TsuWave
Full Member
- Joined
- Oct 12, 2013
- Messages
- 15,766
Still would have bagged had Rashford not been offside
I do think him learning how to play on the wing and improving his defensive qualities will benefit him in the long term. I'd just rather he didn't play every game there.we are trying to turn our potential best stiker into an RW and then worrying about his "defensive qualities". I think Brighton showed how we need to fix the defence, but trying to turn greenwood into a winger is criminal.
I do think him learning how to play on the wing and improving his defensive qualities will benefit him in the long term. I'd just rather he didn't play every game there.
He'd get man handled by pretty much every premier league CB at the moment. He would be utterly invisible. I'm all for playing him as a striker in cup games against smaller teams but he should definitely stay out on the right in league matches for now.we are trying to turn our potential best striker into an RW and then worrying about his "defensive qualities". I think Brighton showed how we need to fix the defence, but trying to turn greenwood into a winger is criminal.
It's not. He is not a midfielder or someone you want to do heavy duty work, he is a finisher and strategic attacker. You don't play him on the right if he is supposed to track back and be involved in covering in a low block. You want players like him further forward, so that when we do win the ball we can counter attack. It's like being worried that Haaland wont achieve his potential because currently he is not helping Dortmund out defensively, too busy scoring goals.He was easily our best player on the ball today. Really tried to run at players and cause some damage, especially when we went down to 10 men.
But, and this is becoming a bit worrying, he's really not helping out enough defensively.
He was easily our best player on the ball today. Really tried to run at players and cause some damage, especially when we went down to 10 men.
But, and this is becoming a bit worrying, he's really not helping out enough defensively.
He was easily our best player on the ball today. Really tried to run at players and cause some damage, especially when we went down to 10 men.
But, and this is becoming a bit worrying, he's really not helping out enough defensively.
I touched on that in Shaw's thread, but I'll do a quick recap here. At first I was blaming him as well but I just re-watched the entire play and it was actually Maguire who had pushed up out of position and Shaw had no choice but to come in to cover that space. Then there was never a chance for them to swap back.The wide open spaces down our left flank were horrific. I’m not sure that’s all Mason’s fault though. Have a look at where Shaw’s starting position in the move leading up to Son’s goal. It’s unbelievable. Plus we’re playing with three central midfielders. They have to react to those situations and fill those gaps.
I touched on that in Shaw's thread, but I'll do a quick recap here. At first I was blaming him as well but I just re-watched the entire play and it was actually Maguire who had pushed up out of position and Shaw had no choice but to come in to cover that space. Then there was never a chance for them to swap back.
This is why maybe we need to support AwB/Shaw better .. If him and Rashford are not helping the defense and you have Matic Pogba supporting .. then there is not much the defense can do ..He’s always been clumsy defending, you can tell he’s a striker playing on the right. He does seem to be learning that position better from an attacking point of view though. Last season he was scoring great goals, then you wouldn’t notice him for another 70 minutes. He’s much more involved in the build up now, could just be a confidence thing.
The problem is if we have Martial, Rashford and Greenwood all doing that, we're suddenly down quite a few bodies.It's not. He is not a midfielder or someone you want to do heavy duty work, he is a finisher and strategic attacker. You don't play him on the right if he is supposed to track back and be involved in covering in a low block. You want players like him further forward, so that when we do win the ball we can counter attack. It's like being worried that Haaland wont achieve his potential because currently he is not helping Dortmund out defensively, too busy scoring goals.
He didn't follow him to the other side of the field. He followed him into the centre, exactly where Maguire would normally have been. If at any stage Shaw left Lamela to go back out wide it would literally have left Lamela 1 on 1 with the goalkeeper with no other defender remotely close enough to stop him. Anyway, if you want to discuss this further you should do it to my post in the Shaw thread so we don't take this one off topic.There’s no way Shaw should have followed Lamela that far. Wingers swap flanks all the time. Our wide attackers constantly did it under Fergie. Takes a special breed of idiot fullback to trot alongside them all the way from one side of the pitch to the other.
True that. I don't personally think Greenwood should be used that way, but I see your point. I keep thinking about Rashford being tired of working defensively under Mourinho as a winger, and he has struggled out wide for a while now since his injury, maybe he is just a bit sick of it right now. In regards to Greenwood I don't even see any of it in his game defensively.The problem is if we have Martial, Rashford and Greenwood all doing that, we're suddenly down quite a few bodies.
Most top teams these days, or teams in general, can maybe have one player not helping much defensively. Everyone else is normally working quite hard winning the ball back and pressing.
Just had this thought myself actually - the fact we've brought in two players junior to Greenwood means that that he remains our first choice RW option. The start to the season has been rocky for the whole team, but I suspect once we settle down he'll find himself in great goalscoring form. Definitely most excited to watch his progress this season.With no senior RW coming in, this will be another big season for Mason. I exited tbh.
He played about 2600 minutes last season. Saying 40 games is a bit disingenuous, he was a substitute in 9 of them and was taken off in nearly every game he started.Not getting Sacho I think is a negative for greenwood. The kid played 40 professional games last season and had no rest coming into this season the burn out is inevitable
Did we ruined Rashford?we are trying to turn our potential best striker into an RW and then worrying about his "defensive qualities". I think Brighton showed how we need to fix the defence, but trying to turn greenwood into a winger is criminal.
Rashford played most of his underage football on the wing.Did we ruined Rashford?
Same thing is said about him when we play Rash at LW, with Zlatan then Lukaku hogging the solo CF role. Once Lukaku is out, and we tried Rashford at CF, turns out it's not his best position after all... he can definitely do it in big games at CF when the likes of City, Pool etc (bar Mourinho-ish teams) are giving him plenty of spaces to exploit, but usually rubbish vs weak teams parking the bus.