I have been following this thread from the beginning, and, in my opinion, this one thread is the best way to have any and all discussions about Greenwood.
You can't have a discussion about his performances at Getafe without discussing why he is in Getafe in the first place and what United will do after his loan to Getafe has finished. If anything, it's the more nuanced and intelligent way of discussing his worth to United.
What I have seen in this thread a lot, is a pattern of new posters entering this thread, usually giddy over some highlight or stat, and not fully appreciating the context of his performances, followed by long term posters in this thread, with well practiced replies, reminding these new posters of the context of why he's in Getafe and why, in their opinion, he shouldn't come back.
What does happen, however, is the new posters are unaware of how much practice the long term posters have, so they proceed to perceive that they are getting piled in on, because they are thinking of debating points on the fly, whereas the long term posters have been resusing their debate points for months.
Unfortunately, this leads to emotional responses, like "I hope said poster never gets pushed too far by a woman", which then leads to bannings.
Personally, from the only evidence I have been privvy to, I think Greenwood is a cnut and I never want him to be associated with my club ever again. But I'm a CA and CSA survivor, so my view will always be through that lense, and I appreciate that others' won't.
However, I do want my club to profit from the little shit, and his performances for Getafe are directly relevant to that. At the same time, I do want those posters who are unaware or ill informed about the subject of DV, the accusations and the evidence that's out in the public sphere, to be informed of the severity of the situation and why a few decent performances don't tip the balance of whether he should come back.
You can't have no thread, because he's still a contracted United player, and you can't have two because that was brutal, so this one thread is the best way to discuss him.