Yes but nowhere close to candidate for a job like united. We shall see how he does, good luck to him.He's clearly showing he knows football, certainly better than Rooney, Lampard, and Gerrard. Plus he did well in his short term as manager here, he's talented.
Hardly a high bar, is it? Nobody is arguing that he's got talent.He's clearly showing he knows football, certainly better than Rooney, Lampard, and Gerrard. Plus he did well in his short term as manager here, he's talented.
Harsh on Gerrard he's won shit in a decent enough league.He's clearly showing he knows football, certainly better than Rooney, Lampard, and Gerrard. Plus he did well in his short term as manager here, he's talented.
It's a really low bar tbh.Hardly a high bar, is it? Nobody is arguing that he's got talent.
Oh not now, not good for us or him. In the future he might be good enough. I think if he continues at Middlesbrough he should get a PL chance with someone.Yes but nowhere close to candidate for a job like united. We shall see how he does, good luck to him.
He's clearly showing he knows football, certainly better than Rooney, Lampard, and Gerrard. Plus he did well in his short term as manager here, he's talented.
Over what period though?
Gerrard has an SPL title to his name albeit before he proved to be useless elsewhere, Carrick has barely two seasons experience at Middlesbrough to his name.
Apart from Guardiola other 3 have achieved nothing yet and could easily fade into relative obscurity in not so distant future in terms of managerial prominence.Carrick, Alonso, Arteta, Guardiola - do DLPs simply make the best managers?
Apart from Guardiola other 3 have achieved nothing yet and could easily fade into relative obscurity in not so distant future in terms of managerial prominence.
So honestly I really don't know whether there is any correlation here .
Historically central midfielders and centre backs? Yes.They're all young and well on course. It's a semi jokey question, but I genuinely think players who are conductors on the pitch are more likely to be better tacticians. Especially those who were playing that role in the last 10-15 years in which tactics shifted towards possession, playing out from the back etc. Could also add Xavi to the list. They're all early 40s, and I don't see many other early 40s managers doing as well as those DLPs.
Gerard had the favourite in a two horse race and the other horse went lame.
Carrick took a bottom of the league side to the brink of promotion, lost 60+ G&A this season and after a rough start has them around the playoffs while nursing an injury crisis worse than ours. I heard the commentators say that after the 2 injuries tonight they have 14 players out, most of them first teamers.
He’s got them scoring goals too, which is practically unheard of for a Middlesbrough side barring the periods they had the likes of Ravanelli, Viduka and Hasselbaink.
His record as manger, excluded trophies, is far more accomplished than Gerard I’d say.
I'm pretty sure some of us said the same about ETH.Carrick will be a good manager you can just see it. He knows what he is doing.
He's only 42 mateGlad to see Carrick doing well.
Before he steps into Carrington and gets fascinated by McTominay.Carrick will be a good manager you can just see it. He knows what he is doing.
Let’s not get carried away. A lot different managing Middlesbrough to United. Let’s wait to see if he ever gets promoted with Middlesbrough and has a decent season in the prem first.Next united manager
Does this statement even hold under scrutiny .Would be good if he can put together a good end to this year and challenge for promotion next season. A few years of experience in the Championship and then a move up to a mid-table premier league club could be great for him. Managers need to evolve before they make the step up to the elite clubs.
McKenna looks slightly ahead in terms of career progression, but he has experience working his way up coaching in the youth levels and was seen as a very talented manager back then too.
Will definitely be interesting to see these two progress over the next few years.
Harsh on Gerrard he's won shit in a decent enough league.
The guy needs to do better than McKenna for that.Next united manager
After a barren run and proceeded to go unbeaten.
I dislike Gerrard as much as the rest but he’s achieved something at least in management.
Defenders seem to make better pundits as they have to read a game constantly.Carrick, Alonso, Arteta, Guardiola - do DLPs simply make the best managers?
I am aware that most people dont follow the Championship, but to praise him moving them from near the relegation places to top half is ridiculous, as the job became vacant in the first place due to them severely underperforming.
He is now in his first full season and has them sitting in 12th - truly remarkable, dont know how he has done it.
I forgot about the league cup and, when I saw this thread bumped, thought he has been sacked. He couldnt complain even if he was.
He has them well drilled yes but far too inconsistent, so not sure where all of this optimism is coming from. Bottom line, the results have not been good enough
Not really, it does work, but not for everyone and it's definitely not the only way. Someone like Klopp worked his way up as suggested, while Pep or Zidane where just thrown into it after only managing the reserves - but they were familiar with their club, so they only needed to adapt to the team, not the structure around it.Does this statement even hold under scrutiny .
I would think McKenna is ahead of him at the moment. Obviously he doesn't have the playing history with us that Carrick does, but he's done even better with Ipswich than Carrick has done with Boro.Really do think he will be end up here eventually. He’s showing himself to be a really good manager dealing with difficult circumstances at Middlesbrough and imposing a good style of play. Feels like exactly the sort of manager Ratcliffe would eventually love to have in charge of us.
Alonso hasn't won anything yet but to say he hasn't achieved anything yet is completely unfair. Leverkusen are quite literally performing as one of the best teams in the world, and have been doing so for 4-5 months now. Whether this will continue is obviously yet to be seen but that doesn't happen by accident.Apart from Guardiola other 3 have achieved nothing yet and could easily fade into relative obscurity in not so distant future in terms of managerial prominence.
So honestly I really don't know whether there is any correlation here .
Gerrard started his management career quite well before it all fell apart on him once he moved to the PL, so that's a cautionary tale of getting too ahead of ourselves. Hell even Rooney and Lampard did a decent job at Derby based on the circumstances at the club at their respective times.He's clearly showing he knows football, certainly better than Rooney, Lampard, and Gerrard. Plus he did well in his short term as manager here, he's talented.
That wasn't slight against any of the names mentioned it was just an observation that Apart from Guardiola none of them have proven to be great managers yet to make an assertion that DLP's make the best managers .Alonso hasn't won anything yet but to say he hasn't achieved anything yet is completely unfair. Leverkusen are quite literally performing as one of the best teams in the world, and have been doing so for 4-5 months now. Whether this will continue is obviously yet to be seen but that doesn't happen by accident.
That's my thinking as well that there is no pattern to what may or may not work at So called bigger clubs when appointing managers infact it kind of hold true for most Clubs .Not really, it does work, but not for everyone and it's definitely not the only way. Someone like Klopp worked his way up as suggested, while Pep or Zidane where just thrown into it after only managing the reserves - but they were familiar with their club, so they only needed to adapt to the team, not the structure around it.
And considering that there are lots of managers who work their way up and just seem to hit a ceiling at some point (like Moyes) show that not everyone has the necessary skills despite getting the chance to evolve.
While that's obviously very good and nice to see, he has to make it count. Otherwise it will be dismissed as a purple patch and forgotten.Alonso hasn't won anything yet but to say he hasn't achieved anything yet is completely unfair. Leverkusen are quite literally performing as one of the best teams in the world, and have been doing so for 4-5 months now. Whether this will continue is obviously yet to be seen but that doesn't happen by accident.
Yes, I agree.While that's obviously very good and nice to see, he has to make it count. Otherwise it will be dismissed as a purple patch and forgotten.
They are favourites to win the cup and have decent shots at the EL and the league, they should get at least one this season.
All those ex-players from the same generation as Carrick should have stayed in the lower divisions.
Best place to learn.
