Devil may care
New Member
- Joined
- Jan 7, 2010
- Messages
- 35,976
No doubt Memphis isn't quite Hazard or Isco class. They had like you said, some magical stuff in their locker which made them future Ballon D'Or candidates. What I'm arguing however is that while Memphis isn't exactly in their vicinity from an individual skillset standpoint, he's no agricultural grafter by any means either, the type of tangible output and the ability to play within the constraints of a structure defined by the manager that he exhibits is an oftentimes overlooked factor while evaluating players and their long term development.
Van Gaal always judges his players by their footballing intelligence, determination, attention to detail, ability to work hard for the team-mates around him and effectiveness in his overall philosophy so to speak. He doesn't care if a player can beat 5 defenders, or pull an impromptu rabona, or nutmeg a player of the edge of the box or execute other superficially brilliant things of that nature. Because those things don't add anything tangible to the overall result, and the ball always travels better in space, than by a player running with it.
Jari Litmanen wasn't the most skilled player in the world, he certainly was no Gheorghe Hagi or Jean-Pierre Papin. But he was arguably the biggest offensive difference maker in Van Gaal's Ajax team that dominated Europe for a period of 3 seasons. No one will mistake Thomas Muller for Rui Costa, but he's superbly efficient in what he does and arguably the better player despite his individual shortcoming.
Memphis has enough individual talent to one day day be a Top 15 or even 10 caliber player, I truly believe that. He might never be an Isco or Hazard or even Sterling who are more naturally gifted, and if they develop properly, seem destined for greater individual accomplishments.
But if can come in, show good defensive workrate (like he did vs Spain for example), produce interspersed moments of magic, be productive, score in the neighbor-hood of 15 or 20 goals per season, and help further Van Gaal's philosophy, then he'll be an excellent addition considering the price tag. You don't always need multiple superstars to win or play attractive football. Teamwork, tactical intelligence, execution of the game-plan and productivity is paramount.
I guess part of this is what concerns me, it's like we are systematically removing instinct and individuality out of the team. I can see structure as vital defensively and even with midfield, but structural wingers seems to be a strange way to approach things. Maybe I'm just too much of a romanticist but I miss a bit of genuine flair out wide for us.
You clearly see his ceiling a lot higher than I do and in fairness the interest in him from so many top teams supports you over me. I just wonder if he can come straight in and play in that front 3, if not it means more Young and us treading water in regards to the forward line.