Morgan Schneiderlin image 28

Morgan Schneiderlin France flag

2015-16 Performances

View full 2015-16 profile

5.7 Season Average Rating
Appearances
38
Goals
1
Assists
1
Yellow cards
5
Status
Not open for further replies.
RedPed said:
You're having a laugh! The player's shite! Not worth £25m and not good enough for United. Just a mid-table squaddie. Should have stayed at Southampton. That's his level.
Click to expand...
You forget we are at the same level! Hasn't really turned up for us this season, lacks a bit of aggression so far that he showed at Southampton.
 
I thought he was good. And he is most certainly good enough for a top team. Some Ihni binni dimi diniwiny anitaime in here tbh.
 
RedPed said:
You're having a laugh! The player's shite! Not worth £25m and not good enough for United. Just a mid-table squaddie. Should have stayed at Southampton. That's his level.
Click to expand...

He'll get lambasted for this performance as his mistakes were high profile. He was marking the man for their first goal and made an awful pass out of defence for their second. But he also anchored well which aided Herrera in putting in a fantastic performance. Other than that pass, he had a very good second half. intercepted and read so many balls into midfield from Arsenal.
 
He was better in the second half. Shocking marking for the first goal though and a poor pass leading to the second. Those are the facts and anything else he did was nowhere near good enough to make up for that.
 
Despite being (at least partly) at fault for both goals, I think he was great at times. Really broke up play well and got stuck in.
 
I think he did really well overall. I know he made mistakes but that didn't drop his performance either, and he protected the back 4 well imo.

One of his best performances, if not the best, performances for us. Carrick and Blind were hardly bothered by passes down the middle, he did his job very well considering how much Herrera was pushing up
 
Thought he improved in the second half. Horrible defending for Arsenal's goals though, expected better from him.
 
He was absolutely awful.

All the nonsense about how LVG fecked up by not playing him at the Emirates. We might have lost by more had he played.
 
Not great in the first half but really good in the second, the amount of times he gets his foot in and wins the ball to start an attack is great. Not having people criticise him for that performance - was big for us in the second half.
 
Multiple interceptions further up the pitch in the second half. Glad his performance came better
 
Akash said:
He was absolutely awful.

All the nonsense about how LVG fecked up by not playing him at the Emirates. We might have lost by more had he played.
Click to expand...

Yeah, I'm struggling to agree with a lot of the positive comments. Didn't offer anywhere near enough for someone involved in both games we conceded.
 
I thought he did well for the most part, can't be easy for him being expected to do most of the defending in he middle with two center mids behind him playing center back.
 
He was easily our worst player today. He gave the ball away for the second goal too if I'm not mistaken? But feck it we got the win and I couldn't be happier. He really needs to improve though if he wants to cut it here.
 
Don't think he's as bad as some saying in here, but he hasn't been playing well either. I stick to my opinion that he'll improve.
 
He was very good today imo. Got in interceptions. Had a couple of fouls. And pressed well. He forced them back to their half countless times.
 
5 tackles, 3 interceptions, 4 clearances and 84% pass accuracy.. Good performance overall
 
bucky said:
Don't think he's as bad as some saying in here, but he hasn't been playing well either. I stick to my opinion that he'll improve.
Click to expand...
amazing what the pressure of signing for United does to some players. i've been saying this (underlined) all season and reckon next season we'll see what we were wanting to see this season from him.
 
LuisNaniencia said:
This. We would not have won this game without him despite his mistakes. The problem with him is what he does so well, he does very quietly. Tackling and intercepting just isn't sexy.
Click to expand...

Yup, no doubt he can improve but without him today we would absolutely have been overrun. Herrera was absolutely shattered running up and down the pitch and as great as Mata was scurrying everywhere too, he wouldn't have helped Morgan defensively down the middle.

He deserves criticism but you can't expect him to be dictating play from his position or be ultra composed in a very unbalanced team.
 
Sid234 said:
I think he did really well overall. I know he made mistakes but that didn't drop his performance either, and he protected the back 4 well imo.

One of his best performances, if not the best, performances for us. Carrick and Blind were hardly bothered by passes down the middle, he did his job very well considering how much Herrera was pushing up
Click to expand...

I thought that to, shocked at the reaction on here.
 
Sid234 said:
I think he did really well overall. I know he made mistakes but that didn't drop his performance either, and he protected the back 4 well imo.

One of his best performances, if not the best, performances for us. Carrick and Blind were hardly bothered by passes down the middle, he did his job very well considering how much Herrera was pushing up
Click to expand...
this.

Some really stupid overreactions in this thread, ppl just remember only mistakes it seems, he's made a scapegoat here and for that reason there is nothing between excellent or poor, we didnt get thrashed like last time we played Carrick there on double pivot with Sweinsteigger. Morgan played there alone the whole game today, it was far from ideal but he made the job
 
He did a really good job overall tactically, but made two individual errors that led to goals.
 
I thought he done well.

Messed up on Welbecks goal but was good other then that.
 
Don't know what half the people see. Just because he isn't getting in the box and having shots doesn't mean he isn't having a good game.

He does the dirty work for us and I lost count the amount of times he made vital interceptions. He and Herrera played well together.
 
Adam-Utd said:
Don't know what half the people see. Just because he isn't getting in the box and having shots doesn't mean he isn't having a good game.

He does the dirty work for us and I lost count the amount of times he made vital interceptions. He and Herrera played well together.
Click to expand...
Agree. The second half especially. They were immense. Lost count the number of times, the two of them stopped a surging Arsenal player.
 
Yeah, I'm one of his biggest critics... and even I thought he had a good, especially in the second half... was getting around the pitch, breaking up play and really high energy. The only issue with him I had was tactical, in that sometimes he'd continue the press up the field and be way out of his DM position when Arsenal were coming forward... (there was one point in the first half where him and Herrera were are two furtherst men forward and Juan Mata was holding!) - but I think that was a direction from LVG, so I won't blame him too much for that...

His decision making does let him down at times - but yeah, more games like the second half will definitely be a step in the right direction
 
Status
Not open for further replies.