charlenefan
Far less insightful than the other Charley
- Joined
- Aug 17, 2005
- Messages
- 33,052
Jamie redknapp says it smacks of desperation.
Jamie redknapp is a gobshite.
Indeed
Jamie redknapp says it smacks of desperation.
Jamie redknapp is a gobshite.
Oh its gonna be a thing!Please don't start making this a thing....
We replaced Lukaku from within. Its Rashfords injury that we are replacing.Okay, anyone who doesn't think this is an act of desperation isn't living in the real world. It has taken us till deadline day to replace Lukaku who left in the last transfer window. We have had the best part of six months to sort a replacement...and we really should have forward planned before the Belgian actually left in any case. Now we are scrambling around unceremoniously to find anyone to fill that huge hole up front.
We have ended up with a 30-year-old striker whose best season for Watford is well behind him, and who at his best still basically a B-Division Lukaku ( to be painfully honest). It all makes our sidelining of Lukaku in favour of Rashford (who doesn't see himself as a striker anyway) all the more baffling. Because there is no question Lukaku would have stayed had he had the confidence of Ole.
Now Ole has to ask himself if he honestly thinks Ighalo is a better bet than Lukaku.
Now having said all that, I went the guy to tear it up. I will be 100% behind him and hope he shows his best form for us. Nobody really loses. He has six months to impress. For us it is a stop gap till the summer, or I hope it is.
But really how we got to the position where we had to go for Ighalo, shows how poor we are at recruitment planning. It really is all over the place. Even the Bruno signing which we are all excited by, was such a farce before we finally got it over the line, for more than we would have paid if we had gone for it during the summer.
Anyone it is Ighalo a go go and he will get my vote at the least. It will give Martial the kick up the butt that he so rightly needs. It is a plan B.
Because he's a twat.We've got one senior striker and an 18 year old kid in his first season.
We were fecking desperate. That's why we've got him.
Why is Redknapp acting like we think this is some great signing, we all know it's a short term deal to help us out.
Please don't start making this a thing....
Drogba was older and still a decent striker when he returned from China. Spurs offer Ighalo a contract first but rejected them and choose us because he is a fan of this club.Insane. Signing a striker from goddamned Chinese league. That's where players retire. Has anybody ever signed a 30-year-old from China into EPL? We let Lukaku go for THIS? I just can't wrap my head around how crazy this feels. It will take him a whole season to get in form for EPL level, coming from China (that assuming he can still play at this level). What is the fecking point for this loan?
He really doesn't understand football does he?Jamie redknapp says it smacks of desperation.
Jamie redknapp is a gobshite.
Insane. Signing a striker from goddamned Chinese league. That's where players retire. Has anybody ever signed a 30-year-old from China into EPL? We let Lukaku go for THIS? I just can't wrap my head around how crazy this feels. It will take him a whole season to get in form for EPL level, coming from China (that assuming he can still play at this level). What is the fecking point for this loan?
Jamie Redknapp asked Harry Kewell on SSN today if he played with Emre Can at Liverpool. Emre Can was 14 years old when Kewell left the club.Jamie redknapp says it smacks of desperation.
Jamie redknapp is a gobshite.
We replaced Lukaku from within. Its Rashfords injury that we are replacing.
Lukaku is and was a flop. Lukaku is shit and good luck to him in Italy
What an absolutely top post! I am amazed that some fans really are raising their nose against the signing of Ighalo. All the points you mentioned are absolutely spot on, and if we pull off top 4, that would be a phenomenal window. And Matt Law can bugger off with his snide sh**e. For all of Chelsea/Lampard's hoiler than thou attitude, I hope we pip them to that top 4 spot.Wrong.
There are almost no strikers in the world willing to come here for half a season, to sit on on the bench when everyone is fit.
The good ones will never leave mid-season to come to a struggling club in January. The ambitious ones will never accept their lowly place in the squad pecking order. The ones without PL experience will never be able to acclimatise to the league quickly enough to make a difference between now and May. And in the rare cases they would, the clubs wouldn't sell at a low enough price to justify United spending big on stop-gap.
Ighalo is the best option available.
Why am I the only one that feels like I have no idea what he's like?
Maybe, just maybe, we have a target for the summer and need a stop gap. Instead of spending loads on someone we don't want, we've got in a loan to cover rashford and then we'll sign who we want in the summer. I know people love to bash the club but after we rightly fecked off haaland we were never going to be able to bring in a main target. This isn't ideal but its way better than panic signing somwone. Lukaku was toxic, we are better off without him.
Jamie Redknapp asked Harry Kewell on SSN today if he played with Emre Can at Liverpool. Emre Can was 14 years old when Kewell left the club.
What are you on about? What spin? Ive seen it with my own eyes.That is utter bull. You are believing the PR spin. If we thought Rashford was the answer, we would not have been after Mario Mandzukic. And if Rashford was the answer, why is it he wants so badly to play on the right and does not see his best position as a striker. He has said this out of his own mouth. Don't believe the hype.
Says all that needs to be said about the transfer policy of Utd these days. Lukaku out, Ighalo in.
I'm happy with it overall. As the short term fix we could have done worse. My only memories were him scoring game after game last time I watched him. Gives us some cover at least without breaking the bank and can buy us time till the squad gets addressed again in the Summer.Arguably improved since then. Had a great couple of years with Nigeria, which is a better sign than his China form. Was top scorer in AFCON qualifiers and then the main finals. There’s a lot of decent African players who can’t match his goals.
Don’t get me wrong, this is a certainly unfashionable and underwhelming signing, but there’s reasons for some optimism. It’s 90% about attitude; a motivated Ighalo > half-arsed Lukaku.
I’m curious, why?We did what Spurs and Chelsea failed to do this window, and what Barcelona failed to do a year ago.
I have doubts about Ighalo's ability. But this has to be seen as a really good bit of transfer business by the board.
I remember him being good at Watford and surprised they sold him in the end, but I do remember his head had been turned and his final season was poor which is why they sold.Why am I the only one that feels like I have no idea what he's like?
So actually we have no replacement for Lukaku? I see. That move for Mandzukic during the summer was just a mirage? And we are replacing a right sided fast forward with an out-and-out striker who hasn't played at a top level for some time, and is out of match practice? Okay.What are you on about? What spin? Ive seen it with my own eyes.
Lukaku is replaced, we need numbers behind the front 3 and this is the answer.
If rashford wasnt injured we woudnt be in this market hence he is a Rashford replacement and is why he will be gone when Marcus returns.
It could not be any clearer.
We're signing a player who can play in the PL and has done well here before, in a position we're severely lacking bodies in? The whole deal is costing £5m in total for 6 months. Why is this a bad deal? Because he plays in China? Atletico Madrid just loaned Carassco back from China for 6 months too, guess they're also desperate?
Inter and Tottenham wanted him on loan but he chose United, are you aware of that?
How do you think this will impact Greenwood and Martial, now that they know there's a mature pro around the place that's there to lighten their goal burden?
Try not to be outraged about everything, you'll feel a whole lot better.