Marcelo

Last year he was an unrelenting monster... this year he's dropped a bit, but he's still top class.

I love him.
 
Eire Red United said:
Young who kept Salah in his pocket, lets see can Marcelo do the same.
Click to expand...
They're unlikely to setup like we did vs Pool and neither will marcelo be asked to do what young did. His contributions going forward are way too imp.
 
Vato said:
I'd have Marcelo over any LB that ever played. Obviously I'm a little biased but still, he's an absolute legend for us.
Click to expand...
It's not just the goals he brings, it's the importance of the goals. He is always ready to step up in big moments when his team badly need a moment of individual brilliance. He's such a good player. One of my favourites over the past decade. Love his passion and his hair.
 
#07 said:
Marcelo made 50 appearances in 2010-11 and 44 in 2011-12. In 2012-13 he was injured a lot, which gave Coentrao more chances. Coentrao almost ended up joining us because of his lack of game time though.

Marcelo was Mourinho's first choice left back.
Click to expand...

He didn't seem to trust him in a lot of big away games though. He left him out against Bayern in the CL semi's, against Atletico in the league and against Barca in the league, cup and supercup.
 
kouroux said:
I think it's intended for him to be so high like that, it's a risky tactic but what he brings far outweighs what he can cost his team in terms of goals leaked. Otherwise Marcelo wouldn't be a starter for them for years. They've accepted that it's part of their game so not sure how much it can be truly of his fault
Click to expand...
Yeah I'm not questioning his use high up the park or his contribution, but purely his decisions between the ball going out of play and it ending up in the net at the other end.
 
Gio said:
Yeah I'm not questioning his use high up the park or his contribution, but purely his decisions between the ball going out of play and it ending up in the net at the other end.
Click to expand...
I suppose sprinting would have made for better viewing but not sure it would have helped judging where he was at the time
 
unitedbhoy said:
It's not just the goals he brings, it's the importance of the goals. He is always ready to step up in big moments when his team badly need a moment of individual brilliance. He's such a good player. One of my favourites over the past decade. Love his passion and his hair.
Click to expand...
:lol: Oh man, what I'd give for such a head of glorious hair.
 
kouroux said:
I suppose sprinting would have made for better viewing but not sure it would have helped judging where he was at the time
Click to expand...
True. It was more the faffing around getting the ball that had already gone out of play - bit naive really.
 
Gio said:
Yeah I'm not questioning his use high up the park or his contribution, but purely his decisions between the ball going out of play and it ending up in the net at the other end.
Click to expand...
Defending is for the weak, Gio:lol:Also, with Marcelo doing crazy things at least we know Madrid will suffer some goals and the games will be more interesting for us neutrals:D
 
unitedbhoy said:
It's not just the goals he brings, it's the importance of the goals. He is always ready to step up in big moments when his team badly need a moment of individual brilliance. He's such a good player. One of my favourites over the past decade. Love his passion and his hair.
Click to expand...

:lol:
 
How i wish we have him. He and Sanchez would be absolute mint on the left together

If i remember correctly, he started not so well at Madrid coming from Brazil. Then he truly started to show his worth and genuine quality. Brazil are blessed with great full backs
 
unitedbhoy said:
It's not just the goals he brings, it's the importance of the goals. He is always ready to step up in big moments when his team badly need a moment of individual brilliance. He's such a good player. One of my favourites over the past decade. Love his passion and his hair.
Click to expand...

Yeah he, Ramos and Ronaldo are the real big characters in the Madrid team
 
Charles Miller said:
Alex Sandro is more physical but Marcelo is far superior in terms of Skills.

Sandro is good in defense in 1x1 situations but his positioning is not top level imo. He is having a very average season after be linked with Chelsea last window. Apparently Juventus fans lost their patience with him.

Last season i would say he was the second best LB, but right now i would pick Alaba and Jordi Alba over him. Hes probably just looking for a move and can back to his normal form, but his attitude this season is really worrying.
Click to expand...
Thanks mate, very insightful :)
 
bebeanderson said:
Maldini doesn't work as a LB in today's game.
Click to expand...
Are you drunk

He was a better two way player than Alex Sandro or Jordi Alba who are two of the best around right now. If he were born 20 years later he'd have been a better version of Lahm/Alaba

As for Marcelo, he is a winger/midfielder. Simple as that. The last in the line of great brazilian FBs who actually only played there because they could. Nilton Santos, Leo Junior, Branco, and now Marcelo.

