Neymar joins PSG on a five year deal

Status
Not open for further replies.
Are you a Barca supporter?

I'm guessing so. Fair play then. I can see your concern about finding a replacement, and how much it might cost. I still think the draw of Barcelona will far outweigh the loss though. If any of this bollocks is true.
How? The only player who can change a game on his own in world football now more than Neymar is Messi. He can literally take the ball anywhere in the final third and dance his way past players like they are not there. You can have as many world class midfielders, defenders, goal poachers or whatever and they still wouldn't offer as much impact, potentially of course. It's like saying Barcelona should have sold Messi 10 years ago if they were offered *insert whatever amount*. Neymar is no Messi but the point is he belongs to a very unique category of players.
 
If PSG are really paying this fee and wage, they are stupid beyond belief.

Personally, I don't think Neymar is in the game changing one man maestro that Ronaldo, Messi, fat Ronaldo, Maradonna is and so won't guarantee them CL. He is more like in the Suarez, Bale, Aguero category.

If Barcelona get that kind of money for him and can reinvest most of it back into their team, they will emerge a better side.

He may not be in that category, but he's better than Bale and Aguero quite clearly. And he's better than Suarez too imo.

He's only bettered by Messi in terms of a creative attacking force in world football.
 
they make it a non negotiable as part of the deal.

There are no buyout clauses in France, so that is not an option.


It depends on the club, for PSG he is probably worth the entirety of the 220m because he brings way more than his football skills.

Agreed. He's worth the world to them. 200, 400, doesn't matter. Buying Neymar is basically making a shortcut to everything they're trying to build.
 
of course it can, but when you're more than doubling the world record, equivalent to obe tenth of our clubs entire value, then the risk is far, far greater.

Don't cut half of the post because the first part is important here. And the risk is not far greater, the risk would be greater if doubling the world record had a impact on the injury proneness of the player and remember they don't care about money, it's not as if it was going to prevent them from spending next year, only the wage would be a problem but there are insurances for that.
 
In a world where 85m £ is being paid for Lukaku 222m € for a 25 y/o Neymar seems a good price. Would be great for PSG.
 
If this goes ahead he will forever regret not becoming the hardworking wing-back he could have been under Mourinho. Sad.
 
How? The only player who can change a game on his own in world football now more than Neymar is Messi. He can literally take the ball anywhere in the final third and dance his way past players like they are not there. You can have as many world class midfielders, defenders, goal poachers or whatever and they still wouldn't offer as much impact, potentially of course. It's like saying Barcelona should have sold Messi 10 years ago if they were offered *insert whatever amount*. Neymar is no Messi but the point is he belongs to a very unique category of players.
There's a Messi and Neymar thread floating around I'm sure.
 
If this is actually happening I'm sad for his career and glad it's not us paying this much for him.


I also have a hunch that there's probably more money involved under the table, 220m euros actually seems meh for Neymar in this market
 
If this goes ahead he will forever regret not becoming the hardworking wing-back he could have been under Mourinho. Sad.
Heh.

Doesn't matter anyway. We cooled our interest weeks ago. Just didn't get around to telling anyone.
 
Disagree. If Ronaldo had sustained a serious injury at United before the Madrid move people in here would still be going on about it.

If PSG are going to absolutely shatter any semblance of sanity for half a billion on one player, that's a story. Everything has fundamentally changed, in my small opinion.

That part is crucial people in here think about football, PSG's owners think about geopolitics. If Neymar fails it will be someone else, their goals aren't football related. They are not United, Barcelona, they are not a sugar daddy club either, El Khelaifi is a publicist for Qatar and Neymar is their current potential Hollywood sign.
 
I fear we're approaching some kind of bust situation. It can't be good when cannon fodder will end up costing £60 million.
I hope we don't attempt to sign him (unlikely anyway) because I would prefer it wasn't us to be the ones who 'destroyed the market'.
Imagine the abuse PSG are going to get from all other fans :nervous:
 
I hope we don't attempt to sign him (unlikely anyway) because I would prefer it wasn't us to be the ones who 'destroyed the market'.
Imagine the abuse PSG are going to get from all other fans :nervous:

We'll probably be blamed in any case.
 
If this is actually happening I'm sad for his career and glad it's not us paying this much for him.


I also have a hunch that there's probably more money involved under the table, 220m euros actually seems meh for Neymar in this market

It's because that's his buy out clause. Had it been a higher clause like €500m I doubt Barca would have even considered €220m. Barca can't do anything but offer a new contract to Neymar to counter it. If PSG actually have met the buy out clause it's up to Neymar to make the decision
 
I hope we don't attempt to sign him (unlikely anyway) because I would prefer it wasn't us to be the ones who 'destroyed the market'.
Imagine the abuse PSG are going to get from all other fans :nervous:

We'll get abuse regardless. Might as well get them with Neymar on board :drool::nervous: . Seriously though, don't think it's viable at all for any club who isn't funded by a private oligarch and plus I doubt Neymar is interested in coming here.
 
