with 1-0 amd focus on west ham but now with no martial, cavani and probably even rashford we might see another 0-0 against west ham.
Don't bother about them. They'll always have their excuses.The football played is what worries me more than the result tonight, and it’s been creeping up as the seasons gone on. This is not some one off incident.
Even if we win playing like this and people make legit points about how awful we played, it’s shut down by people who say “shut the feck up, we won, why are you complaining you toxic fan. you have an agenda against ole!”
You asked a question whether fans would have taken 1-0 and the answer remains yes irrespective of whether Milan has injuries or not.You know Milan also have injuries and are missing a lot of players, right ?
Not so much the results, but there is a pattern to seems to occur more often now and the coaching staff either don't see or more worryingly don't know how to fix it.
Also, our football is awful and has been for a while now. Where is the process?
Apart from City, not really no.
You asked a question whether fans would have taken 1-0 and the answer remains yes irrespective of whether Milan has injuries or not.
I have preferred Ole's recruitment and long term vision with youth much more than the other managers you mentioned.It's not about the results, it's about the lack of improvement from a coaching perspective. Having nothing to place your faith in. They keep bringing up results and overlooking the actual concerns people are having though.
Let's play their game and judge him on results though - over 2 years in and he's no closer to any trophy, let alone major ones. Correct me if im wrong, but Jose and LVG had won trophies and it still wasn't good enough for them to avoid the sack.
So the question remains, what exactly are we intent on keeping him around for? There are clearly coaches out there who play much more progressive football, there are coaches out there who are more results orientated too.
It honestly just seems like people are just so desperate for him to be the one due to the failed managerial appointments and that he's a United legend.
I've maintained im yet to see anything I can put my faith in. If a few good results a season against big boys was enough, we should have just kept Jose. At least he won trophies here and there too.
Yeah I can only speak for myself. But there won't have been so much over reaction either had we 1-0.Yes for you, you're talking about yourself only I believe ?
We were facing a very injury riddled Milan and they dominated us for the majority of the game. Yeah no, I honestly doubt everyone would have been cheerful here.
Amazing logic! Ofcourse people will react to awful football when there’s not even a result to show for it, don’t you think? This is exactly why Jose was bad fit here, same with Ole. They haven’t got a scooby on how to coach a coherent attacking unit, unfortunately. Counter-attacking is the the most basic form of them all that doesn’t require much input from the coaching stuff.Yeah I can only speak for myself. But there won't have been so much over reaction either had we 1-0.
I have preferred Ole's recruitment and long term vision with youth much more than the other managers you mentioned.
It feels like he is at least sticking to United philosophies and planning a little bit longer term than other managers we have had. Maybe that means we need to give him more time than we did those others, for the long term vision?
However, he is learning on the job and his in game management leaves alot to be desired. Coaching maybe also, but I recall our teams dropping too deep when clinging on to leads or getting nervous at the end of games many times over the last 8 years.
Yes for you, you're talking about yourself only I believe ?
We were facing a very injury riddled Milan and they dominated us for the majority of the game. Yeah no, I honestly doubt everyone would have been cheerful here.
Comfortable? If Maguire wasn't a donkey this would've been an easy 2-0 win.Especially funny when you consider all of the snobby remarks about Serie A here constantly. The league is trash and yet Milan come to OT with lots of injuries and look so comfortable.
And james missing an open goal.Comfortable? If Maguire wasn't a donkey this would've been an easy 2-0 win.
So true! Farmers league.. They looked the better side despite missing their best players.Especially funny when you consider all of the snobby remarks about Serie A here constantly. The league is trash and yet Milan come to OT with lots of injuries and look so comfortable.
The poster asked whether fans would have been happy with 1-0. Ofcourse they would have been. My post was a response to his. Performance was poor and I don't see anyone saying otherwise.Amazing logic! Ofcourse people will react to awful football when there’s not even a result to show for it, don’t you think? This is exactly why Jose was bad fit here, same with Ole. They haven’t got a scooby on how to coach a coherent attacking unit, unfortunately. Counter-attacking is the the most basic form of them all that doesn’t require much input from the coaching stuff.
Do you not think these sorts of performances happen a little too often though? Without that City result we wouldn’t have looked good in a match for quite a while.Jesus Christ. Absolute drama queens, we played a good side in a tough European match, games like this often aren't pretty and often require us to dig in. We looked fantastic against the best team in Europe a couple of days ago yet we have know it alls in here banging on about patterns of play and deteriorating style of play. We had an off night, get over it.
Jesus Christ. Absolute drama queens, we played a good side in a tough European match, games like this often aren't pretty and often require us to dig in. We looked fantastic against the best team in Europe a couple of days ago yet we have know it alls in here banging on about patterns of play and deteriorating style of play. We had an off night, get over it.
Of course, I'd love to play like we did at city more often and not get stuck into these ugly battles as often but we're spread thin in one of the most challenging seasons there has ever been. We're sitting in second in the league, still in the FA cup after 2 tough draws and still in the EL. We need to get over the finish line and I'll take ugly wins and hard fought draws to get there.Do you not think these sorts of performances happen a little too often though? Without that City result we wouldn’t have looked good in a match for quite a while.
I think it's very unfair to say we lack tenacity, we have that in spades. We do lack some leadership I feel definitely and we lack focus at times, the (wrongly) disallowed Kessie goal for example. But we certainly do dig in, it's something we're quite good at, as long as there aren't too many corners.That's the point of beef.
At least my take on him and the team.
We just don't. We don't dig in.
Every game again and again we come out of that tunnel without any grit. We start games without purpose. We lose focus, shit, we don't even have a focus.... it's like they come out and they play some football.
With Fergie, you knew - if we're behind - last 20 mins all hell breaks out, and we get what we need - a goal in the 90', a win in the dying moments... anything. But you knew. The team knew. IT was BRANDED into them.
We lack tenacity. We lack grit. We lack leadership ON and OFF the field.
He makes rookie mistakes with changes.
And god knows we need more leaders ON the field.
But, everything starts with him.
Comfortable? If Maguire wasn't a donkey this would've been an easy 2-0 win.
Jesus Christ. Absolute drama queens, we played a good side in a tough European match, games like this often aren't pretty and often require us to dig in. We looked fantastic against the best team in Europe a couple of days ago yet we have know it alls in here banging on about patterns of play and deteriorating style of play. We had an off night, get over it.
We could've won 3-0 and it still would've been anything but easy. Milan were by far the best team on the pitch tonight.
I did comment on the match thread after we scored that he looked glum in his seat. I have no faith in him at all but lots of people support him. The same as they did for Moyes.