Could just as easily play as an attacking winger or CM. Amazing player

Yes he's one of the vice-captains. The second in fact, when Ramos doesn't play he's the captain
 
Gio said:
Mistake 1 - Sauntering around getting the ball back that had gone out of play like he’s playing 5s down the park with his mates. Mistake 2 - Jogging back into position as Bayern countered (Real should have covered him better of course but he doesn’t help himself).
Click to expand...
I wouldn't have mattered how fast he would have ran back. Every player was in position behind him, only one needed to see Kimmich's run but they just stood around like cones and let him get through via two simple passes. Also Navas should have saved the shot. The angle was tight and it was straight at him.
 
Mr.Ridiculous__ said:
Quick question.
Which left back would you rather have in your team, Maldini or Marcelo? I am absolutely serious (incase someone thinks otherwise).
Click to expand...
If I wanted to win the league, Maldini

If I had to win a one-off game, Marcelo.
 
giorno said:
Are you drunk

He was a better two way player than Alex Sandro or Jordi Alba who are two of the best around right now. If he were born 20 years later he'd have been a better version of Lahm/Alaba

As for Marcelo, he is a winger/midfielder. Simple as that. The last in the line of great brazilian FBs who actually only played there because they could. Nilton Santos, Leo Junior, Branco, and now Marcelo.

Could just as easily play as an attacking winger or CM. Amazing player

Yes he's one of the vice-captains. The second in fact, when Ramos doesn't play he's the captain
Click to expand...

Give him to Pep and he will reinvent him into a winger/CM inverted FB :drool:
 
Whenever Madrid plays big teams, I feel like Marcelo's defensive frailities/positioning issues will be exposed. And then in real game, it actually turns out to be opposite with Marcelo producing some key attacking contribution.
 
Amazing offensively, inept defensively. Salah is going to have a field day that side and no way Zidane tells Marcelo not to attack.
 
One of my favorite players ever. Amazing footballer and a likeable guy too.
 
Thought he was awful defensively today but great going forward. His attempt to block KDB's shot as well was incredibly poor. Seems to get a free ride whenever he is bad defensively because he's great on the ball.
 
Benched for the CL knockouts after having an incredible CL campaign last year.

So, how will he be remembered? On the same level as Roberto Carlos or on the same level as someone like Jordi Alba?

Up until 5 years ago he was getting benched by Coentrão and now he’s getting benched by Reguilon... he hasn’t been great internationally but had a fantastic peak and plenty of remarkable CL performances.
 
As one of the best playmaking full backs in the history of the game. Both building up the play from the back and being able to create something from nothing in the last third.
 
Peyroteo said:
Benched for the CL knockouts after having an incredible CL campaign last year.

So, how will he be remembered? On the same level as Roberto Carlos or on the same level as someone like Jordi Alba?

Up until 5 years ago he was getting benched by Coentrão and now he’s getting benched by Reguilon... he hasn’t been great internationally but had a fantastic peak and plenty of remarkable CL performances.
Click to expand...
He looks fat to me. I bet if Juventus really sign him he will suddenly recover form and play well two years more.

He is not on same level as Roberto Carlos imo. As for Jordi Alba its a matter of football taste. I would pick Marcelo but i understand the arguments of people who would prefer Alba.
 
Peyroteo said:
Benched for the CL knockouts after having an incredible CL campaign last year.

So, how will he be remembered? On the same level as Roberto Carlos or on the same level as someone like Jordi Alba?

Up until 5 years ago he was getting benched by Coentrão and now he’s getting benched by Reguilon... he hasn’t been great internationally but had a fantastic peak and plenty of remarkable CL performances.
Click to expand...
He is way superior to Jordi Alba. I also think Real just want to phase him out. Im not really convinced Reguillion is genuinely benching him.
 
Alba was never nowhere near as good as him. During his peak(and that was for good few years) he was miles better than any other LB in the world, no matter how shit defensively he was.
 
First time seeing him play in a few weeks. What a stinker he's having.
 


With Marcelo on the pitch Madrid concede once every 52 minutes. With Reguilon on the pitch they concede once every 135 minutes
 
Sean_RedDevil said:
Sometimes you need a new challenge....i think that is the case with Marcelo.
Click to expand...

I’m not sure it’s just that, physically he looks a shadow of his former self.

Not sure if he needs a new challenge or he’s actually finished but it’s been painful to watch him this season.
 
Amar__ said:
Alba was never nowhere near as good as him. During his peak(and that was for good few years) he was miles better than any other LB in the world, no matter how shit defensively he was.
Click to expand...

He was turning up in 3-5 cl games a season and embarrassing himself week in week out in La Liga. He is one of the main reasons Real struggle in the league defensively. He was benched by Coentrao, benched by Real's current LB.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.