That part is crucial people in here think about football, PSG's owners think about geopolitics. If Neymar fails it will be someone else, their goals aren't football related. They are not United, Barcelona, they are not a sugar daddy club either, El Khelaifi is a publicist for Qatar and Neymar is their current potential Hollywood sign.
Geopolitical signings? Christ Rouve, it's all gone mad.
 
Neymar is easily worth €200m, he's top quality, young and marketable.

The main risk if he signs for PSG is that he loses himself in the Parisian nights like Ronaldinho.
 
Does no one else think this is just a revenge shot from the PSG owner for Barca's public courtship of morata?

IIRC he threatened to do this with Messi a few years back when Barca tried to turn Thiago Silvas head.

Like a big "We warned you not to feck with us, no suffer the consequences"

Think if this does happening will break the market, Fifa and IMF will want more control over football finance.
 
Geopolitical signings? Christ Rouve, it's all gone mad.

Well, that's why they bought PSG to promote Qatar. I remember that people couldn't make the difference between Qatar and the United Arab Emirates, now they know that it's not the same.
 
We'll get abuse regardless. Might as well get them with Neymar on board :drool::nervous: . Seriously though, don't think it's viable at all for any club who isn't funded by a private oligarch and plus I doubt Neymar is interested in coming here.
Our £100m Greizmann will look like pennies when we sign him :D:wenger:
 
Theres not a chance in hell that neymar would leave playing at barca with messi to go to psg. Psg can offer whatever they want, dont see why he would leave.
 
I highly doubt that when the fee is 220m.
If Neymar is actually available I think at least three clubs (including us) would readily pay the fee.
Would be horrible if this happened anywhere near the release clause. It'd be like old times where the world record went to a level so far beyond what'd been paid before it seemed incredible.

You wonder what level of price it'll all peak at before every profit stream is maximised and it all starts falling apart.
I suppose the one last untapped one in English football is clubs individually selling their tv rights. But for a lot, they'd surely get less than the collective tv deal, and only the top 6 would cream in way more
It's not every summer a player of Neymar's caliber goes anywhere. I don't get what's so incredulous about this; the market is a shambles and this as a top-end makes more sense than what's going on to drive bottom levels up.
I want it to happen, solely because of the reason that this transfer will throw all, each, every, uno, dos, tres, cuatro, ek, do, teen, transfer and budget speculations and how much United overpay for players outta the window!
No it wouldn't - £75m-£90m for Lukaku looks more absurd than double that plus a bit for Neymar.
Wow:eek: PSG just destroyed the transfer market for the rest of us.
No they haven't (presuming this actually happened). There's only 1 Neymar, and there won't be a player anywhere near his level sold this window. The price for Neymar wouldn't be a barometer for anything else, unless you were going in for an equivalent level player. Players like Lukaku and Walker going for what they did is far more damaging to the market as a whole than this.
 
That part is crucial people in here think about football, PSG's owners think about geopolitics. If Neymar fails it will be someone else, their goals aren't football related. They are not United, Barcelona, they are not a sugar daddy club either, El Khelaifi is a publicist for Qatar and Neymar is their current potential Hollywood sign.
Next thing you know WWIII breaks out because of a football transfer.
 
Is this on then? I assumed it was just PSG trying to stir shit up after Barca went for Verratti, a bit like the whole Thiago Silva/Messi thing a few years back, but it hasn't dropped off the homepage all day.
 
This is about who's got the biggest private parts by the Qataris.
 
Actually, i've read their revenue for 2016/17 was €708M, with a profit of €18M before taxes

I reeeeally would like to see whether they can afford to give neymar such a contract
Their income for 2016 is $750 or €679 or £575. I know you are saying 16/17 .

https://www.forbes.com/sites/kurtba...s-record-revenue-of-750-million/#706ef3f35b1e

For 2017 its reported as $770 or €708 or £590

https://www.forbes.com/sites/kurtba...istory-of-sports-at-770-million/#56ca30ac7e82

Not sure what these numbers mean, in what they can or cant afford but its a lot of money upfront before tax and overheads.
 
How was he wrong about Morata when Mourinho himself confirmed we bid for him?

Could be wrong, but didn't he claim it was done several times? It was obviously a lot further off than he thought it was.

On Neymar, if he really is interested in moving, we should try to get him. Guy is a genuine superstar and would take us up a few levels by himself alone. Not to add his commercial potential.
 
SO does this mean PSG are about to spend 300M on 2 players 222M on Neymar and 70-80M on Sanchez?
 
I guess this decision is irreversible? Anyway, it's all nonsense and I don't see him leaving at all. He'll replace Messi soon enough and he's way too good to be at PSG. We should be in for him even at the 200m price if he were genuinely interested in a move.
 
I guess this decision is irreversible? Anyway, it's all nonsense and I don't see him leaving at all. He'll replace Messi soon enough and he's way too good to be at PSG. We should be in for him even at the 200m price if he were genuinely interested in a move.

Maybe we can't afford it?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.